Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Disabled My Account After I Criticized Them

lincoln.metacannon.net

71–80 of 246 posts

Re: Facebook Disabled My Account After I Criticized Them

#71

They saved you the work of deleting the account yourself. Say thanks and move on with your life =)

They actually don't delete the account. The account may remain forever deactivated, with your personal data intact, but you stripped from your right to access it, or request its deletion.

There are several reports about people logging in after a year and seeing the same message as the day they were banned from Facebook.

Re: Facebook Disabled My Account After I Criticized Them

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They exist because they're popular, you can't dictate what is popular among the masses without authoritarianism.

They exist because they’re profitable. They can become unprofitable through democratic legislation.

Twitter is only barley profitable as of a year ago, yet it has continued to exist as a large social network during that time, so that explanation doesn't fit.

Re: Facebook Disabled My Account After I Criticized Them

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or, perhaps, these problems are reasons why large, centralized social networks shouldn’t be allowed to exist.

They exist because they're popular, you can't dictate what is popular among the masses without authoritarianism.

Sure you can, just require interoperability with similar services and prevent them from straight up buying the competition and watch their "popularity" fade away.

Re: Facebook Disabled My Account After I Criticized Them

#75

I think FB has a fundamental issue here, which is that: 1) they don't feel they can NOT police content 2) they are wayyyyy too big to police content manually 3) any AI they train to police content, is not going to be able to state clearly why a given post/account was banned, and anyway... 4) if you state objective, clear rules that are automated, it will be pretty easy to game them (e.g. using euphemisms or code word…

> 2) they are wayyyyy too big to police content manually

To be more exact: they do not want to spend money on competent policing. They probably have capability to employ ten times as many human moderators as they do now, thus reducing the blatant error rate (at least in the case of highly influential pages and people), but that would eat into their profits.

Re: Facebook Disabled My Account After I Criticized Them

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don’t have to dictate popularity: just create legal liability frameworks that make a solution like Mastodon more appealing than a solution like Facebook or Twitter

People can still be banned on Mastadon, it changes absolutely nothing. In a world where Mastadon becomes more popular than FB people will complain about being banned from the most popular node instead of the most popular http website.

Mastadon is federated, so you can be banned from someone else's instance but you can always start your own instance, or join one where you're not banned.

Re: Facebook Disabled My Account After I Criticized Them

#77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They exist because they're popular, you can't dictate what is popular among the masses without authoritarianism.

Sure you can, just require interoperability with similar services and prevent them from straight up buying the competition and watch their "popularity" fade away.

I think preventing FB from buying competitors is perfectly reasonable, but that doesn't really mean much with respect to FB's popularity. It's not as if users have to choose "should I use FB or instagram" they can and do use both, and that would still be possible whether FB owned instagram or not.

Re: Facebook Disabled My Account After I Criticized Them

#78
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They exist because they're popular, you can't dictate what is popular among the masses without authoritarianism.

They exist because they’re popular and because the currently successful ones acquired or strangled all of their smaller meaningful competitors using investment capital and money from first mover advantages.

Can you give some examples?

Re: Facebook Disabled My Account After I Criticized Them

#79
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I find the idea of Facebook being "necessary" for anyone quite spectacularly laughable. This isn't, air or water. You can live without it, and many people happily do. Facebook is about as essential as essential oils.

That's a short-sighted statement. On a personal level, I completely agree with you. Facebook is a giant waste of time for the typical user and a big +1 for your life if you ditch it. For many business, however, it's critical. My local Snap-on Tools dealer uses it to announce where his truck will be each day and what tools and equipment he's running on special. He hates Facebook but told me the other day that he condu…

A lot of businesses in the developing world just use messaging apps for effectively the same purpose. You don't need FB.
Post reply on HN