Live data from Hacker News

Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes

github.com

331–340 of 352 posts

Re: Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes

#331

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the 1940s and 1950s radio programs and eventually television shows were sponsored by advertisers. soap operas get their name for being vehicles for soap companies. Off the top of my head Fitch's soap company was a big advertiser in the 40s. Another big advertiser in the forties and fifties was rexall. I don't know what the return on investment was, I always figured they did it as a way to show that they supported…

I've long known this, but not how they used it to advertise -- was it product placement, pre-roll, being the only mid-roll adverts??

Each show i listen to generally will have a primary sponser, who writes the show "headline song" and generally that sponsor will write lyrics to make that a jingle that has to do with their product.

Then you get the intro to the show, and sometimes a product spot. Then the show starts, and depending on the format (half hour, multi-part 12 minute, etc) you may get a mid-roll and finally at the end a final sponsor message, plus the studio (like CBS) would pitch other shows on their network, and the star of the show would also have their current movies and other productions pitched at the end, as well.

Check out Richard Rogue on OTRR or archive.org for both styles, the mid-roll and the post-intro roll with jingle, it varies depending on year of production. Their main sponsor was Fitch, as far as i can tell.

Re: Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes

#332
post #189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s annoying that this has been downvoted because having your identity in easily-readable files on your computer is literally worse than saving passwords in a text file: Passwords will prompt 2FA, notifications and whatnot; Cookies might just work, albeit temporarily.

While I see the problem with malicious applications pillaging your users home directory, let's not forget that being able to tinker and hack together things is also one of the greatest strengths of the desktop platform.

Yes please keep storing your passwords on the desktop just because the desktop platform is so great.

Your reasoning makes zero sense. You can keep the platform strong and still keep some information safe, no?

WTF HN

Re: Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes

#333

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Are the sponsor parts really so bad? Yes. Some of us don't like being assaulted with sales pitches everywhere we look.

Maybe these creators should post sponsor-free versions of their videos on Patreon? If you are watching for free, and you're that annoyed by ads, then maybe you just feel entitled.

> If you are watching for free, and you're that annoyed by ads, then maybe you just feel entitled.

If the the content is there, I'll watch it; if it's not, I won't. I certainly don't feel entitled to it.

If anything, the sense of entitlement seems to be emanating firmly from the people who upload the videos: they seem to think that because they upload videos, they are entitled to make money from them. Sorry, no.

Re: Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes

#334

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Map Men do great sponsor parts, actually entertaining to watch. I find the same with christmas adverts each year - I don’t do tv, but go out of my way to watch the adverts and get in the festive mood come December.

I find their sponsor parts to be obnoxious enough to deter from watching their videos when a new one comes out :/

Luckily they're at the end of the video, and I believe your opinion is the minority.

Re: Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes

#335

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'll add another wrinkle: I like content-creators that create for the love of doing it and not to try and turn it into a business. When I follow a YouRuber (I'm borrowing that typo, I like it) and have seen them descend into the paid/promotional arena, I have been turned off and stopped subscribing to their channel. Advertising tends to naturally weed out, for me, the ones who are not as passionate about what they do…

Preface: I am a Youtuber who prefers not to do sponsored segments but has done some in the past. > Advertising tends to naturally weed out, for me, the ones who are not as passionate about what they do. This is a remark I see over and over again, basically "You're only in it for the money" once you do sponsors. Here's the thing that no one really gets, Youtube is not a hobby. I don't care what the channel topic is, b…

> Youtube is not social media, we're not posting videos so our friends can see what we're up to.

Speak for yourself. I post videos on Youtube to show some low hundreds of people (including friends) that are subscribed to me what I'm up to, to give them a good laugh or to share some music, art or software I've made. No one owes it to me to elevate this hobby into a job. There are many Youtube channels like this.

Maybe if I had a million subscribers the urge to attract people with youtube-faced thumbnails and to monetize through shitty mobile game sponsorships would be overwhelming but I'd like to believe that I wouldn't be pissed off if people opted to mechanically skip the latter.

> So if nobody used adblock I could make literally double the amount on just the on platform ads alone.

If people didn't have access to clean water on tap, I could make more money selling bottled water.

Re: Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes

#336

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Map Men do great sponsor parts, actually entertaining to watch. I find the same with christmas adverts each year - I don’t do tv, but go out of my way to watch the adverts and get in the festive mood come December.

The only adverts I actually unskip (using SponsorBlock normally) are those by InternetHistorian.

You should check out Internet Comment Etiquette then.

Re: Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes

#337
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Are the sponsor parts really so bad? To me not only is it easy to skip, I want indie people to make enough money to produce high quality content; otherwise media is just what a few biggies want to fund. In my experience, it's the same with ads everywhere else. It (usually) starts out not being overly obnoxious, with just a "this video is sponsored by [garbage tier mobile game/earphones/vpn/whatever] more about them…

Map Men do great sponsor parts, actually entertaining to watch. I find the same with christmas adverts each year - I don’t do tv, but go out of my way to watch the adverts and get in the festive mood come December.

Bill burr on his podcast is also good. He usually spends the segment making fun of the companys or getting off topic mid read ranting about something else. Hes mentioned hes had a few companies demand refunds afterwards.

Re: Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes

#338

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Great link! Do you think it is fair to say the YouTube Premium payout model is similar to the music streaming platform, Spotify? At the risk of nerd sniping myself, thinking deeper, I wonder if people who sign up for YouTube Premium do less random surfing on YouTube and instead focus on a few channels they love? That would _further_ concentrate their payouts. If true, then the 10x figure sounds reasonable.

Nope. Spotify divides the whole subscription revenue per content's share in total time being played, thus it doesn't matter if you listen exclusively to some garage band - your money would go to whatever pop is now topping.

Well not really because you up the count for the garage band you're listening to. Quick calculation shows this model gives more influence on the repartirion of money to those who listen to the most music, even though they pay the same (as compared to YouTube's that gives the same budget to everyone)

Re: Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes

#339

I pay for YouTube premium, but this beautiful piece of software automatically strips out the commercials from the videos and it seems I can download any video from YouTube even without logging in. My question is the following: What is benefit of setting my credentials to the config file?

My friend downloaded whole of Pluralsight's database using yt-dl. Config files are necessary for sites that require the user to access the content.

Re: Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes

#340
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

youtube-dl has been inactive for the last 2 months. Most things still work but support of different services is something that needs daily updates to not break. Even if most popular websites still work, pages like Newgrounds are breaking. There's 3.7k open issues right now and nothing gets merged [0]. [0] https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl/issues

But still, why a fork? Why not contribute to the original project? Why not ask for maintainership if you need it?

Asking is meaningless if nobody answers.
Post reply on HN