Live data from Hacker News

iPhone 13 teardown and repair assessment [video]

youtube.com

51–60 of 168 posts

Re: iPhone 13 teardown and repair assessment [video]

#51
post #21

I have to defend Apple for these verification checks. I bought replacement display online and replaced it myself, after I was all done found the display was fake based on bad colors. It was old iPhone which didn't have fake component detection, I traded in that phone and now somebody else has iPhone with poor display. iPhones get used for longer period of time by multiple users and they carry high resale value, if th…

There certainly is a way out of this: don't buy shitty replacements. You could still get your display replaced by a legit service before Apple introduced verifications. You might prefer that someone else takes care of your broken phone, but why'd you want to force that on everybody?

“Legit service” stores actually can get the genuine parts and software though. This mainly affects DIY repair.

Re: iPhone 13 teardown and repair assessment [video]

#52
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

An iphone can perfectly last six years.

Not without repairs.

The only thing I have ever had to have done is battery replacements and those are offered at a fair price from apple or authorised repair locations.

Re: iPhone 13 teardown and repair assessment [video]

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually its just an side advantage but deep down our heart we know apple is doing this for their own benefit not for consumers. I agree with you that every parts must be substituted with genuine parts in case of component damage. I had tried to replace s6 battery and spent like $500 but alas I failed. After 4-5 month the battery gets swollen and the backcover gets damaged costing me more. So I had to dump it and I a…

I'm not sure if things have changed, but at least a few years ago, Apple prices for display replacements were really quite fair and far below Samsung, IIRC. Something like $ 150. I'd also be interested in some statistics on the frequency of display damage. With waterproofing and these new types of glasses, I wouldn't be surprised if they had come down rather drastically. I remember every phone I having a cracked disp…

Yeah because LCD is generally cheaper than AMOLED and yes iphone screens were pretty common and replacing them is quite simple.

Re: iPhone 13 teardown and repair assessment [video]

#54
post #21

I have to defend Apple for these verification checks. I bought replacement display online and replaced it myself, after I was all done found the display was fake based on bad colors. It was old iPhone which didn't have fake component detection, I traded in that phone and now somebody else has iPhone with poor display. iPhones get used for longer period of time by multiple users and they carry high resale value, if th…

It also massively reduces the value for thieves since even the parts become worthless.

Re: iPhone 13 teardown and repair assessment [video]

#55
post #21

I have to defend Apple for these verification checks. I bought replacement display online and replaced it myself, after I was all done found the display was fake based on bad colors. It was old iPhone which didn't have fake component detection, I traded in that phone and now somebody else has iPhone with poor display. iPhones get used for longer period of time by multiple users and they carry high resale value, if th…

Except Apple also disables functionality if you replace the part with another genuine part from another iPhone. The only excuse is money, money, money.

Actually there is another good reason for this, and that is preventing theft.

What is the point of stealing an iPhone 13 if you can't just sell the phone on (because of iCloud lock) and you can't chop-shop any of the expensive parts because they're all cryptographically registered?

Re: iPhone 13 teardown and repair assessment [video]

#56
Pretty disingenuous for this guy not to mention the potential benefits of such measures, namely: iPhones become pretty much worthless on the black market, discouraging theft.

I'm more worried about someone stealing my phone (where the cost is the whole value of the device) than I am about breaking the phone (usually my fault) where the cost when repaired by Apple is fairly reasonable.

Re: iPhone 13 teardown and repair assessment [video]

#57
post #21

I have to defend Apple for these verification checks. I bought replacement display online and replaced it myself, after I was all done found the display was fake based on bad colors. It was old iPhone which didn't have fake component detection, I traded in that phone and now somebody else has iPhone with poor display. iPhones get used for longer period of time by multiple users and they carry high resale value, if th…

Except Apple also disables functionality if you replace the part with another genuine part from another iPhone. The only excuse is money, money, money.

I knew a guy who used to run one of these little repair stalls, almost all of his parts came from stripping down stolen devices he got from local scallys. These were all genuine parts, but it made stealing these phones more lucrative.

Re: iPhone 13 teardown and repair assessment [video]

#59

Paying a few hundred $ for a phone that lasts for just a couple of years never made sense in the first place. The amount of e-waste generated is insane, 'right to repair' and 'responsible use of capital and resources' go hand in hand. Phones could easily last a decade.

I would strongly argue that Apple products last longer than any other products in the market.
Post reply on HN