Live data from Hacker News

Spotify launches in the US

spotify.com

211–220 of 274 posts

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#211

Here's some invites, register with them at https://www.spotify.com/us/invitation/ Updated list of the ones that are left, be quick: eB2BAJAA9xLxYBxD asMr7rpHG2Lqm3wE eJBKb75caywbasFD aSHF6dFyM7Gbyrrq abULR7ucEmwp6GBZ aBYECGgHw9yLuTzx dwZxF2PGmNpVkeEP eLxsqahHYLsdHDGF aadzPV2nfdXB3STx

Thanks! Used "bYyg4LTtVSTuNgSz"

enjoy!

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#212

How is Spotify different from Rdio?

Spotify is also a music management app like iTunes. So you can use Spotify to play your own music files along with their vast catalogue. With Rdio you can only play Rdio songs and if some song isn't on there you'll have to whip out iTunes or another media player.

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#213

I thought I spent them all when I got Spotify but apparently I have 10 invitations, codes: bsAdzYsqp64ngwLP bkhVaqTDPkcbMP94 aHLNnUyw7zxAS5Rg bZBEuEEpynPUAYmH beHDAAHEes95D2Tm bxCUSJbGxWTsz5Pw e7PemkbC2sLykXwM dxa6t3M2Ncu9Ra52 aCxAbykNEyrJzWCs deUWDgPchWycFhK3

Used bxCUSJbGxWTsz5Pw Thanks!

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#214
Am I the only one who signed up for a premium account with the expectation that I would be able to share it with my wife? I'm not quite sure why there's the artificial restriction on being in 'online' mode on more than one computer. It's really a deal-breaker for me. Our only option (I guess) is to have two accounts, which means managing two playlists, etc. (we like to curate them together, our music tastes are very similar). Ah well, I'm not sure if I will continue my subscription past this month...

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#215

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you actually have a source concerning paying artists or are you just fabricating everything you say? http://www.grooveshark.com/labellist

Let's play a game! Step 1. Pick an artist! I'll go for "Britney Spears". Step 2. Pick an album! I'll go for her latest "Femme Fatale". Step 3. Find that album on Groove Shark! Easy enough, it's right there under "Britney Spears". Step 4. Check which label that album is distributed under, Wikipedia states it's under the label "Jive" (who are a division of Epic, part of Sony). Step 5. Search through that list for any l…

EMI, one of the majors, has an agreement with Grooveshark. Merlin, which some say is the 5th largest label, also has an agreement with Grooveshark. Plus all of those other labels on that list that, to you, may be small but represents a LOT of artists.

Youtube also allows uploading of content and takedowns via DMCA, so that is a bit disingenuous of you to claim it's not standard practice. Labels have every right to be compensated and also do takedowns if they choose, but RIAA normally just blankets takedowns that may or may not be inaccurate.

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#216
I'm interested in seeing if their better than piracy strategy will actually work.

Rhapsody had tried the same thing in the mid 2000s, letting people play songs for free.

They seem to think that people who aren't willing to pay for music will use Spotify because it lets you play free music, and then magically decide to start paying for mobile access. But the reality will probably be these users sticking to their less than legal ways and keeping their mobile access via iTunes. So without the compelling free component, it ends up being just an improvement over other music subscription services, and music subscription isn't really a groundbreaking new model.

...or Perhaps subscription is the model of the future and there hasn't been a large enough marketing push educating people yet...

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#217
post #158
post #97

As someone completely unconnected to the company, I don't understand how MOG has totally failed to get any mindshare. Same product, same price, but has been available in the US (including on the iPhone) for >1 year. I assume it must be a profound marketing failure, because the product itself is stellar. (I really, really like it.) If I worked there I'd be driven absolutely insane by the media buzz for all-you-can-eat…

Yes, I agree. MOG has been ahead of the competition for almost a year and yet you never hear anything about it. Total, epic marketing fail.

I disagree that Mog is ahead of the competition.

For me, while Mog has more songs, they lose to Rdio in their UI, their iPhone app, and the social aspect of the service.

When I was comparing them, it was neck and neck between the two, but I couldn't stand Mog's crashy AIR player compared to Rdio's rock-solid AIR player. The Rdio website is much more intuitive and usable, IMO. Also, the new Rdio for Mac app is crazy awesome. The Mog iPhone app used to sign me out all the time, too, which was really irritating.

I've also found a lot more new music through Rdio than I ever did when I was using Mog. The social features are nice because I've been able to find people who like the same type of music and then listen to new music they discover.

It's all a lot of little things, but they added up to make Mog really quite unacceptable for me.

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#218
post #208
post #35

So, do I want to give Rdio up for this?

I'm an Rdio user and I've been trying Spotify today. I'm not thrilled with their music library. There are a bunch of bands that I love that Rdio doesn't have (Arcade Fire, Shins, Ramones, Pink Floyd, older Flogging Molly, newer Eisley, etc.). There are only a few albums that I really want that Rdio doesn't have, by contrast. I feel like Spotify's UI is just a gray iTunes, whereas Rdio's UI is more in line with how I…

It's true that most of the bands you listed were not available a while back, but I believe all of them are available now. We are missing some Pink Floyd though.

If there's something missing that you really want to see, make a request here: https://spreadsheets.google.com/a/rd.io/viewform?formkey=dHd...

And thanks for sticking with rdio!

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#219
post #58
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have been using Spotify in the US in closed beta as well for over a month, so just wanted to give my two cents on these points. I will respond in order: 1.The ads on the free plan are obtrusive, but it's free. I didn't find them any more obtrusive than Pandora's ads. That said, I love the service and wanted to take it mobile, so I upgraded to premium, so I'm no longer hearing ads. 2.I didn't experience disappearing…

Sorry, I wasn't clear that that I have a UK account so the disappearances happened over a long period over a year ago. My bad about The Stones. Maybe they were there that xmas. I suspect that the issue the small independents have with Spotify is exactly linked to Artists' fees. Selling small amounts of CDs is actually worthwhile for a small artist - being on Spotify isn't.

Queen is also there.

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#220

Am I the only one who signed up for a premium account with the expectation that I would be able to share it with my wife? I'm not quite sure why there's the artificial restriction on being in 'online' mode on more than one computer. It's really a deal-breaker for me. Our only option (I guess) is to have two accounts, which means managing two playlists, etc. (we like to curate them together, our music tastes are very…

Having done a bit more looking, it seems like Rdio, MOG, and Spotify all have this restriction, and according to help articles on the MOG site, this is due to the contract the recording industry puts forth. I guess I see where they think this should be included, but I really don't think they should expect one family to purchase 2 or 3 subscriptions.
Post reply on HN