Live data from Hacker News

‘Insanely cheap energy’: solar power continues to shock the world

theguardian.com

331–339 of 339 posts

Re: ‘Insanely cheap energy’: solar power continues to shock the world

#331

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think any serious free market advocate thinks the government doesn't have a place in restricting and producing negative and positive externalities, respectively. A free market generally means one where one's control over their person and private property is not restricted as long as that control is not being exercised to violate other's equal right to their person and private property, and to the commons . Bu…

Distilled down to its essence a free market grants you protection from involuntary transactions and access to voluntary transactions. Externalities are involuntary transactions, from a free market perspective they aren't any different from robbery or the dreaded... taxes. However, taxes are collected by the government that our population has voted in (in democratic nations). This is also why we prefer government mono…

Yes, that is a good distillation. There are also taxes that do not violate free market principles, like a tax on usage of land, or any other natural resource.

The incredible thing is that these free-market-respecting taxes are found by economists to have zero negative effects on economic efficiency:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax

They are also very easy to administer and impossible to evade - thus extremely fair - and do not require creating a surveillance state to monitor private economic interactions, as a sales or income tax do.

Re: ‘Insanely cheap energy’: solar power continues to shock the world

#332

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Annual fees on those farms make no sense... We've got a quote for €6k - €2.5k subsidy for 8KW system. We use a ton of power - which is a main factor how quickly you get your money back.

What doesn’t make sense about it? We were planning to get 18kW system installed on roof, but to get sign off from power grid we would need to upgrade our power lines at great expense (we are end of line rural), so I am wondering about using solar farm for additional capacity (when it’s available). Interested in your thoughts.

18-25 €/kw = €200 per year times 25 years = 5k€ of 8k€ install is 62.5% of your system cost... This actually buys you some off the shelve batteries (5kwh so far IIRC) which might alleviate your line capacity issue (not sure tho).

Plus they reserve right to set it whatever they want it and you have no practical way to sell your investment...

Re: ‘Insanely cheap energy’: solar power continues to shock the world

#333

> "[in 2000] Shi agreed and ended up settling in the small city of Wuxi" A bit of a tangent, but it’s always strange to me when people describe Chinese or Indian cities with millions of residents as "small". Wuxi had >1 million people in 2000, and today has like 3.5 million (6.5 million in the prefecture). This article makes it sound like a minor town in a remote province, but Jiangsu has about the same population as…

I used to have a Chinese colleague who when asked where he came from would answer that he was from "A small town, you wouldn't know it. Only 3M people". He was right; I had never heard of it. I guess in China, which has multiple mega cities, that is indeed a bit unremarkable. It's all relative.

Something similar kind of happened to me ... the university I am at (normally) comprises 50k people. No idea where they are ... especially because Bielefeld University is just one building.

Re: ‘Insanely cheap energy’: solar power continues to shock the world

#334
post #293

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Doesn’t really matter whether you do or not, it’s in Europe.

Ok 3 cities. Russia is in Europe like Turkey is. So make that 4 cities.

The vast majority of its population, 75%+, lives in Europe. Just because their current leader is worsening its ties with the West does not make Russia any less part of Europe.

Re: ‘Insanely cheap energy’: solar power continues to shock the world

#335

> "[in 2000] Shi agreed and ended up settling in the small city of Wuxi" A bit of a tangent, but it’s always strange to me when people describe Chinese or Indian cities with millions of residents as "small". Wuxi had >1 million people in 2000, and today has like 3.5 million (6.5 million in the prefecture). This article makes it sound like a minor town in a remote province, but Jiangsu has about the same population as…

I used to have a Chinese colleague who when asked where he came from would answer that he was from "A small town, you wouldn't know it. Only 3M people". He was right; I had never heard of it. I guess in China, which has multiple mega cities, that is indeed a bit unremarkable. It's all relative.

My wife is from a city of 7 million in China. Not only would you not have heard of it, most Chinese I've met also need some explanation of where it is.

I've traveled in China, and sometimes we just stop at some convenient roadside "village" for lunch, the kind of place that would have a Denny's and a gas station in the US. Except in China, the restaurant has five stories and it's bumper to bumper traffic outside. The population difference is really hard to get used to.

Re: ‘Insanely cheap energy’: solar power continues to shock the world

#336

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What doesn’t make sense about it? We were planning to get 18kW system installed on roof, but to get sign off from power grid we would need to upgrade our power lines at great expense (we are end of line rural), so I am wondering about using solar farm for additional capacity (when it’s available). Interested in your thoughts.

18-25 €/kw = €200 per year times 25 years = 5k€ of 8k€ install is 62.5% of your system cost... This actually buys you some off the shelve batteries (5kwh so far IIRC) which might alleviate your line capacity issue (not sure tho). Plus they reserve right to set it whatever they want it and you have no practical way to sell your investment...

Yeah, batteries won’t cut it really - need to store thousands of kWh for winter. I’ll have to look into the terms some more - afaik nothing is finalised yet, awaiting change in law. Thanks for input!

Re: ‘Insanely cheap energy’: solar power continues to shock the world

#337

Earlier quoted context omitted.

18-25 €/kw = €200 per year times 25 years = 5k€ of 8k€ install is 62.5% of your system cost... This actually buys you some off the shelve batteries (5kwh so far IIRC) which might alleviate your line capacity issue (not sure tho). Plus they reserve right to set it whatever they want it and you have no practical way to sell your investment...

Yeah, batteries won’t cut it really - need to store thousands of kWh for winter. I’ll have to look into the terms some more - afaik nothing is finalised yet, awaiting change in law. Thanks for input!

Batteries are to get you thru the night, forget winter.

2.3k euro for 5kwh [0] which sounds more than Tesla Powerwall. You probably want more, but you do your math. Probably you'll want to return more to network in summer and use that in winter. Store peak winter excess

0: https://shop.saulesgraza.lt/parduotuve/saules-elektrines/sau...

Re: ‘Insanely cheap energy’: solar power continues to shock the world

#338
post #334

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ok 3 cities. Russia is in Europe like Turkey is. So make that 4 cities.

The vast majority of its population, 75%+, lives in Europe. Just because their current leader is worsening its ties with the West does not make Russia any less part of Europe.

My point was more when people say they're "going to Europe" they never mean they're going to Russia. If they're going to Russia they say they're going to Russia and not Europe. Russia is culturally and geographically unique.

Re: ‘Insanely cheap energy’: solar power continues to shock the world

#339
post #185

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I look at this chart [0], seeing that we’re wasting about 2/3 of our energy, I expect the energy demand to drop significantly if we electrify everything and have more local energy sources. [0]: https://flowcharts.llnl.gov/

Note that much of the waste probably comes from thermal / fossil power generation, which is unavoidable even in theory (cf. Carnot efficiency). That is, unavoidable unless chemical energy is turned into electrical energy directly like in fuel cells (these have smaller but still surprisingly large losses), or the rejected thermal energy is used for heating.

With local energy sources, I meant, local renewables energy sources. So no chemical energy.
Post reply on HN