Live data from Hacker News

An Asian Uber Driver Was Attacked by a Mob. Then YouTube Took Down His Video

inquiremore.com

91–100 of 191 posts

Re: An Asian Uber Driver Was Attacked by a Mob. Then YouTube Took Down His Video

#91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One way to fight these biases is to remind ourselves that it’s a very small percentage of any demographic that commits violent crimes. It might be more useful, then, to say “99% of X people are never violent versus 99.2% of Y people.”

That's an interesting way of thinking of it. I suppose this reveals an inherent problem with using statistics to represent crime — their significance is easily distorted, even if the numbers themselves are accurate. But to throw a hypothetical at you: is it right for an Asian person in San Francisco to be more scared when they see someone of "X" race than when they see someone of "Y" race? Even if most of the people…

That’s the thing though, the percentage of a random person of any demographic attacking you is like <<< 0.1% (or something), maybe comparable to your chance of dying in a car crash. Yet people cling to stereotypes and don’t wear seatbelts. If people are afraid of a person of certain race approaching them they should be afraid of many other improbable scenarios.

Re: An Asian Uber Driver Was Attacked by a Mob. Then YouTube Took Down His Video

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It can only mean one thing, the elephant in the room, black-on-asian violence Is there anywhere I can read about this elephant in the room? I'm not sure why the label is important here; is the implication that black people are ideologically motivated to attack Asians? Are you sure this was a hate crime (the driver was attacked because was Asian) or a crime of oppurtunity (the driver was attacked because he was an e…

It is critically important in a political climate where one side is using the spectre of white supremacy as a political cudgel. When a complicit media makes a consistent effort to paint a false picture. This censorship is not an isolated incident. News articles regularly leave out the perpetrator's race unless it's white. Reddit regularly deletes and locks threads on inconvenient articles/videos such as this, includi…

Thank goodness we have... Fox News? Newsmax? OAN? Breitbart? to give us the real scoop.

The company you keep and all that.

Re: An Asian Uber Driver Was Attacked by a Mob. Then YouTube Took Down His Video

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Does black-on-asian violence have some kind of special status in comparison to black-on-any-other-skin-color violence?

It doesn't fit the white supremacist narrative. Several articles and news stories were attempting to sell violence on Asians as a result of the white supremacy / privilege, but that died down when the truth didn't fit.

[deleted]

Re: An Asian Uber Driver Was Attacked by a Mob. Then YouTube Took Down His Video

#94

As sad as this incident is, equally sad are the comments on this post here- People who are using this incident and youtube's actions to fit their own agenda, rant against youtube (instead of addressing the real elephant- uber exploiting its drivers) and justifying their own sense of racial wrong and injustices. Nothing in the article indicates that this incident was racially motivated in any way. Grow up. Read the ar…

Nothing in the article indicates that it was racially motivated... except the title.

You are correct, but the op is leading us in that direction. Just look at the top comment. All online communities have some group think, it's unavoidable. The HN group think is best represented by the top comment.

Re: An Asian Uber Driver Was Attacked by a Mob. Then YouTube Took Down His Video

#96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One way to fight these biases is to remind ourselves that it’s a very small percentage of any demographic that commits violent crimes. It might be more useful, then, to say “99% of X people are never violent versus 99.2% of Y people.”

That's an interesting way of thinking of it. I suppose this reveals an inherent problem with using statistics to represent crime — their significance is easily distorted, even if the numbers themselves are accurate. But to throw a hypothetical at you: is it right for an Asian person in San Francisco to be more scared when they see someone of "X" race than when they see someone of "Y" race? Even if most of the people…

For some reason it's perfectly acceptable to apply this logic to women being scared of men, but don't dare apply the same logic to race.

Re: An Asian Uber Driver Was Attacked by a Mob. Then YouTube Took Down His Video

#99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just to explore this: what exactly is your objection to the often-cited observation that black people, who are 13% of the population, commit 52% of the violent crimes? I don’t even know if that’s accurate - if not, then surely that’s the biggest problem with it. But if it’s true, then why is it a dog whistle? I’m not challenging you here, I’m trying to understand why it’s wrong to state it in this kind of context.

Because most people who use that rhetoric will always imply the disparity exists because of genetic disposition rather than a social one. The logic tree goes from "black people commit a lot of violent crime" to "black people are dangerous" (then from there to other various racist tropes), while ignoring the mountain of other socioeconmic issues. Consider this, if I told you Koreans only make 1% of Japan but they make…

You make a very good point. Regarding the Korean example, I’d conclude that Koreans are more likely to get involved in organized crime in Japan because of structural factors of Japanese society and economy.
Post reply on HN