Live data from Hacker News

Arm China Has Gone Rogue

semianalysis.substack.com

611–620 of 686 posts

Re: Arm China Has Gone Rogue

#611

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can steal your way to the top. It worked for the greeks. It worked for the mongols. Arguably it worked for the spanish and british. I dont see the free market holding back authoritarian takeovers. At some point the west will wake up but when they do, is it too late?

And it worked and is working for the US.

Almost every country has a dark side with slavery. Slavery however was not what made empires.

What makes empires different is that they extracted the riches from lamds abroad, thru violence (stealing) which often meant war, murder, and pillaging. Usually this was followed by slavery. Slavery itself was often transactional consequence between to original human traffiker and the idiot buyer.

The US was a global power before it went on military adventurism. It can be argued whether the US could have become a world power without slavery, but that line of question can be leveled to any other country with significant power today.

The US became a global power and incredibly rich , in spite of its government only deciding to stick its nose abroad starting around the 1960s.

The US may have done pretty dark things abroad in the last 50-60 years. But thats when it really starts. And by that time, we had already a monopoly on world power.

If anything, the US has proven that it's technique for stealing to keep its advantage has been incredibly ineffective and downright inept (cuba, vietnam, arguably Afghanistan)

This is unlike china, that steals as a matter of national policy, and its stealing its way to the top

Re: Arm China Has Gone Rogue

#612
post #610
post #608

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The effect in question was discovered by a German two decades earlier Oh hey, you're right. So Bose only invented the use of the effect for radio, not the Schottky diode itself. I stand corrected. > ?????? We're not talking about pseudoscience here. Mercury distillation is not pseudoscience; like glassblowing, it was an existing technology that was a basis for the vacuum-tube age. Of course, if you trace any techno…

1) Chemistry and physics has nothing to do with the pseudoscience of ayurveda, and vice versa. 2) Even if somehow you could make the connection (which I still strongly doubt since I haven't seen the these Ancient Indian vacuum pumps in museums any more than I've seen a vimana in a museum), it still would be hardly relevant since it would be the same connection as between a car and a screwdriver. A screwdriver can be…

Probably you'll have a different perspective about the significance of screwdrivers once you learn a little more about the history of technology.

To correct one misreading on your part, though, my claim was that the technology of distillation was developed in India (or possibly China), not the Sprengel pump. I too would be very surprised to find a medieval Sprengel pump from India or anywhere else.

I'm curious: would you also be so foolish as to claim that chemistry and physics have nothing to do with the pseudosciences of phlogiston, numerology, astrology, and alchemy? How about the steady-state theory of cosmology?

Re: Arm China Has Gone Rogue

#613
post #612
post #610

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1) Chemistry and physics has nothing to do with the pseudoscience of ayurveda, and vice versa. 2) Even if somehow you could make the connection (which I still strongly doubt since I haven't seen the these Ancient Indian vacuum pumps in museums any more than I've seen a vimana in a museum), it still would be hardly relevant since it would be the same connection as between a car and a screwdriver. A screwdriver can be…

Probably you'll have a different perspective about the significance of screwdrivers once you learn a little more about the history of technology. To correct one misreading on your part, though, my claim was that the technology of distillation was developed in India (or possibly China), not the Sprengel pump. I too would be very surprised to find a medieval Sprengel pump from India or anywhere else. I'm curious: would…

A vacuum tube is not based on "distillation" of anything. It operates with charge carriers in vacuum, with no phase change of any masses involved, whereas distillation involves liquid/gas transitions so it can't possibly have anything to do with the operation of a vacuum tube which is based on an arrangement of solid electrodes in a vacuum and the flow of charge carriers between them. As for the history of technology, I'm moderately familiar with it and I don't see the relevance here. If absolutely everything you touch when creating something were relevant for the question of "Have you an example of a western invention not based on existing technology?", then not only would the answer be "there isn't any", but as a corollary, one would have to conclude that there is NO example of ANY invention from ANYWHERE that isn't based on existing technology. Clearly that doesn't seem to be the intended reading of that question.

Re: Arm China Has Gone Rogue

#614
post #102

I wish the author can learn some Chinese before writing this article. And the related Chinese news was already there last year. The thing is the pure ARM internal political conflicts. ARM China CEO WU, a US citizen, claimed that he reported few high-level managers' corruptions and then he got fired by the ARM Softbank. ARM Softbank united with all board directors, including all Chinese investors, to fire Wu. But when…

Source please? Those are extraordinary claims.

Chinese is totally fine.

Re: Arm China Has Gone Rogue

#615
post #613
post #612

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Probably you'll have a different perspective about the significance of screwdrivers once you learn a little more about the history of technology. To correct one misreading on your part, though, my claim was that the technology of distillation was developed in India (or possibly China), not the Sprengel pump. I too would be very surprised to find a medieval Sprengel pump from India or anywhere else. I'm curious: would…

A vacuum tube is not based on "distillation" of anything. It operates with charge carriers in vacuum, with no phase change of any masses involved, whereas distillation involves liquid/gas transitions so it can't possibly have anything to do with the operation of a vacuum tube which is based on an arrangement of solid electrodes in a vacuum and the flow of charge carriers between them. As for the history of technology…

You can't make a Sprengel pump without distilling your mercury (it doesn't work if the mercury sticks to the walls of the tubes and leaves crap all over them), and you can't make a vacuum tube without some kind of hard vacuum pump, and, as I pointed out above, the Sprengel pump was the only kind of hard vacuum pump available for decades. (I already explained all of this fairly clearly in previous comments, such as https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28333304.) In fact, the invention of the Sprengel pump produced an explosion of inventions and discoveries, of which the so-called Edison effect was only one.

I do think that that there is no example of any invention from anywhere that isn't based on existing technology, including specifically existing technology invented on other continents, and my reading of the question was that it was intended to make precisely that point, thus concisely pointing out the ignorant fallacy at the heart of the original racist bullshit comment, "I can think of nothing unique, only modification of existing inventions."

Re: Arm China Has Gone Rogue

#616
post #615
post #613

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A vacuum tube is not based on "distillation" of anything. It operates with charge carriers in vacuum, with no phase change of any masses involved, whereas distillation involves liquid/gas transitions so it can't possibly have anything to do with the operation of a vacuum tube which is based on an arrangement of solid electrodes in a vacuum and the flow of charge carriers between them. As for the history of technology…

You can't make a Sprengel pump without distilling your mercury (it doesn't work if the mercury sticks to the walls of the tubes and leaves crap all over them), and you can't make a vacuum tube without some kind of hard vacuum pump, and, as I pointed out above, the Sprengel pump was the only kind of hard vacuum pump available for decades. (I already explained all of this fairly clearly in previous comments, such as ht…

Again,

1) the tools are traditionally not a part of the invention,

2) by referring to distillation as a prerequisite for the mercury vacuum pump operation, you're referring to a tool twice removed from the invention in question, and

3) even mercury distillation itself is not based on ayurveda anyway. It's based on physics.

Re: Arm China Has Gone Rogue

#617
post #296

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And Airbus. An incredible number of people working at Airbus Tianjin factory went to work at Comac.

In California, we celebrate workers' rights to move between companies, and have made non-compete clauses unenforceable.

That's not what I'm talking about. Notice that Airbus started assembling A320 planes in China (under Chinese pressure), then Comac was founded, most of Chinese people working at Airbus went to Comac 1000 km away to build an A320 clone. This isn't simply a case of people "freely switching jobs". Particularly not in light of blatant and repeated Chinese espionage of incredible breadth in France going on for years and years:

2011: https://www.lefigaro.fr/actualite-france/2011/10/12/01016-20...

2014: https://www.nouvelobs.com/societe/20141204.OBS7033/comment-l...

2015: https://www.liberation.fr/futurs/2015/02/16/l-espionnage-chi...

2018: https://www.capital.fr/economie-politique/la-france-visee-pa... https://www.businessinsider.fr/des-espions-chinois-ont-ete-a...

2019: https://rmc.bfmtv.com/emission/expliquez-nous-quand-le-contr...

2020: https://www.leparisien.fr/faits-divers/l-improbable-trahison...

Re: Arm China Has Gone Rogue

#618
post #599

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How many Muslims has America sterilized and brainwashed?

I don't have the numbers on Muslims, but here you go: https://en.mundohispanico.com/the-uterus-collector-sterilize... You've probably already thought of multiple excuses, because you've been conditioned not to think of immigrants in concentration camps as people.

How about you don't make assumptions about who you're talking to?

Re: Arm China Has Gone Rogue

#619

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not sure how did you get the idea that the market was not there. Arm China had stellar financial results. Arm holding, with 49% share of the company, has significant upside to gain from the market. And this fiasco is partly a misconduct of Mr. Wu, showing no signs of being directed by Chinese investors. And partly because of Trump's tech ban, which obviously affect arm China's prospect. And then this statement: > I b…

"Arm China had stellar financial results. Arm holding, with 49% share of the company, has significant upside to gain from the market." This is because clients and accounts that previously belonged to Arm had to be handed over to Arm China if Arm wanted to continue doing any business with Chinese firms, regardless of whether they'd actually courted their business. This is like picking your left pocket and arguing that…

Did you read the post?

This is so that they can listed on the public market.

There were no evidence that this joint venture was mandated.

And this joint venture happened after Softbank took over arm. And of course, Softbank thinks they can manage the listing process.

Re: Arm China Has Gone Rogue

#620
post #336

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Closing off and turning inwards"? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative

Viewed through the lens of the original Silk Road, the "closing off and turning inwards" trend is consistent with an increasingly Middle Kingdom posture. China is the center of the world in this posture, and in a very nearly literal sense all roads lead to China with BRI. It also neatly dovetails with asserting greater, more finely-granular political and social control the leadership desires (from which all other pow…

You’re right, it’s an uninformed perspective. You’re starting with a conclusion of what the Chinese government’s intent is and then trying to find a way to fit the facts into that narrative.
Post reply on HN