Live data from Hacker News

After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullying, Google promoted him

morningbrew.com

61–70 of 349 posts

Re: After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullying, Google promoted him

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

“I crush people” is an unacceptable attitude for a manager to take regarding his own employees. Whether those employees can handle that sort of counterproductive adversity is irrelevant.

We don't live in a utopia. There are going to be people that say and do things that you dislike; That's reality. Instead of running to an authority figure to complain every time you encounter adversity, like a child, people need to learn to handle those situations...like adults. Someone acting mean or making an off color comment like this are a fact of life. No amount of safe spaces and down voting inconvenient truth…

I would probably handle the situation like an adult. By quitting. People dealing with the consequences of their actions are a fact of life.

I want my place of work to be a safe pace and I'm not ashamed to admit it. If I want to confront somebody's tamper tantrum I'd... do exactly what I'm doing right now, really.

Re: After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullying, Google promoted him

#62

I see a lot of people saying this seems not a big deal, or that his leadership deserved promotion. It’s because this is a second order article. The original, most substantive source that I could find is quite thorough: https://archive.is/wqdkF > "He would ask us to do personal things for him," one of these people said. "He said, 'I need you to write a briefing for me on Russian history and politics.' [...] We had abs…

The complaints in the article sound ridiculous. He wrote "the F* word" in an email? He fired people? He sometimes got angry?

Maybe he just is a human being. People seem to feel entitled to godlike father figures as bosses now, who pamper them all the way in their comfy 9 to 5 jobs?

Not saying you should scream at your employees, but humans can get angry and in general are not perfect. If it is too much for you, quit.

I wonder how far Steve Jobs would have come if he only stared out today? I've heard he also made people cry.

Re: After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullying, Google promoted him

#63
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's personal because it's not work-related. He would demand people do random, pointless tasks for him to show dominance.

Demanding random, pointless tasks from subordinates is a bad sign, but the Russia example might not be one of those. If a boss needs information s/he can ask a subordinate to make a brief. Sometimes the reasoning behind the important request is not clear to the subordinate and it might seem pointless. A good boss would generally explain, but failing to do it is still very very far from bullying (plus, some important…

Well, I write software. If you randomly ask me to write a brief history of Japanese factories, I’m going to be like wtf. You’re going to have to explain yourself.

I won’t do it for the Elongated Muskrat himself.

Re: After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullying, Google promoted him

#64
post #8

I feel like this story is overblown. He was clearly a bad manager. From what I can gather, he was placed on leave after an investigation and then moved to a policy position where he does not manage anyone. Calling it a promotion is pure spin.

At my old company it was a bit of a joke, you would repeatedly see shit managers become "architect"s. Management were too cowardly to get rid of bad managers, so they were forced to promote them to get them out of their role. So managers who were shit technically constantly ended up with senior technical titles - and everyone knew why.

Re: After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullying, Google promoted him

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quite a lot of people drop out of Oxford because it's an intense high-pressure environment. It may not have been out of choice, even if he's portraying it that way

Only 1.3 percent of students drop out of Oxford, versus 7.4 percent for the UK. https://www.ox.ac.uk/about/facts-and-figures/full-version-fa... Not at all like America where only 1/3 graduate.

In elite schools [edit: that are as elite as] Oxford, the drop out rate would be close to Oxford's. The US numbers are pretty skewed by the massive drop out rate in 2-year community colleges, which both admit huge numbers of people and have very high dropout rates. Also, a huge percentage of dropouts are in the first year, when people are deciding that college may not work for them or be the right fit.

Re: After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullying, Google promoted him

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why is writing about Russia a personal thing? I think I will need more context to understand this.

It's personal because it's not work-related. He would demand people do random, pointless tasks for him to show dominance.

Then subordinates must show their dominance not doing useless work. I've been in meetings in which I'm the one screaming to my boss in the face. When another boss tried to make me look bad with our superiors, I showed them their ineptitude and bully behavior. A few times had to quit a job due to the toxic environment, but always got more interesting and rewarding jobs. Never felt guilty about crushing a bully.

Re: After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullying, Google promoted him

#67
post #17

> "Employees said Suleyman encouraged them to use private chat groups on Signal and Telegram for work conversations, some of which were set up to automatically delete messages after a set period. Employees were also on occasion asked to delete messages from their phones, a former employee said. They were also told to notify the group once they had done so. > "Mustafa was super paranoid about Google spying on him, so…

Whenever I've encountered managers refusing to use company-provided communications for company work, it's one of two explanations: (Note these apply specifically to managers communicating with their teams. I'm not including ICs who just prefer to not use company comms) 1) Leadership has developed a reputation for routinely reading people's private communications. Specifically, not just for investigating specific even…

That second anecdote is absurd in its ridiculousness. What a crazy person that guy must have been!

Re: After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullying, Google promoted him

#68

I see a lot of people saying this seems not a big deal, or that his leadership deserved promotion. It’s because this is a second order article. The original, most substantive source that I could find is quite thorough: https://archive.is/wqdkF > "He would ask us to do personal things for him," one of these people said. "He said, 'I need you to write a briefing for me on Russian history and politics.' [...] We had abs…

The complaints in the article sound ridiculous. He wrote "the F* word" in an email? He fired people? He sometimes got angry? Maybe he just is a human being. People seem to feel entitled to godlike father figures as bosses now, who pamper them all the way in their comfy 9 to 5 jobs? Not saying you should scream at your employees, but humans can get angry and in general are not perfect. If it is too much for you, quit.…

Toxic work environments are just a breeding ground for lawsuits and expose anyways

Re: After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullying, Google promoted him

#69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

“I crush people” is an unacceptable attitude for a manager to take regarding his own employees. Whether those employees can handle that sort of counterproductive adversity is irrelevant.

We don't live in a utopia. There are going to be people that say and do things that you dislike; That's reality. Instead of running to an authority figure to complain every time you encounter adversity, like a child, people need to learn to handle those situations...like adults. Someone acting mean or making an off color comment like this are a fact of life. No amount of safe spaces and down voting inconvenient truth…

@munchler

I did read what you wrote, I meant to reply to the commenter below. As for your point, clearly the higher ups at Google disagree.

Re: After DeepMind’s cofounder was placed on leave for bullying, Google promoted him

#70
post #42

Don’t care about this guy, but why would they think that changes in the reporting hierarchy means a promotion? If my boss leaves then I would report to my skip in the interim and in many companies that’s forever. So just because there’s nobody between me and my skip I got promoted? That’s the most dumb rationale I have ever read. This guy was already the head of a prominent Alphabet division. If you move him around t…

So becoming a VP doesn't qualify as a promotion but going from VP to SVP does?

Becoming a VP can certainly be a promotion, but depending on the corporation being a VP is just a nice high-level title to give to someone too valuable to fire while you put them outside of the main structure. So, it's a promotion in title but a demotion in duties/authority so it doesn't feel bad to the person.
Post reply on HN