Live data from Hacker News

Covid-19 breakthrough data

coronavirus.health.ny.gov

81–90 of 180 posts

Re: Covid-19 breakthrough data

#81
post #13

Does anyone have data on boosted death rate? It is really hard to find stats. “Vaccinated” is such a difficult term because it can encompass J&J from nearly a year ago for example. I see some breakdowns by vax supplier vs hospitalizations. Really would like to know how many people who have taken the booster have died from covid ideally with age data.

Closest I've seen - https://twitter.com/zeynep/status/1482501951065661440?s=20 Source - https://www.alberta.ca/stats/covid-19-alberta-statistics.htm... The answer seems to be extremely few boosted deaths, especially under 80. You are at more risk unvaccinated in your 40s than boosted in your 80s.

Thanks! At least provides a bit of a window into what is going on

Re: Covid-19 breakthrough data

#82
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The vast majority of cases don't end up in the hospital, vaccinated or otherwise. People seem to forget this fact.

The “only 1% will die” argument, sure I remember that one from early days. But hospitals are currently overwhelmed with mostly voluntarily unvaccinated people. My advice is don’t break your arm or get in a car accident or have a heart attack right now - it could be lethal because health care resources are at a breaking point (in the US).

[dead]

Re: Covid-19 breakthrough data

#84
post #9

I wonder how under-reported mild breakthrough cases are, due to self testing? I'm fully vaccinated and boosted, and I had what I suspect is Omicron about 10 days ago. I had a mild fever (approaching, but not reaching 101), a sore throat, sneezing and nasal congestion for 3-4 days, and I tested positive with an over the counter rapid test. Overall, it was like a very minor cold. My girlfriend also tested positive, and…

Based on the positivity rate I would guess that the “official” count is off by a factor of 3-10.

I haven’t seen such absurd lines lately in NYC, but I also don’t see any compelling reason for most people to go get an official test.

Re: Covid-19 breakthrough data

#85
post #13

Does anyone have data on boosted death rate? It is really hard to find stats. “Vaccinated” is such a difficult term because it can encompass J&J from nearly a year ago for example. I see some breakdowns by vax supplier vs hospitalizations. Really would like to know how many people who have taken the booster have died from covid ideally with age data.

[deleted]

Re: Covid-19 breakthrough data

#86
post #5

Interesting that while the odds of the vaccine protecting against infection are near all-time lows (mid 70s), vaccine protection against hospitalization is near all-time highs (mid-90s). Also interesting that this data treats 14-days+ after last shot as fully vaccinated, so presumably two-shot and three-shot people are both treated as “fully vaccinated”. > Fully-vaccinated people may have received additional or boost…

That's probably essentially what you'd expect with omicron, which is more effective at immune escape but appears less effective at causing serious illness (at least in vaccinated and previously infected people).

Short of a vaccine that prevents infection isn’t this the best case scenario?

Re: Covid-19 breakthrough data

#87
post #68
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The “only 1% will die” argument, sure I remember that one from early days. But hospitals are currently overwhelmed with mostly voluntarily unvaccinated people. My advice is don’t break your arm or get in a car accident or have a heart attack right now - it could be lethal because health care resources are at a breaking point (in the US).

Truly a novel situation we find ourselves in: https://www.google.com/search?q=intitle%3Ahospitals+intitle%... https://www.google.com/search?q=intitle%3Ahospitals+intitle%...

I think activating “crisis standards of care” is a bit more substantial and worrying than any previous claims of being simply “overwhelmed” which could be subjective. This is what we are seeing here in the US.

https://www.google.com/search?q=intitle%3Ahospitals+intitle%...

Re: Covid-19 breakthrough data

#88
post #79
post #48

Figure it’s relevant to this thread - Eric Topol (very credentialed medical researcher) does a pretty good overview & summary on how the vaccines are doing. https://erictopol.substack.com/p/were-very-lucky

If there were enough vaccines for everyone around the world to get the protection equivalent of 3-shots, and people took them, the pandemic would be over now This is a very bizarre assertion. Given that, the vaccinated spread covid, even with no symptoms, vaccination status does not limit spread. No amount of vaccinated people, will end the pandemic. Note that, to spread covid, it must be replicating in the body. The…

Maybe if everyone got it all at once (and before omicron perhaps)? Idk tho these are all hypotheticals

Re: Covid-19 breakthrough data

#89

To enjoy an interesting and arguably also somewhat more accurate experience reading articles such as these, try mentally replacing the term "vaccine breakthrough" with "vaccine failure". Going to hospital is not protection.

How have you found the article to be more interesting when doing this substitution? Did you find it more accurate as well, and if so how?

Re: Covid-19 breakthrough data

#90
post #13

Does anyone have data on boosted death rate? It is really hard to find stats. “Vaccinated” is such a difficult term because it can encompass J&J from nearly a year ago for example. I see some breakdowns by vax supplier vs hospitalizations. Really would like to know how many people who have taken the booster have died from covid ideally with age data.

Closest I've seen - https://twitter.com/zeynep/status/1482501951065661440?s=20 Source - https://www.alberta.ca/stats/covid-19-alberta-statistics.htm... The answer seems to be extremely few boosted deaths, especially under 80. You are at more risk unvaccinated in your 40s than boosted in your 80s.

> You are at more risk unvaccinated in your 40s than boosted in your 80s.

At more risk from Covid19 during first eight weeks after the booster, yes.

But you're at more risk from other shit. And maybe even from Covid19 after eight weeks.

Post reply on HN