Live data from Hacker News

Apple and Disney among companies backing groups against US climate bill

theguardian.com

31–40 of 317 posts

Re: Apple and Disney among companies backing groups against US climate bill

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The proposed changes include a $12,000 tax rebate on buying a new electric car, weatherization incentives for homes, and will probably include sweet deals on solar panels. Where’s the inconvenience?

Only if the vehicle is built in a union shop, which the leading EV manufacturer is not. The credit is significantly reduced otherwise. Also, gas burning PHEVs (Prius) count as EVs which is such a limp handout to legacy auto and does little to push R&D forward.

Honestly, I'll never understand American politics. Linking a EV tax credit to unionisation just boggles my mind.

Re: Apple and Disney among companies backing groups against US climate bill

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The proposed changes include a $12,000 tax rebate on buying a new electric car, weatherization incentives for homes, and will probably include sweet deals on solar panels. Where’s the inconvenience?

> Where’s the inconvenience? I don't want to buy a new electric car. I have a perfectly working petrol car. Why should I subsidize some rich guy's fancy new electric toy?

Because the rest of us are subsidizing the externality of the destruction your petrol car is wreaking on the environment.

...also, given that you're calling it a "petrol" car - a Briticism - do you even live in the US? If not, you won't be the one subsidizing it in case this bill comes to pass anyway.

Re: Apple and Disney among companies backing groups against US climate bill

#33
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Opposing it means you oppose ... If life were so simple. Of course, the reality is this bill covers everything from child tax credits, paid leaves, to god knows what else.

Oh no, god forbid we try to drag ourselves into the 21st century, and get somewhere close to what every other modern democracy has offered for decades.

No other country (democracy or not) has such a huge influx of legal and illegal immigrants and a laughably porous border. The US admits more people than the populations of some these democracies that people compare the US with.

You can have a huge welfare state or open borders but not both. Unless the US invents a perpetual motion machine.

Edit: downvotes and running away, the mark of a rational mind

Re: Apple and Disney among companies backing groups against US climate bill

#34

The Build Back Better bill (or reconciliation bill) is the only real climate legislation that will plausibly be signed into law in the United States in the 2020s. It offers a meaningful path forward for the US to curb its carbon emissions. Opposing it means you oppose doing anything about mitigating the climate crisis within the United States from a federal legislative perspective within a timeframe where we can reas…

Why not just have a clean climate bill? This is just political nonsense.

Re: Apple and Disney among companies backing groups against US climate bill

#35

The Build Back Better bill (or reconciliation bill) is the only real climate legislation that will plausibly be signed into law in the United States in the 2020s. It offers a meaningful path forward for the US to curb its carbon emissions. Opposing it means you oppose doing anything about mitigating the climate crisis within the United States from a federal legislative perspective within a timeframe where we can reas…

This bill isn’t a focused climate or infrastructure bill. That’s the marketing dressing for a widely scoped bill where only 23% of spending is for infrastructure. In actuality it includes many radically left-leaning policies, which moderates on neither side of the aisle can support. A prominent example is that it included changes to immigration that would grant citizenship for 8 million illegal immigrants, which luck…

I have never heard this particular angle on this bill, and would hope that it's wrong. Can someone confirm/deny with some references?

Re: Apple and Disney among companies backing groups against US climate bill

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh no, god forbid we try to drag ourselves into the 21st century, and get somewhere close to what every other modern democracy has offered for decades.

No other country (democracy or not) has such a huge influx of legal and illegal immigrants and a laughably porous border. The US admits more people than the populations of some these democracies that people compare the US with. You can have a huge welfare state or open borders but not both. Unless the US invents a perpetual motion machine. Edit: downvotes and running away, the mark of a rational mind

https://www.amazon.com/Open-Borders-Science-Ethics-Immigrati...

Re: Apple and Disney among companies backing groups against US climate bill

#38
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So its not revenue neutral.

Revenue neutral doesn't mean you can't increase taxes. It just means the funding isn't based on borrowing.

"Revenue neutral" just means a bill will not increase government revenues.

edit : You can downvote me all you want, it isn't going to change the definition of the term.

https://definitions.uslegal.com/r/revenue-neutral/

Re: Apple and Disney among companies backing groups against US climate bill

#39

The Build Back Better bill (or reconciliation bill) is the only real climate legislation that will plausibly be signed into law in the United States in the 2020s. It offers a meaningful path forward for the US to curb its carbon emissions. Opposing it means you oppose doing anything about mitigating the climate crisis within the United States from a federal legislative perspective within a timeframe where we can reas…

If this is true then maybe the fault lies partially with the bad-faith legislators who have stuffed the bill with a Christmas wish-list of items that suit their agenda but have nothing to do with climate change, thus making it harder for the bill to pass?

While this sounds truthy, would be even better if you have refs on what's been stuffed in.

Re: Apple and Disney among companies backing groups against US climate bill

#40
post #7

The Build Back Better bill (or reconciliation bill) is the only real climate legislation that will plausibly be signed into law in the United States in the 2020s. It offers a meaningful path forward for the US to curb its carbon emissions. Opposing it means you oppose doing anything about mitigating the climate crisis within the United States from a federal legislative perspective within a timeframe where we can reas…

So its not revenue neutral.

Neither are all the giant tax cuts that have been passed since Bush Jr. or defense spending.
Post reply on HN