Live data from Hacker News

Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online trolls

reuters.com

131–140 of 168 posts

Re: Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online trolls

#131
post #104

This is sort of off topic. >users who post defamatory comments Wouldn't that be more like Twitter Mob. Does the word "Troll" means something different in Australia, or is it the headline written by Reuter using the word "Troll" differently to what I understand, or does "Troll" means something differently in the US given Reuter is an US media. Just what is "Trolls"?

If you read the article you'll see the "standard" used to remove speech is much, much broader than "defamatory comments". >>The new legislation will introduce a complaints mechanism, so that if somebody thinks they are being defamed, bullied or attacked on social media, they will be able to require the platform to take the material down. If one merely "thinks" they are being bullied or attacked, the law will require…

How enforcable will that be on platforms that are neither owned nor hosted in Australia?

Re: Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online trolls

#132
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Australia is a highly compliant/obedient society. It’s also highly litigious, lots of fines for anything and anything. It’s the defamation capital of the world. Yes this will be enforced, it’ll be enforced selectively against critics of the current government. There is a video of the announcement with the current PM grinning and smirking in the background like a little kid when this is discussed https://www.reddit.co…

Australia litigious ? No it's not.

Yes, it absolutely is.

Re: Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online trolls

#133
post #108
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For people who arent familiar with Oz politics I'II fill in the blanks a bit to compensate for the selective partisan filter here. France was pissed of with Australia because they took a perfectly legal exit on a contract for submarines. This kind of staged contract is normal for large military tenders as once committed you are locked into an effective monopoly. So with each stage there is typically an exit path to k…

Australian exports to the European union will suffer. There will be no nuclear subs here for decades, if ever. We'll be given second hand dross before the new subs arrives., and it bears mentioning the French subs were nuclear, and retrofitted with diesel to meet this contract. The French subs need recharging. The US and UK offer are single charge for life. It's a five eyes con. We pissed off the Japanese to take the…

Great, thanks for sharing your opinion. Because thats all it is.

Re: Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online trolls

#134
post #110
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For people who arent familiar with Oz politics I'II fill in the blanks a bit to compensate for the selective partisan filter here. France was pissed of with Australia because they took a perfectly legal exit on a contract for submarines. This kind of staged contract is normal for large military tenders as once committed you are locked into an effective monopoly. So with each stage there is typically an exit path to k…

The problem wasn't that the deal was cancelled, it was that the French were blindsided and didn't know. The text message leaked by Morrison (unprecedented bullshit!), shows that the French knew of issues (which they did of course, nobody is denying this), but the day before the public announcement of Aukus were asking for news, meaning they didn't know the contract will be cancelled . Morrison is so stupid he leaked…

It astonishes me the level of expertise of some people in the comments section.

Complex defence contract negotiations, submarine technology, geo-strategic planning.

Its really quite impressive.

Re: Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online trolls

#135
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A very partisan take I think.

I think few in Australia would disagree that Scott Morrison is a liar. That was the first thing I really noticed about him even before he was PM, it's nice that the French contract is finally bringing it to the fore. It's insane. The Crikey guys came to the same conclusion I had - he doesn't just use big, strategic lies for political advantage - he lies about the small things when it's not even necessary, and they co…

No he's just on the right and youre on the left. And you dont like anyone like that. And Crikey is hardly a reputable source.

Re: Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online trolls

#136
post #120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I understand the imagery is extremely disturbing, and the worst nightmares of the idea of a concentration camp, which are actually extermination camps, is not what is being executed at the moment by the Australian government, but the fact is, it's a concentration camp all the same. The idea existed long before Nazi Germany and has been executed many places outside it since. Even if it were absolutely true that every…

> Even worse is that people I've known and respected my entire life, intelligent people … are defending, and even calling for the escalation of these tactics. It's a spectrum. More a question of temperament than intelligence: Some people desperately wish to told there's someone out there, looking out for them. A wise enlightened leader, preferably in a tie or a white lab coat. "Just follow orders and everything will…

Well said. Living through this has been a real eye opener on the nature of humanity and civil society. The veil certainly has been lifted.

Re: Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online trolls

#137

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Exactly. I used yo be a total Internet freedom proponent and that's what I want for myself but now as everybody (of whom the majority is mentally unprepared) is on Facebook I admit it makes no sense - Internet kindergartens have to be there for the people who need them (and most of these people just naturally go to places like Facebook and Instagram).

The problem with this is that the mass of clueless kindergarten attendants are fed a steady diet of complete nonsense by curated and cultivated media outlets pushing very specific self serving narratives, which these obedient clueless drones in massive hordes then go out into the world and behave politically and economically exactly as those who treated them like the wind-up toy soldiers they actually are intended. A…

A while ago I would say you are tainted, but I've watched as my group of friends increasingly parroted every corporate media talking point, even when they flip-flopped constantly about a subject. They wouldn't see a conflict there and would deflect if I tried to point that out.

Now I keep to myself and watch the patterns, and I'am ok with that it is what it is, I love my friends and I don't think less of them because of that.

Re: Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online trolls

#138

Australia’s proximity to China is maybe affecting its western ideals. This is one of many things it’s done and doing recently to make it a less free country and this can only be a slippery slope which they are already sliding on.

Besides Australia and New Zealand, are there any particularly liberal countries in that corner of the world at all? The authoritarianism of the China aligned and/or left/communist Asian countries is well understood, but what of the rest? South Korea spent much of the 20th century under military dictatorships, going from one military coup to another. Singapore's single-party system (with suspiciously fascist iconograp…

Where America went, the west asprired to. Where China goes.... In Australia, although they pretend they are standing for something different than what China stands for, the reality is that they have started down the path to similar with some of the legislation the have put in the past 5-10 years.

What is it with Murdoch backed Conservative types in the west and their love of Authoritarianism?

Re: Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online trolls

#139

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The modern definition of troll seems to be more closely related to one of the personalities that got its start at a particular notorious imageboard, who constantly posts flamebait and thrives off of pushing the limits of how much they can upset others. I haven’t seen the original more innocuous definition used in a long time.

Trolling existed on Usenet long before 4chan. https://gizmodo.com/the-first-internet-troll-1652485292

Ugh. I was an antisocial jerk trolling IRC in the early 90s. I would use shell accounts to ping flood servers and cause netsplits just so I could take control of a channel and change the topic to something dumb.

Re: Australia to introduce new laws to force media platforms to unmask online trolls

#140
post #2

>The online world should not be a wild west where bots and bigots and trolls and others are anonymously going around and can harm people I can't express how much I hate this. The online world SHOULD be a wild west, away from government reach, in my opinion.

Nonsense. The wild west led to gunslingers and bounty hunters and true progress was achieved after it was reined in.

Just because you are able to insulate yourself from all the shit that goes on ‘out there’ does not mean everyone else has to be okay with it. Some of that online trolling and hating has affected a lot of people more personally than others. Think about them too.

Post reply on HN