Live data from Hacker News

Elementary OS 6 Odin

blog.elementary.io

201–210 of 321 posts

Re: Elementary OS 6 Odin

#202

- Can't publish closed-source apps on their AppCenter. "To ensure reproducible builds, transparency, and auditability, binaries cannot be uploaded or included alongside the source code to be installed on users' devices." So that precludes my apps, and probably most other devs I know. I'd guess because of this restriction, their app store is going nowhere as a business. - Their 70/30 split is higher than what Apple cu…

One way to "fix" this IMO would be to allow proprietary apps, but keeping the 30/70 split for those to account for increased monitoring and having them confined by the same flatpak permissions as everything else, and lowering the split to 12/88 for open source apps.

Re: Elementary OS 6 Odin

#203
post #165
post #3

Elementary is great, the couple times I've tried it, I wasn't into the desktop paradigm it was encouraging me to use (e.g., no minimize button, native apps that are pretty and consistent but less functional). Will look forward to giving it another spin. Having recently begun using a Mac for the first time, and after having had to suffer with Win10 for a few years, I have to say that I didn't appreciate that several o…

> Ubuntu [...] never does anything I don't expect. Especially when it comes to finder/explorer/nautilus. You expect typing letters while having the file explorer window focused to launch a full recursive file search?

For what it's worth, I discovered this feature on accident because I naturally expected it to do that.

Re: Elementary OS 6 Odin

#204
I really like elementary and the ecosystem-like, but open approach they're taking to desktop linux.

One aspect of it I feel often goes underappreciated is how lightweight it is. Provided you have a reasonable amount of RAM for the tasks you're trying to do, e.g. 4GB+ for normal desktop usage and an SSD, you can run it on fairly old CPUs and it will be blazing fast still.

Congrats to the team!

Re: Elementary OS 6 Odin

#205
post #190

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For me macOS design peaked when they moved from the super readable Lucida Grande to Helvetica Neue because it looked hot on retina displays. I'm not sure which version that was exactly. Purely from a visual standpoint I like the Big Sur redesign way more than I expected. It looks like it was made for dark mode, unlike previous versions where dark mode was kind of an add on. The whole material/translucency thing is re…

The trouble with Lucida Grande was that it didn't have an Italic variant. Which was a bit of a glaring oversight for a default font

Ha, I had no idea. That's kind of a problem, yeah. They REALLY fixed that with San Francisco which has, by my count, a crazy 18 cuts across 8 variants, counting only generic sans serifs.

Re: Elementary OS 6 Odin

#206

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right, a feature which will be very limiting for their store as a business.

But very good for the user, no?

If a mostly empty store is good for the user, then yes. Definitely a store free of many advanced apps with valuable IP.

Re: Elementary OS 6 Odin

#207

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not being able to publish closed-source apps is a feature.

Programmers have got to be the only people who think giving away hard, creative work for free is the only right way to do things. We all gotta eat and programs take time and expertise to build and maintain. Wouldn’t you like to be able to make a living from something you built rather than having a boss and working for a company where your future will never be in your control? I sure would. If people can pay for liter…

Movies don't tend to be able to spy on you, for one. Nor are they generally expected to be maintained over time.

Re: Elementary OS 6 Odin

#208

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right, a feature which will be very limiting for their store as a business.

But very good for the user, no?

As a user I am usually disappointed by open source software when paid alternatives exist (adobe CC, games, office, 3d CAD) with few exceptions (blender), so no.

Re: Elementary OS 6 Odin

#209

This is a big update for a relatively small community distro. Kudos to the team. A summary of some of the cooler features: Performance: General performance improvements on all hardware resulting from optimizing for Pinebook Pro and Raspberry Pi - namely, reducing and asynchronizing inter-process communication between desktop components, removing unused code, and reducing disk I/O. Firmware: Linux Vendor Firmware Serv…

"- Startup is intentionally non-Elementary-branded, better enabling OEM/Vendor branded startup splash screen — "we don’t need to constantly advertise your operating system to you"."

Dang, I really like their logo and it sorta feels nice to see it on bootup. I'm sure there is some way to bring it back though, and it's a tiny thing that, like they said, will probably be far outweighed by the benefit it brings to OEMs.

Re: Elementary OS 6 Odin

#210
post #76

I love the look and feel of elementary, but I'm always skeptical of trying new Linux DEs. I want them to work well, and they often do, but 4K and scaling support is very hit or miss with the ones I've used. I'm currently using Gnome and not impressed at all, just settling on it. Does anyone have experience with other DEs recently with this? Either KDE or Pantheon, or something else? I just want good 4K support and sc…

Do you need a DE? Linux is my daily driver for work and home. I've tried DEs and found them bloated and slow. I have been using i3-wm for years and loving it. You can always use picom compositor on top to mitigate visual glitches.
Post reply on HN