Live data from Hacker News

Shameless Work Influencers Are the Bane of LinkedIn

index.medium.com

101–110 of 228 posts

Re: Shameless Work Influencers Are the Bane of LinkedIn

#101
post #96

Counterpoint: as it is with Facebook, the quality of your feed depends entirely on your connections and who among those connections you have chosen to mute/unfollow. I have over a 1000 connections and I've assiduously unfollowed/muted anyone in my network or adjacent to my network who posts anything that I feel is not substantial. A sample of interactions I had recently: Discussing cost/benefit of going for hybrid/pr…

This is great have you considered writing a LinkedIn article about it?

Re: Shameless Work Influencers Are the Bane of LinkedIn

#102

It's the faux-thentic trope pieces on LinkedIn that annoy me. "I was working so hard I forgot to be me" or "after years of constant success my daughter showed me what success really means". Apparently it means getting likes from strangers. And then there's the business tall tales: "I hired a guy with no qualifications other than a big heart and now he's running a multinational". "I made 10k job applications and lande…

A friend and I have a mini-hobby of sharing these with each other under the title of “Today in Thanking Myself”. The highest level are the ones where people pimp out their own families for LinkedIn karma

I do something similar by locating everyone’s ‘origin’ story. It seems just because you are a mediocre person with income, suddenly you must have this comic book origin story that needs to be out in theaters.

‘Eg, I was retarded in school and no one believed in me, and then one day blah blah blah, and look at me now’ - Coming soon to streaming services and theaters, the story of just a normal person overcoming basic odds to get income like a normal person, but with a dramatic twist.

And they are all shamelessly vain because they are more than willing to reboot their origin story at their next accomplishment.

Particularly bad are women who absolutely cannot stop patting themselves on the back on LinkedIn.

Re: Shameless Work Influencers Are the Bane of LinkedIn

#103
post #25

LinkedIn is missing a major feature, different classes of connections. Your network is meaningless when it’s full of recruiters as well as people you actually worked with.

linked in doesn’t solve the networking problem. maybe i’m different but i’ve never reached out to anyone over linked in to “network”. if i needed to do that i would call, text, email. linked ins real purpose is a search engine for recruiters to contact you. your whole contact list could be recruiters and no colleagues and it would be the same website

If I don't know you and you call or text me, I'm ignoring and blocking you.

Re: Shameless Work Influencers Are the Bane of LinkedIn

#104

It's the faux-thentic trope pieces on LinkedIn that annoy me. "I was working so hard I forgot to be me" or "after years of constant success my daughter showed me what success really means". Apparently it means getting likes from strangers. And then there's the business tall tales: "I hired a guy with no qualifications other than a big heart and now he's running a multinational". "I made 10k job applications and lande…

I have solved this problem by unfollowing people who post or like low quality content. My LinkedIn feed is now mostly filled with useful corporate news.

You should a LinkedIn post about that (but seriously great advice)

Re: Shameless Work Influencers Are the Bane of LinkedIn

#105
post #96

Counterpoint: as it is with Facebook, the quality of your feed depends entirely on your connections and who among those connections you have chosen to mute/unfollow. I have over a 1000 connections and I've assiduously unfollowed/muted anyone in my network or adjacent to my network who posts anything that I feel is not substantial. A sample of interactions I had recently: Discussing cost/benefit of going for hybrid/pr…

This is great have you considered writing a LinkedIn article about it?

I actually read a short post on HN about this recently. It’s here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27325735

Re: Shameless Work Influencers Are the Bane of LinkedIn

#106
Several years ago, there was a burst of people telling stories that were recognizably copied from Somerset Maugham's story "The Verger". What had been lost was Maugham's irony, what was left was a pull-your-self-up-by-your-bootstraps story that could have been inspiring if true but instead was just dumb.

Re: Shameless Work Influencers Are the Bane of LinkedIn

#107
post #22

I find LinkedIn really cringy. And I haven't seen ONE post there that actually added value to my life. It is also toxic as hell. But I know people who got employment offers from LinkedIn. So it adds value in that sense. I just mute and block those influencers. And check LinkedIn maybe twice a week. One of the things I cannot find any excuse for is how fake people are. They are behaving in a fake manner even when they…

Well, one of the main recruiting tools we use when trying to find qualified candidates is LN. so we’ll search for “design” or “engineering” and specific companies and then largely source from LN. So if you want to get in touch with people hiring I suspect LN is a good way. Their tooling for recruiters is pretty robust and sometimes works as you expect it to as well.

Re: Shameless Work Influencers Are the Bane of LinkedIn

#108
post #83
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hacker News. But for simplicity, moderation and downvote buttons would do a world of good.

I don't think it would work on a platform on which people can organize to bully. That's an advantage of HN, it is hard to build such a community because of the lack of communication between users out of topics.

Nothing prevents hn users from getting to know each other and communicate.

I attribute lack of evident destructive mobbing on hn to adequate moderation workforce.

Re: Shameless Work Influencers Are the Bane of LinkedIn

#109
post #7

The same exists on nearly every social media site, sadly. Natural progression I would assume. On Twitter, in dev circles, we have "Junior Dev Porn" where the same poll/questions are asked, the same anecdotes are recycled, and the same code snippets posted, all in the name of empowering junior developers. But at a high altitude it's glaringly obvious the majority are for engagement and follower gain. Especially so whe…

I agree - it seems that all social media platforms suffer from this. Original/useful content seems to lose out in the battle for user engagement. I wonder if you could create a new type of social media platform that overcomes this problem?

How are you going to overcome a problem that we are structurally ingraining into our youth? If the kids are on TikTok by 10 years old, you know, this is a losing fight. The next 3-4 generations will not even recognize that there is a severe vanity and narcissism problem.

Re: Shameless Work Influencers Are the Bane of LinkedIn

#110
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it's not polite to call out BS But it's perfectly fine to spew BS if you do it politely. The "politeness" weapon has been used on me many times

You can use the same sort of polite etiquette in well crafted form to undermine these polite attacks. It takes quick thinking and usually works best in the form of an open ended question that sets the BS in its place. No one says anything explicitly but everyone internally acknowledges it. It may be a bit passive aggressive but such is most modern business culture and meetings.

From why I’ve seen on LinkedIn, subtly doesn’t work. Folks that pick up on it probably spotted the BS already. You really have to hit them over the head with a hammer to drive the point in.
Post reply on HN