Live data from Hacker News

Class-action suit filed against Meta for facilitating Rohingya Genocide [pdf]

edelson.com

31–40 of 164 posts

Re: Class-action suit filed against Meta for facilitating Rohingya Genocide [pdf]

#31
post #4

Starting to wonder if the name became "Meta" so that the headlines wouldn't read "Class action suit filed against Facebook" or "Scandal involving Facebook".

I think this is overthinking it.

Mark Zuckerberg is the head of the world's most mundane tech company at the moment, so he changed the name and the focus of the company to try and dig out of this hole.

Re: Class-action suit filed against Meta for facilitating Rohingya Genocide [pdf]

#32
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How effective can such a thing be? Aren't they using the Meta keyword on all of their products now? As well as the fact it was likely all over the news, globally.

The headline didn't mention facebook, did it?

Let's see https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/28/facebook-changes-company-nam... https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/28/technology/facebook-meta-... https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-59083601

Though you have a point, I know a lot of people who don't know that Alphabet is the parent of Google.

Re: Class-action suit filed against Meta for facilitating Rohingya Genocide [pdf]

#33
post #4

Starting to wonder if the name became "Meta" so that the headlines wouldn't read "Class action suit filed against Facebook" or "Scandal involving Facebook".

"Class action suit filed against Facebook's Parent company, Meta" Easy fix. Just look at Google / Alphabet reporting.

Re: Class-action suit filed against Meta for facilitating Rohingya Genocide [pdf]

#34

Between the UN fact-finding mission saying Facebook played a “determining role” in the genocide, the Bosworth memo, and the shit ton of access we now have thanks to the whistleblower, how is this not a strong case?

I don’t see how Facebook is liable for the actions of other adults.maybe evidence comes out that Facebook actively encouraged it. But seems unlikely.

Re: Class-action suit filed against Meta for facilitating Rohingya Genocide [pdf]

#36

Between the UN fact-finding mission saying Facebook played a “determining role” in the genocide, the Bosworth memo, and the shit ton of access we now have thanks to the whistleblower, how is this not a strong case?

These all add up to a story where Facebook is doing bad things having a negative impact on the world, but that's a very different question than whether they violated any legal obligations. The plaintiff's primary theory of harm seems to be that Facebook allowed people to publish "extreme and outrageous hate speech, misinformation, and conspiracy theories", and publishing things like that would be legally protected in the US even if Mark Zuckerberg himself were the one writing them.

Re: Class-action suit filed against Meta for facilitating Rohingya Genocide [pdf]

#37
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The headline didn't mention facebook, did it?

Let's see https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/28/facebook-changes-company-nam... https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/28/technology/facebook-meta-... https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-59083601 Though you have a point, I know a lot of people who don't know that Alphabet is the parent of Google.

[deleted]

Re: Class-action suit filed against Meta for facilitating Rohingya Genocide [pdf]

#39
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why should we send American kids to die in Burma? To look tough? To redeem the “western world”? What happens after? Are we really liberating Burma for its own purpose, or just establishing American military bases in close proximity to China? It’s these kinds of neo-colonialist urges that got us into the messes in Afghanistan and Iraq. We (the US in particular but also NATO as a whole) need to stop running around the…

> To look tough? Yes, if enemies think you are not tough, you get intimidated, humiliated, and then ultimately attacked. > To redeem the “western world”? Yes, to reverse the 20 years of disgrace, and regain the mandate of righteousness. Without righteousness, you can't do anything well as a united Western bloc — a raison d'etre for the entire post-war Western political system.

From my vantage point, the wars the US gets into are solely designed to grind young American lives into windfall profits for a defense industry that prioritizes contract value over mission goals. Which is why we had no definition of success in either place.

There is no righteousness on the world stage, only exploitation. The US has simply put itself ahead of its allies too many times for the world to trust us anymore.

Re: Class-action suit filed against Meta for facilitating Rohingya Genocide [pdf]

#40

This seems kind of silly. Should radio equipment manufacturers be liable for the Rwandan genocide? I'm not fan of Facebook (I don't even have an account) but requiring them to fulfill a function that the Burmese government didn't do seems shortsighted.

When you use our special transmitters and your listeners use our special headphones, then the headphones will send an encoded signal saying their owner is more liable to be affected by broadcasts urging genocide! This allows you to use the differential broadcasting properties of our transmitter to send special commit genocide now messages to genocide ready users of our headphones while continuing to send innocuous look at this cute bunny pictures to people who will soon be killed!

Buy now, operators are standing by.

on edit: I guess it should be innocuous renditions of The Little Drummer boy to stick to the analogy, but I was momentarily taken by the little bunny idea.

Post reply on HN