Live data from Hacker News

Hong Kong pro-democracy Stand News shuts down after police raid, arrests

reuters.com

21–30 of 74 posts

Re: Hong Kong pro-democracy Stand News shuts down after police raid, arrests

#21
post #7

15-20 years ago I naively thought that many of the Big Tech companies would stand against this type of censorship. Sadly I was wrong and didn’t understand how important it was to have access to the Chinese market and the importance of China’s low-cost manufacturing for these companies as well. Today, the Big Tech companies might not actively support this kind of censorship, but they aren’t aggressively working agains…

It's not just access to the Chinese consumer market; almost every Apple device is manufactured in China, too.

China has jurisdiction over the factories that make virtually everything that powers the US economy.

Re: Hong Kong pro-democracy Stand News shuts down after police raid, arrests

#22
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The big loophole is the provision for China's intervention in matters of "National Security". This is exactly what has been used to craft very vague language that basically allows authorities to treat anything that goes counter to China's official line as a "threat to National Security". It's so vague that self-censorship is now omnipresent in what was, just a few years ago, a bastion of freedom of speech in Asia. Ne…

UK has all means to successfully use force, and secure its gains - that's the military reality on the ground. It has an amphibious force to land a division, more with requisitioned civilian vessels, and it has thermonuclear weapons to threaten chokepoints — more than enough to get the peninsula. UK is not a small military. With mobilised territorials, and first line conscripts, it will be as much as 10-12 divisions r…

This would be the worst course of action. The Chinese population is propagandized enough and won't hesitate to go to war head-on against the West.

Re: Hong Kong pro-democracy Stand News shuts down after police raid, arrests

#23
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The big loophole is the provision for China's intervention in matters of "National Security". This is exactly what has been used to craft very vague language that basically allows authorities to treat anything that goes counter to China's official line as a "threat to National Security". It's so vague that self-censorship is now omnipresent in what was, just a few years ago, a bastion of freedom of speech in Asia. Ne…

UK has all means to successfully use force, and secure its gains - that's the military reality on the ground. It has an amphibious force to land a division, more with requisitioned civilian vessels, and it has thermonuclear weapons to threaten chokepoints — more than enough to get the peninsula. UK is not a small military. With mobilised territorials, and first line conscripts, it will be as much as 10-12 divisions r…

And risk world war 3, for Hong Kong? Never gonna happen.

Re: Hong Kong pro-democracy Stand News shuts down after police raid, arrests

#24
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quoted post unavailable.

What is propaganda about this story? Not once have I read a noticeably biased piece from Reuters. That's because they are a wire service and sell to both sides of the political spectrum (including chinese state media by the way, you'll find reuters cited as source or they use the pre-made articles from reuters' news wire) https://africa.cgtn.com/author/reuters/ or https://america.cgtn.com/anchors-corresp/reuters

When it comes to coverage of major power conflicts between USA, China, Russia, India … Reuters absolutely has the bias and perspective of the west.

Re: Hong Kong pro-democracy Stand News shuts down after police raid, arrests

#25
post #9

This is yet another violation of the Sino-British Joint Declaration, the treaty between China and the U.K. defining how Hong Kong will be handed over to China[1]: > Hong Kong would maintain its existing governing and economic systems separate from that of mainland China under the principle of "one country, two systems". The West needs to realize: China does not uphold its own treaties. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wi…

> The West needs to realize: China does not uphold its own treaties Does any major power?

Ask the Native Americans

Or these guys: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/10/world/asia/white-house-fa...

Or this: https://www.npr.org/2020/01/06/793895401/iraqi-parliament-vo...

Yet just because someone acts badly, doesn’t mean we the People should lower standards for the whole world.

Re: Hong Kong pro-democracy Stand News shuts down after police raid, arrests

#26
I don't like the "pro democrcay" thing... Isn't it more like "pro occidental/western" countries versus "pro chinese/urss/oriental" countries ?

When used that way, democracy sounds like an absolutely good thing which it is not; it's just a way to organize power...

Re: Hong Kong pro-democracy Stand News shuts down after police raid, arrests

#27
post #9

This is yet another violation of the Sino-British Joint Declaration, the treaty between China and the U.K. defining how Hong Kong will be handed over to China[1]: > Hong Kong would maintain its existing governing and economic systems separate from that of mainland China under the principle of "one country, two systems". The West needs to realize: China does not uphold its own treaties. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wi…

The big loophole is the provision for China's intervention in matters of "National Security". This is exactly what has been used to craft very vague language that basically allows authorities to treat anything that goes counter to China's official line as a "threat to National Security". It's so vague that self-censorship is now omnipresent in what was, just a few years ago, a bastion of freedom of speech in Asia. Ne…

Direct military action isn't the only recourse. It would be a pretty dangerous course of action.

There are a lot of Chinese investments in the UK that could be seized, as well as information warfare, travel restrictions, trade restrictions and Cold War style proxy wars.

Also things like giving HK BBO holders a route to British citizenship, which has high levels of support across the political spectrum and could probably be expanded further.

Re: Hong Kong pro-democracy Stand News shuts down after police raid, arrests

#28
post #26

I don't like the "pro democrcay" thing... Isn't it more like "pro occidental/western" countries versus "pro chinese/urss/oriental" countries ? When used that way, democracy sounds like an absolutely good thing which it is not; it's just a way to organize power...

Do you have a better alternative?

Re: Hong Kong pro-democracy Stand News shuts down after police raid, arrests

#29
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The big loophole is the provision for China's intervention in matters of "National Security". This is exactly what has been used to craft very vague language that basically allows authorities to treat anything that goes counter to China's official line as a "threat to National Security". It's so vague that self-censorship is now omnipresent in what was, just a few years ago, a bastion of freedom of speech in Asia. Ne…

UK has all means to successfully use force, and secure its gains - that's the military reality on the ground. It has an amphibious force to land a division, more with requisitioned civilian vessels, and it has thermonuclear weapons to threaten chokepoints — more than enough to get the peninsula. UK is not a small military. With mobilised territorials, and first line conscripts, it will be as much as 10-12 divisions r…

During the Yugoslavian war there was a stand-off between the Russians and some American troops around the Pristina airfield.

"The following morning, Sunday 13 June, Clark arrived at Jackson's HQ in Skopje. It was pointed out to Clark that the Russians were isolated and could not be reinforced by air and that Russian support had been a vital part of getting a peace agreement; antagonising them would only be counterproductive. Clark refused to accept this and continued to order that the runway be blocked, claiming to be supported by the NATO Secretary-General.[2] Jackson refused to enforce Clark's orders, reportedly telling him "I'm not going to start the Third World War for you."[5] When again directly ordered to block the runway, Jackson suggested that British tanks and armoured cars would be more suitable, in the knowledge that this would almost certainly be vetoed by the British government. Clark agreed."

What you are suggesting here is that the British would start World War III of their own accord and that Nato would follow them if they did so.

Not a chance.

Re: Hong Kong pro-democracy Stand News shuts down after police raid, arrests

#30
post #22
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

UK has all means to successfully use force, and secure its gains - that's the military reality on the ground. It has an amphibious force to land a division, more with requisitioned civilian vessels, and it has thermonuclear weapons to threaten chokepoints — more than enough to get the peninsula. UK is not a small military. With mobilised territorials, and first line conscripts, it will be as much as 10-12 divisions r…

This would be the worst course of action. The Chinese population is propagandized enough and won't hesitate to go to war head-on against the West.

It is an interesting question on how to deprogram the pro-communist party populous. All the brainwashed types I’ve ever spoken to believe the most insane things despite otherwise being intelligent people. E.g. Covid was made by the US to frame China. They also seem to conflate criticism of the CCP with Chinese people in general. I suspect many of the people behind the troll pro-China accounts commenting here are doing this (or they’re just paid). (Guys, CCP is anti-Chinese people. If you love China, don’t support this oppressive regime because one day they’ll come for you and your family.) How do we overdone this?
Post reply on HN