Live data from Hacker News

Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations

reuters.com

511–520 of 731 posts

Re: Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations

#511

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, we do not have what you think of in terms of freedom of speech in Canada. A private corporation using their insured property to audibly harass a city and blockade streets is not considered freedom of speech in Canada. Take away their toys and let them hold a protest with their boots and parkas.

Freedom of expression features prominently in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. It is included in Section 2, which details fundamental freedoms, such as freedom of expression, freedom of association, and freedom of assembly. It strains credulity to argue that this protest somehow exceeds protest norms when bullhorns, drums, honking, and other noisemaking has been a key part of protests for decades.

Civil disobedience was always a crime. Blocking streets without a permit is a crime. Excessive noise making at all hours of the day and night is a crime. These actions don't become legal if you label them "protest".

Re: Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations

#512
post #215

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know what decade you were born in, but I have cousins aged 18 and 20 that have never been vaccinated because of their mom's political beliefs.

just because some people disagree with a policy does make it "political". I know someone that opposes seatbelt laws but that doesn't make them "political". That said I don't think it's productive to debate what "political" means.

All policy is political by definition. Also the shared etymology is a bit of a hint too. Observe thar policy-makers is used as a synonym for politicians.

Re: Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations

#513

I must be the only person here who doesn't already know about these trucking protests; I'm having trouble establishing the basic facts of what is in dispute. Who exactly is required to be vaccinated? It seems like the fraction of truckers who engaged in cross-border trucking with the US were subject to a Canadian federal vaccination mandate, which applied to some workers in the transportation sector as well as many f…

The requirement was not dropped, I'm surprised Reuters hasn't corrected that article.

https://nationalpost.com/news/politics/in-for-a-rough-winter...

https://www.bing.com/search?q=canada+trucker+vaccine+require...

Re: Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations

#514

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is being forced. If you can experience significant losses or risks unless you comply, that’s being forced. You’re being disingenuous. It’s easy to see where this breaks down - per your logic a mobster running a protection racket isn’t forcing anyone to pay extortion money either.

It's not forced. There any many jobs that don't require a vaccine. It's a choice. A protection racket is enforced through the use of physical violence. Terrible analogy.

By definition, this is forced. Force means to make someone do something against their will. In this case the choice is be fired or take the vaccine. They obviously don't want to be fired, so they are being forced to take the vaccine. Yes, it isn't physical force, but it is forced none the less.

Re: Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations

#515

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Others have already highlighted that you can be vaccinated and anti-mandate, which is what many people are focusing on. From a numbers perspective, 91.54% of Canadians 18+ have received at least one dose. 88.91% of 18+ have received two. It's /possible/ that truckers are widely unvaccinated (perhaps they all subscribe to the same train of thought), but it's unlikely.

I am vaccinated, boosted, and anti mandate. "He that would make his own liberty secure must guard even his enemy from oppression; for if he violates this duty he establishes a precedent that will reach to himself." — Thomas Paine, Dissertation on First Principles of Government (1791)

You don't have a right to cross a border and spread a deadly disease. As far as I'm aware, these truckers are allowed to work unvaccinated within their own country.

Re: Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations

#516
post #423

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As someone who works in a healthcare type field and with a nurse in the family... No, it's not overblown.

Availability of ICU beds here in Ontario has basically been flat since September, with a slight reduction recently due to Omicron: https://covid-19.ontario.ca/data/hospitalizations Furthermore, unvaccinated people are occupying fewer beds than vaccinated people in terms of numbers. Even if they all got vaccinated, we'd be basically in exactly the same place, so how do you expect vaccine mandates to help here?

The reason Ontario (and Canada in general) is doing well is because they have a much higher vaccination rate and a healthier population in general. In the US, the high numbers of hospitalization and death are overwhelmingly unvaccinated and/or extremely unhealthy individuals. Also, comparing absolute numbers is disingenuous when the vaccination rate is so high.

Re: Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations

#517

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Healthcare workers are now told to remove any indications that they work at a hospital for their own safety. This seems like a really weird narrative. Why would people who are protesting vaccine mandates be against healthcare workers? They aren't the ones keeping the mandate in place. There's a tenuous connection with them being the ones to administer a vaccine if someone decides to get vaccinated but it's not like…

Quoted post unavailable.

You do realize something like 90% of truckers have been vaccinated? It doesn't seem like they think anyone involved with the vaccine are evil...

Re: Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations

#518

I must be the only person here who doesn't already know about these trucking protests; I'm having trouble establishing the basic facts of what is in dispute. Who exactly is required to be vaccinated? It seems like the fraction of truckers who engaged in cross-border trucking with the US were subject to a Canadian federal vaccination mandate, which applied to some workers in the transportation sector as well as many f…

Quoted post unavailable.

> The organizers have demanded that the government be disbanded by the mechanism (senators and governor general dismissing the PM? wtf?) they made up out of nowhere.

In principle, couldn't the Senate force the government into a loss of supply situation triggering mandatory relinquishment of government or advice to the GG to dissolve Parliament? I mean, it wouldn't be immediate, as the timing would be based on the budget cycle, but unless I’m missing something it seems like it would be possible.

Re: Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations

#519

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm replying to someone who claimed mandates will always be political by pointing out a counter example. The covid mandate in the US at least was of adults. All of whom are at some risk (especially if you include long covid).

My point is this: If you have a vaccine its inherently non-political, its just a medical intervention. But when it becomes mandated now you introduce a process by which some people can decide for some other people what must be done. That is politics.

That is not what people generally mean by "political".

Re: Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations

#520

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Healthcare workers are now told to remove any indications that they work at a hospital for their own safety. This seems like a really weird narrative. Why would people who are protesting vaccine mandates be against healthcare workers? They aren't the ones keeping the mandate in place. There's a tenuous connection with them being the ones to administer a vaccine if someone decides to get vaccinated but it's not like…

Quoted post unavailable.

Do you live in Ottawa? I'm asking because you appear to be speaking as though you have some special insight into this. If so, perhaps sharing some video of such incidents would be helpful.
Post reply on HN