Live data from Hacker News

Spotify launches in the US

spotify.com

191–200 of 274 posts

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#191

Is there a site that compares (up to date) catalog sizes of the different services? Rhapsody used to have the largest, but I couldn't abide their website. Rdio has a great site, but their selection wasn't so great. Mog has been a decent compromise, but I'm interested if Spotify has a larger library.

When did you last try rdio? We've filled in a lot of missing chunks in the past few months and more will be coming with time.

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#192
post #47
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks.. Your klout link worked for me (Had never used klout before) Is there a way to play a personalized station? I am a fan of having my music selected for me.

There's a Radio section. You can choose genres and decades, but nothing equivalent to an "Artist radio".

"For now, the Radio feature will not be available for U.S. users."

"The radio feature will eventually be available. However, I can't say exactly when that will be. Be reminded, that Spotify is not chiefly a radio service. The lack of a radio feature for the time being is a factor of licensing agreements with the rights holders but it will eventually be available.

So the lack of a radio feature in no way limits your ability to search for and play the song of your choice. Just to be clear, when the time comes, the absence of a radio feature will be available for free as well as Premium users, as it is not typically one of the main benefits of a Premium subscription. "

http://getsatisfaction.com/spotify/topics/radio_mode_missing...

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#193
post #9

Spotify will change your life from one appreciating ownership to one preferring access. At least it did with me.

As long as they have all the weird music I listen to, sure. Is there a way to check their selection without signing up? I don't see any way to check if they have Soul Coughing, Zyklon Boom, Любэ, the original Grand Theft Auto soundtrack, Tub Ring, etc? (These are the first few songs I see in my playlist on my iPhone.) I'd be pretty pissed if I signed up and got a Top 40's equivalent for my money.

Sadly, there is no way to preview the catalog. I have an account and checked your list, though, because I've not heard of the majority of those and was curious:

Soul Coughing - Y Zyklon Boom - N Любэ - N GTA - Only GTA IV and Vice City Tub Ring - Y (these guys have a great sound, thanks for the heads up!)

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#194

Spotify seems less exciting than Grooveshark, which has been available in the US for a long time. http://www.grooveshark.com

If "exciting" means "Actually paying artists and not fucking them over constantly and abusing the DMCA to get away with it" then yes, it certainly is less exciting .

Do you actually have a source concerning paying artists or are you just fabricating everything you say?

http://www.grooveshark.com/labellist

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#195
post #42

I've been using Spotify since the UK closed beta (a few years ago, now). At first it seemed like the most amazing thing ever, but slowly I fell out of love with it, and now I barely use it. Why? 1) The ads. At first they were reasonably infrequent and unobtrusive. But gradually they became more frequent and more and more obtrusive. Eventually some companies were deliberately producing jarring ads to grab your attenti…

As I think you have realised some of your issues (ads and artist payments) could be solved by paying for premium. Premium customers also get access to some music that isn't available for free (and early access to lots of new albums). I think the problem for you though is the music you listen to. I have never seen music start to disappear (and I listen to a wide variety of music). It's also not reasonable to expect ar…

> I think the best way to use Spotify is in addition to iTunes.

I agree. I previously used Grooveshark for this purpose, but the number of times I found mislabeled or corrupted tracks sparked me to switch to Spotify a while back.

A win for iTunes over Spotify, for me, is AirPlay. I know I could use AirFoil with Spotify and achieve much the same thing, but then I lose the (fabulous) remote control from iPad/iPhone capabilities.

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#196
Some invitations:

cFYRnaVgfcBYcHH4

fBMLspgTF7BHcRG2

apR5Pfyq8wPzpfTB

akeAbUJG2rLegCVR

bXsqWk2X8CdE3u8q

cJe98FeBPxbFKZq8

drp8Z28F9CRPppgb

eS246SkKmR7BkHmc

aaAwWd8wDpLtbyK8

dhumPYKa39FpheNt

eeZ7kDbS627tZWT3

fDrYCerDMxTwhcwR

aur28tHeccFFkwmd

dS4BNB6sRfkHXLdT

bWL8EA3gykcKJ297

ee4bT9x7hqnwYn6Y

bpm37X3WRJzbetYP

a5BC5M9Wc7DqHTBt

dZBuu2N822TsFnuV

ayXFyz2UpkTt8nxP

bxgLmUd9St9TDZyE

cT84HV9bNDKBTzFB

d2HP73bXDeFzXJ6m

c2DdHmFHTFPndmbz

cK7p6Bb2km9gs9ys

dEkcKKAbqgKrqDSg

fhEphBnfdVDMbFMg

fJLy43hTBdAry8rW

Enjoy!

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If "exciting" means "Actually paying artists and not fucking them over constantly and abusing the DMCA to get away with it" then yes, it certainly is less exciting .

Do you actually have a source concerning paying artists or are you just fabricating everything you say? http://www.grooveshark.com/labellist

Let's play a game!

Step 1. Pick an artist! I'll go for "Britney Spears". Step 2. Pick an album! I'll go for her latest "Femme Fatale". Step 3. Find that album on Groove Shark! Easy enough, it's right there under "Britney Spears". Step 4. Check which label that album is distributed under, Wikipedia states it's under the label "Jive" (who are a division of Epic, part of Sony). Step 5. Search through that list for any label associated with the ones I just listed.

nothing

So here they are, making money of the latest Britney Spears album, yet they aren't licensed to! What a surprise! This is all Grooveshark do. They will only remove after they get a DMCA request because "oh our users upload it! We didn't know! Those naughty users!". That label list is 95% small labels nobody cares about that very few people listen to the music of, none of the larger labels are on there. I would love to see Grooveshark publish a breakdown of what % of their music (based on listens) is licensed vs. unlicensed. I'd bet $100 it's less than 50%.

"oh but it's too hard to get licenses! It's the big bad RIAA!!". Wait a second, we're posting in a thread about a company doing exactly what Grooveshark should be doing and doing it successfully!

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#199
post #196

Some invitations: cFYRnaVgfcBYcHH4 fBMLspgTF7BHcRG2 apR5Pfyq8wPzpfTB akeAbUJG2rLegCVR bXsqWk2X8CdE3u8q cJe98FeBPxbFKZq8 drp8Z28F9CRPppgb eS246SkKmR7BkHmc aaAwWd8wDpLtbyK8 dhumPYKa39FpheNt eeZ7kDbS627tZWT3 fDrYCerDMxTwhcwR aur28tHeccFFkwmd dS4BNB6sRfkHXLdT bWL8EA3gykcKJ297 ee4bT9x7hqnwYn6Y bpm37X3WRJzbetYP a5BC5M9Wc7DqHTBt dZBuu2N822TsFnuV ayXFyz2UpkTt8nxP bxgLmUd9St9TDZyE cT84HV9bNDKBTzFB d2HP73bXDeFzXJ6m c2DdHmFHTFP…

Thanks frek, much appreciated! Used c2DdHmFHTFPndmbz.

Re: Spotify launches in the US

#200
post #196

Some invitations: cFYRnaVgfcBYcHH4 fBMLspgTF7BHcRG2 apR5Pfyq8wPzpfTB akeAbUJG2rLegCVR bXsqWk2X8CdE3u8q cJe98FeBPxbFKZq8 drp8Z28F9CRPppgb eS246SkKmR7BkHmc aaAwWd8wDpLtbyK8 dhumPYKa39FpheNt eeZ7kDbS627tZWT3 fDrYCerDMxTwhcwR aur28tHeccFFkwmd dS4BNB6sRfkHXLdT bWL8EA3gykcKJ297 ee4bT9x7hqnwYn6Y bpm37X3WRJzbetYP a5BC5M9Wc7DqHTBt dZBuu2N822TsFnuV ayXFyz2UpkTt8nxP bxgLmUd9St9TDZyE cT84HV9bNDKBTzFB d2HP73bXDeFzXJ6m c2DdHmFHTFP…

Used dS4BNB6sRfkHXLdT
Post reply on HN