Live data from Hacker News

Anyone working at Facebook: what happening at Facebook on Google+?

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 95 posts

Re: Anyone working at Facebook: what happening at Facebook on Google+?

#51
post #19

My opinions are my own and I can't speak for Facebook as a whole (or in any capacity, really, which is why this will forever remain an anonymous post). I think Google will gain some traction initially, but what we're working on in my group is light years ahead of the Facebook you see and use today, and probably not the same direction that Google is (or can be) heading. Yes, we've had our stumbles with privacy, but wi…

"Yes, we've had our stumbles with privacy, but will Google be any better? Any legitimate complaints that I've heard are either something we're resolving or is an inherent problem that any social networking site will face." I would argue that Google will be better because it's clear they've made privacy the most important part of their offering. By making circles one of the topmost items, they take something that most…

I'll say one thing about Circles... Google doesn't really have any social users yet.

Facebook, to implement Circles as it exists in Google now, will have to retrain their users. Not an easy feat.

The concept of a quick pivot to add new features or markets is silly. If your users expect you to do it the old way, you'll face a long uphill battle.

Re: Anyone working at Facebook: what happening at Facebook on Google+?

#52
post #42
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He's a troll. That sentiment is not prevalent in the company.

Then why I can't easily export my friends list from Facebook to Google+?

Because Google is too proud to use the simple AJAX API that Facebook provides to do so.

https://developers.facebook.com/tools/explorer/?method=GET&#...

Re: Anyone working at Facebook: what happening at Facebook on Google+?

#53
post #39

My opinions are my own and I can't speak for Facebook as a whole (or in any capacity, really, which is why this will forever remain an anonymous post). I think Google will gain some traction initially, but what we're working on in my group is light years ahead of the Facebook you see and use today, and probably not the same direction that Google is (or can be) heading. Yes, we've had our stumbles with privacy, but wi…

It's funny. Google Profiles actually exposes your email addresses to harvestors: (ie profiles.google.com/GMAIL_USERNAME). Google+ at least fixes that.

I actually preferred that since it made the URL easy to remember and easy to link. gmail's spam protection is extremely good.

Re: Anyone working at Facebook: what happening at Facebook on Google+?

#55
post #8

Facebook's response to Google+ actually took place last summer and last fall. I was an intern there at the time, so I got to see it. Google Me, as it was known at the time, was clearly Google's first serious attempt at moving into social, and everyone was a little bit nervous. So, Zuck declared "Lockdown" for sixty days. "Lockdown" was a term from Facebook's early days, which meant when they had a serious competitor…

G+'s Circles are a killer feature and they alone make me hope G+ takes off. Circles solve some very entrenched problems in social networking. So I really hope Facebook is working on a quality response to that.

Re: Anyone working at Facebook: what happening at Facebook on Google+?

#56
post #50
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's a persistent myth that Facebook Group is the same as Google+ Circles. They are nowhere near each other. In fact, Google+ does not have the equivalent of Facebook Groups, unless you count in the older Google Groups. Facebook Group is closer to Google Groups or Yahoo Groups or any one of the dozens of forum-type sites. You create a space in which people join. It creates a venue. Google+ Circles is much closer t…

I think you misinterpreted the parent post. It's saying not saying that Facebook Groups is the same as Google Circles, it is saying that both Facebook and Google+ have the group functionality (in the sense of Unix groups - ie, grouping users for access restriction purposes). In Facebook it is called user lists.

Yeah, my mistake. Thanks for pointing it out.

Re: Anyone working at Facebook: what happening at Facebook on Google+?

#57
post #54

Well, here's one thing that happened the other night: http://circlehack.com Edit : This is the circles UI implemented for Facebook friend lists. Three FB engineers put it together the night Google+ launched.

Since I'm wary of clicking random FB buttons, would you mind explaining what this is?

Re: Anyone working at Facebook: what happening at Facebook on Google+?

#58
post #55
post #8

Facebook's response to Google+ actually took place last summer and last fall. I was an intern there at the time, so I got to see it. Google Me, as it was known at the time, was clearly Google's first serious attempt at moving into social, and everyone was a little bit nervous. So, Zuck declared "Lockdown" for sixty days. "Lockdown" was a term from Facebook's early days, which meant when they had a serious competitor…

G+'s Circles are a killer feature and they alone make me hope G+ takes off. Circles solve some very entrenched problems in social networking. So I really hope Facebook is working on a quality response to that.

I think Facebook has had groups for a while - they just aren't exposed that well in the UI. (I don't think I've ever tried to use them, though, so maybe they're different from Circles in some way.)

Re: Anyone working at Facebook: what happening at Facebook on Google+?

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I take it you don't use gmail as your email provider then?

gmail doesn't lock you in... so I am not sure what your point is.

My point was that Facebook don't also provide email services. Perhaps lock-in is too strong a term, but it's certainly convenient enough to discourage using anything other than gmail - and means that google will own a much larger chunk of your online identity than Facebook does now.

Re: Anyone working at Facebook: what happening at Facebook on Google+?

#60
post #57
post #54

Well, here's one thing that happened the other night: http://circlehack.com Edit : This is the circles UI implemented for Facebook friend lists. Three FB engineers put it together the night Google+ launched.

Since I'm wary of clicking random FB buttons, would you mind explaining what this is?

It looks to be a quickly-hacked together interface for making Facebook user lists with the Circle interface.
Post reply on HN