Live data from Hacker News

Tahoe's hiring crisis is unraveling small businesses during its busiest season

sfgate.com

81–90 of 170 posts

Re: Tahoe's hiring crisis is unraveling small businesses during its busiest season

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>>>If you need to hold hunger and homelessness over people’s heads in order to make them work, maybe your system is morally bankrupt? You mean the human condition? Life has always been this way and since we're not a post-scarcity society yet I don't see how any workable system would not be morally bankrupt by this standard.

> we're not a post-scarcity society yet How can we be sure that we aren't? Or rather, how will we ever be able to tell whether we are living in a post-scarcity society, when artificial scarcity is imposed by those with political power? We don't have true scarcity in housing. What we have is artificial constraints on building being imposed by the state. We also don't have scarcity in basic foodstuffs. There's plenty o…

> Capitalist market economies are usually very efficient at allocating such resources

Sure, as long as "efficient" means "most aligns with the desires of capital".

Re: Tahoe's hiring crisis is unraveling small businesses during its busiest season

#82

Honestly, I think this is good for Tahoe in the long run. The NIMBYs who constantly block development are getting a taste of their own medicine. When they’re finally fed up with the low staff and poor service they’ll see the need for affordable housing.

When I watched the movie Elysium, I always wondered where the restaurant workers, hotel housekeepers, and other service workers on the station lived. Maybe it was all automated. If the rich want to have these rich-only enclaves, they're gonna need to learn how to be a little more self sufficient.

Re: Tahoe's hiring crisis is unraveling small businesses during its busiest season

#83
post #24

“ Those who beat the real estate curve and bought property for their employees to live in before home prices skyrocketed are faring much better on the hiring front than their comrades.” So we are returning to factory towns? It seems the only solution is the cap rental prices, which traditionally doesn’t work. Maybe the city should be buying at the housing and providing it?

The solution is to not interfere in the market.

I would agree with you typically, but it seems in this case in Tahoe, if you don’t interfere in the market, the businesses will eventually either go out of business, or the economy will stagnate. Property owners are not willing to lower their price, why should they? Businesses can only raise the money they’re willing to offer so much. They could raise prices but then you run into a tipping point where people say you know Tahoe is just too expensive to get a sandwich. Eventually it’s a race to the top, but the top is a cliff.

I guess the businesses could close and people could just stop going to Tahoe all together.

Re: Tahoe's hiring crisis is unraveling small businesses during its busiest season

#84

“ Those who beat the real estate curve and bought property for their employees to live in before home prices skyrocketed are faring much better on the hiring front than their comrades.” So we are returning to factory towns? It seems the only solution is the cap rental prices, which traditionally doesn’t work. Maybe the city should be buying at the housing and providing it?

> Maybe the city should be buying at the housing and providing it? We do this in New York. It’s pork for politicians.

Really? I thought companies owning the housing of their workforce to be a terrible thing because it could easily lead to abuse, and more likely than not will. I didn’t know that governments were already doing this… That’s depressing.

Re: Tahoe's hiring crisis is unraveling small businesses during its busiest season

#85

>> "Wilderotter starts his employees at $20 an hour." That's the entire problem. Everything is tied to pay. The reality is that nobody can get good labor, let alone good skilled labor, at 20$/hour. If your business model can only work by paying minimal wages then your businese model has failed. Labor costs, wage expectations, have gone up. That is a good thing for employees. I have little sympathy for anyone who thin…

I don't disagree with you here. But we need to be explicit about the implications: whole sectors of the US economy have a "failed business model" by this standard. In particular, the US model of restaurants is fundamentally based on paying minimal wages to almost all employees.

A restaurants greatest costs aren't labor but rent. They pay huge amounts to landlords, amounts higher than the landlords mortgage costs. A restaurants low-wage employees then pay 50+% of their wages to other landlords to cover other mortgages. That's the real problem killing the business model: too many people shovelling too much money in exchange for permission to work/live at a particular location. A more normal situation would be where rents are again cheaper than mortgages, when rent represents less than 50% of expenses. Then the restaurant business model starts making sense.

Re: Tahoe's hiring crisis is unraveling small businesses during its busiest season

#86

Honestly, I think this is good for Tahoe in the long run. The NIMBYs who constantly block development are getting a taste of their own medicine. When they’re finally fed up with the low staff and poor service they’ll see the need for affordable housing.

Or do the unfathomable: Pay people better.

Paying more can entice people to commute, but there is still no housing. The real solution is more housing.

Re: Tahoe's hiring crisis is unraveling small businesses during its busiest season

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or do the unfathomable: Pay people better.

I don’t understand the “pay people more” sentiment. It _seems_ like the correct and obvious solution, but it seems like it just moves the goal line. Margins are razor thin in restaurants specifically. If you pay people more, you’ll need to raise your prices and that will offset the pay raise if it happens across the board. What am I missing?

Exports, tourists, buyers of inflated properties (income)

CEOs, managers, capitalist rent-seekers (outflow)

Re: Tahoe's hiring crisis is unraveling small businesses during its busiest season

#88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or do the unfathomable: Pay people better.

I don’t understand the “pay people more” sentiment. It _seems_ like the correct and obvious solution, but it seems like it just moves the goal line. Margins are razor thin in restaurants specifically. If you pay people more, you’ll need to raise your prices and that will offset the pay raise if it happens across the board. What am I missing?

The fact that rents could drop but a readjustment of the value of real estate cannot be allowed to happen.

Re: Tahoe's hiring crisis is unraveling small businesses during its busiest season

#89
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The solution is to not interfere in the market.

I would agree with you typically, but it seems in this case in Tahoe, if you don’t interfere in the market, the businesses will eventually either go out of business, or the economy will stagnate. Property owners are not willing to lower their price, why should they? Businesses can only raise the money they’re willing to offer so much. They could raise prices but then you run into a tipping point where people say you…

As services raise prices and/or quality suffers, the desirability falls, and so will the housing prices, unless the owners like a private resort. It may take time.

Agree with the land value tax (if you don't have it) - it would flatten and speed things up.

Re: Tahoe's hiring crisis is unraveling small businesses during its busiest season

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't disagree with you here. But we need to be explicit about the implications: whole sectors of the US economy have a "failed business model" by this standard. In particular, the US model of restaurants is fundamentally based on paying minimal wages to almost all employees.

A restaurants greatest costs aren't labor but rent. They pay huge amounts to landlords, amounts higher than the landlords mortgage costs. A restaurants low-wage employees then pay 50+% of their wages to other landlords to cover other mortgages. That's the real problem killing the business model: too many people shovelling too much money in exchange for permission to work/live at a particular location. A more normal s…

This randomly selected but high-google-ranked page disagrees with you:

https://www.caminofinancial.com/restaurant-costs/

So does this one:

https://www.7shifts.com/blog/restaurant-costs/

and this one:

https://www.touchbistro.com/blog/restaurant-operating-costs/

Post reply on HN