Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: Udacity dark pattern to cancel a subscription

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 77 posts

Re: Tell HN: Udacity dark pattern to cancel a subscription

#52
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I really wish there was a non-US alternative to this.

Wise let’s you do this with virtual cards - not on a per subscription basis - but you can wipe them all then get a new one.

That's good to know, didn't know Wise had virtual cards.

Re: Tell HN: Udacity dark pattern to cancel a subscription

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure I'd agree with that in this case. Knowing you are getting screwed and choosing not to do anything about it seems to be a bit different than someone that is unaware or someone attempting to stop it but just can't beat the company at their game. Blaming the latter I'd agree that would fall under victim blaming, but I don't agree with that label for the former.

These companies are using human psychology in immoral ways to victimize people. Whether a person fights back (which isn’t free) or not, they are already being victimized. Some of us do fight back, but not enough to cut into the profitability of these actions. To claim one of these victims is “part of the problem” because they lack the time or capacity to defend themselves is shameful; especially since making such a s…

If you think I'm trying to normalize this practice, then you've clearly got some wires crossed. You're riding your emotions a little hard on this one me thinks. The person that started this thread has since admittedly accepted their share of the blame.

I clearly stated it was a shitty company for doing these things. There are things in life that are difficult and shitty to have to deal with, but not dealing with them is just sticking one's head in the sand. We've all been guilty of it, at least I know I have and am on other things. It doesn't make it wrong to call me out on it. By actively not doing anything about the only thing I can control (myself), I am allowing them to prey on my $10/month.

Re: Tell HN: Udacity dark pattern to cancel a subscription

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

These companies are using human psychology in immoral ways to victimize people. Whether a person fights back (which isn’t free) or not, they are already being victimized. Some of us do fight back, but not enough to cut into the profitability of these actions. To claim one of these victims is “part of the problem” because they lack the time or capacity to defend themselves is shameful; especially since making such a s…

If you think I'm trying to normalize this practice, then you've clearly got some wires crossed. You're riding your emotions a little hard on this one me thinks. The person that started this thread has since admittedly accepted their share of the blame. I clearly stated it was a shitty company for doing these things. There are things in life that are difficult and shitty to have to deal with, but not dealing with them…

Disclaiming something doesn’t negate other actions. Everyone acknowledges there are things we can do as individuals to deal with the problem. Just because the original poster also acknowledges it doesn’t negate you claiming he is “part of the problem.” That is the essence of victim blaming, and that is what serves to normalize the aforementioned immoral behavior.

Re: Tell HN: Udacity dark pattern to cancel a subscription

#56
There is a very simple way to deal with the agent. Just don't answer any questions. Open the conversation, and then respond with "I want to cancel my subscription", no matter what they ask. If they ask if you want some other service instead, don't say "no", say that you want to cancel your subscription.

Re: Tell HN: Udacity dark pattern to cancel a subscription

#57
post #32
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Where are the companies that don't pull this shit? Netflix? Amazon?

I recently cancelled my Netflix account. Cancelling was easy enough. However about one week later, I got a churn email in the style of "Hey Ywain, here are 3 good reasons for you to ~~give us your money~~ subscribe again". I was pretty sure my account was set to not receive any kind of promotional emails, so I clicked the "Unsubscribe" link. The link asks you to login, and immediately after login it redirects you to…

When you mark an email spam you should not get another non transactional communication from them, ever

Re: Tell HN: Udacity dark pattern to cancel a subscription

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you think I'm trying to normalize this practice, then you've clearly got some wires crossed. You're riding your emotions a little hard on this one me thinks. The person that started this thread has since admittedly accepted their share of the blame. I clearly stated it was a shitty company for doing these things. There are things in life that are difficult and shitty to have to deal with, but not dealing with them…

Disclaiming something doesn’t negate other actions. Everyone acknowledges there are things we can do as individuals to deal with the problem. Just because the original poster also acknowledges it doesn’t negate you claiming he is “part of the problem.” That is the essence of victim blaming, and that is what serves to normalize the aforementioned immoral behavior.

We'll just have to agree to disagree, as I just don't feel this is victim blaming. There's a difference of saying that it is the person's fault for this happening to them, and recognizing that a shitty company is preying upon people because they allow themselves to continue to be preyed upon. It is possible to be a willing victim, at that point, the victim blaming shield is no longer applicable.

You feel differently, and that's your right. I just choose to not coddle those that choose to be the victim. They've moved into the enabling role.

Re: Tell HN: Udacity dark pattern to cancel a subscription

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It has worked plenty on me. Am I really going to make a phone call over $10 month? For months and months, no, I will not.

I'm the opposite, once you make it difficult for me to cancel a service, my resolve to be rid of you increases 10 fold. It overwhelms any discomfort making a call would put me through.

Blue Apron used this pattern. For over a year, every week I went to Google, typed in a search term that would give me a paid ad from Blue Apron, I clicked through it and made sure my next 4 weeks of meals were skipped. (Along the way, I learned there was a cancel fully online page, but it was not linked in the nav, furthering my resolve to keep doing this.)

Eventually a new CEO took over and the cancel online page appeared in the nav whereupon I canceled that way and wrote them a quick note of thanks for putting it in the nav.

Worst part was: we genuinely enjoyed the service for over a year and many of their recipes have become part of our regular menu at home. We stopped only when the recipes got somewhat repetitive and then the convenience wasn’t quite worth it. I liked and recommend it (now), but this attempt to goose the retention numbers really sat poorly with me.

Post reply on HN