Live data from Hacker News

Cryptonomicon: Among the Bitcoin maximalists

harpers.org

31–40 of 138 posts

Re: Cryptonomicon: Among the Bitcoin maximalists

#31
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yup, classic fascist rhetoric. It's not surprising they point to a woman being independent and expressing her sexuality as the example of "degenerate culture". The "other" (people of colour, women, queers) are producing art that represents our own experiences, which is a threat to their desired white hetero-patriarchal order. Never mind that Mozart wrote a ton of filthy shit. People have been obsessed with sex foreve…

I think the comment about the music is ridiculous, but the broader point about free money causing the gradual degradation of food, housing, standard of living, etc. is not without merit.

History does not have origin in French parlors, mon ami.

Re: Cryptonomicon: Among the Bitcoin maximalists

#33
post #8

> In The Bitcoin Standard, Ammous blamed the Fed for the modern “breakdown of the family,” and for “perhaps most damagingly, the depletion of the soil of its nutrients, leading to ever-lower levels of nutrients in food.” He compared the art of the Renaissance, Classical, and Romantic periods, all financed properly with sound money, to the decadent culture of the twenty-first century, with its “animalistic noises’’ an…

Ah, so Bitcoin is just Goldbug-ism for the Age of Information.

Re: Cryptonomicon: Among the Bitcoin maximalists

#34
post #23
post #8

> In The Bitcoin Standard, Ammous blamed the Fed for the modern “breakdown of the family,” and for “perhaps most damagingly, the depletion of the soil of its nutrients, leading to ever-lower levels of nutrients in food.” He compared the art of the Renaissance, Classical, and Romantic periods, all financed properly with sound money, to the decadent culture of the twenty-first century, with its “animalistic noises’’ an…

It's not just 100 years old. It's over 1000 years old and it evolved from nothing to what we have. It's very weird that you ignore history like this. You should read up on Spain, silver, gold, china and tons of other history regarding tender. What we have with fiat is your very well working monolith fine tuned over centuries while everyone who wants to make money of of you tells you why their Nanoservice with securit…

Gold and silver coins are not fiat though.

Re: Cryptonomicon: Among the Bitcoin maximalists

#35
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the comment about the music is ridiculous, but the broader point about free money causing the gradual degradation of food, housing, standard of living, etc. is not without merit.

Degradation of food? Housing? Do you know what people ate when Bach was alive? Or in what conditions most people lived?

Well we are approaching half of americans having a chronic disease and a large part of that is from what we eat along with lack of exercise. it does seem like we have a degradation of the nutrients in our food supply as well.

https://www.fightchronicdisease.org/sites/default/files/docs...

https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/vanishing-...

Re: Cryptonomicon: Among the Bitcoin maximalists

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To those of us who are far-right, Christian, and have noticed the lack of distinction that seems to be applied between say, David Duke, and Chris Rufo, this is not the takedown-by-association you seem to think it is.

It was not intended as a take down. Thanks for clarifying. It's becoming clearer that Bitcoin is the "currency" of the far right. For those of us who consider this ideology abhorrent and counter to the ideals of a free and democratic society it's good to have that out on the table and on full display.

> It's becoming clearer that Bitcoin is the "currency" of the far right.

Does this extend to all cryptocurrencies or is it just Bitcoin?

A Ukrainian organization called 'Come back Alive' who have just been de-platformed by Patreon [0] are now turning to Bitcoin donations [1]. Does that make them far right?

Or maybe the starving Afghans who are under sanctions due to the Taliban are trying to survive by using Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies managed and accepted by NGOs helping them survive [2]. Perhaps they are all far-right too?

[0] https://blog.patreon.com/on-the-removal-of-come-back-alive

[1] https://decrypt.co/93810/patreon-suspends-ukrainian-ngo-come...

[2] https://theintercept.com/2022/01/19/crypto-afghanistan-sanct...

Re: Cryptonomicon: Among the Bitcoin maximalists

#37
post #21

That's a great read. What's striking, in his description of the conference, is the total lack of any connection to real world activity. None of these people seem to be trying to get enough Bitcoin together to build a steel mill or a wafer fab or a smartphone factory or, indeed, any kind of startup that does something. Bitcoin is expected to somehow generate wealth without actually doing anything that generates revenu…

There are actually quite a few companies doing things with bitcoin that generate revenue. Bitcoin isn't supposed to make you money; it's supposed to be money. Dollars on their own don't generate revenue, nor is gold locked in a safe. Bitcoin has qualities that make it better than fiat and better than gold, at the cost of an established history. Perhaps the author just spoke to the wrong people, didn't get the fundame…

> Spoke to the wrong people.

So either the conference didn't have the right people, or this journalist is shit at their job. Which implication do you claim?

Re: Cryptonomicon: Among the Bitcoin maximalists

#39
post #8

> In The Bitcoin Standard, Ammous blamed the Fed for the modern “breakdown of the family,” and for “perhaps most damagingly, the depletion of the soil of its nutrients, leading to ever-lower levels of nutrients in food.” He compared the art of the Renaissance, Classical, and Romantic periods, all financed properly with sound money, to the decadent culture of the twenty-first century, with its “animalistic noises’’ an…

I think the phenomenon you're observing is that the quote observes a true correlation, coincidence, or relation, but "sounds crazy" because the implication it draws is _very_ strong relative to what can probably be evidenced. In other words, it _is_ the case that Renaissance works were financed with harder money than works today. That's a historical matter of fact. It _is_ the case that families are breaking down or…

This is the classic conspiracy treadmill and subsequent dive:

See correlations that are unsettling or suggestive;

imagine causal forces which are fundamentally out of reach epistemologically, but explain the causation for the correlation which is apparent;

institutionalize the theory into a worldview;

attach your identity to it and obey in-group/out-group social maxims;

find home in only the in-group because only they tolerate your assertions with no challenge;

cement the worldview in your mind as a quasi-religious totalizing narrative because of the lack of challenges.

Re: Cryptonomicon: Among the Bitcoin maximalists

#40

An actual Bitcoin Maximalist conference is happening March 3-6 in Las Vegas. It is called the Unconfiscatable Bitcoin “not Blockchain” Conference.[0] In contrast, BTC Miami was where Ethereum was first announced. [0] https://unconfiscatable.com/

Bitcoin is unconfiscatable , but the catch is you must spend it in space
Post reply on HN