Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Vantage – An alternative AWS console focused on developer experience

vantage.sh

41–50 of 88 posts

Re: Show HN: Vantage – An alternative AWS console focused on developer experience

#41
Crazy how you need a tool that reads another tool to figure out how much you're spending for the original tool.

I'm sure there was a purpose for how the AWS console was originally built, but if someone spent this much time for an alternative, there's a clear problem in its original conception.

Re: Show HN: Vantage – An alternative AWS console focused on developer experience

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The provided CloudFormation stack creates a Cross Account IAM Role with a list of read only permissions. We don't accept access keys or secrets. - A permissions overview is here (most aren't used for now). This list was made from the AWS-managed IAM policy of "ReadOnlyAccess" but whittled down to remove things like our ability to read from S3 Buckets or Databases: https://docs.vantage.sh/permissions/ - The latest Clo…

I'm so refreshed to see this designed this way. I assumed that they would be asking for an API key or equivalent, because I don't know anything about the product team or the company and this bad behavior is so bog-standard. I beg you to blog heavily about this approach, especially if you find success with it / it doesn't provide a very negative user experience. See if you can get featured on enterpriseready.io or som…

Hey, thanks for that comment and I'm glad folks are noticing our approach. We are happy to blog about it. We've had a tremendous amount of success with it.

Security is a top concern of ours and this was really the only option for what we are doing.

Re: Show HN: Vantage – An alternative AWS console focused on developer experience

#44

Although this is a nice little simplified view into your AWS account I think calling it an "alternative AWS console" is misleading because you can't actually do anything with it, use it to make changes, etc.

It's a fair call out and something we've struggled with in messaging at this stage of the company. It's hard to keep messaging simple but also be succinct with what we are providing. We will be iterating on this over time.

That being said - we are slowly adding management actions and I do believe we will be compatible with a number of AWS services in due time. For example, you can manage Route 53 record sets directly from Vantage. We wrote a post up on it here: https://medium.com/@bensign/raising-the-bar-for-the-route53-...

Re: Show HN: Vantage – An alternative AWS console focused on developer experience

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you have over $500 per month of AWS spend, you are still free to use the product (no credit card required to get started) and everything will work but certain features will be restricted. For example, cost transparency reports will require an upgrade to use for spend over $500 per month. The specifics are detailed on our pricing page here: https://vantage.sh/pricing We are taking a look at what it would take to of…

Makes a lot of sense. Theres an interesting item I noticed: -You limit based on spend -You don't support all AWS Services -As a result you don't see all of our spend -Which means you actually limit based on spend of supported services? (I think?)

That's correct.

It also aligns our incentives with insuring we do as good a job as possible with appropriately representing your costs :)

Re: Show HN: Vantage – An alternative AWS console focused on developer experience

#46
post #42

I was a bit whelmed when I used it. I expeced an alternative to the AWS console, but got a monitoring dashboard. Didn't seem like I could do much with it besides looking at my resources.

Out of curiosity - what else would you like to do? We're always open to feedback. The only write actions we have are around Route 53 detailed here but we're adding more soon: https://medium.com/@bensign/raising-the-bar-for-the-route53-...

Re: Show HN: Vantage – An alternative AWS console focused on developer experience

#48

Any thoughts on a self hosted version? (I didn't look too closely at all the marketing stuff if this is already addressed) Would be nice to put something like this up behind our own VPN auth etc

We have been asked about this a bunch, yup.

It isn't something we're going to get done in the near term but if you'd like to discuss, I'd be happy to chat about it. Feel free to email me at ben@vantage.sh

Re: Show HN: Vantage – An alternative AWS console focused on developer experience

#49
post #42

I was a bit whelmed when I used it. I expeced an alternative to the AWS console, but got a monitoring dashboard. Didn't seem like I could do much with it besides looking at my resources.

Out of curiosity - what else would you like to do? We're always open to feedback. The only write actions we have are around Route 53 detailed here but we're adding more soon: https://medium.com/@bensign/raising-the-bar-for-the-route53-...

I guess, I would like to do what I can do with the actual AWS console. Provision and update my resources. Otherwise it's, like I said, only another monitoring dashboard.

I mean, that isn't bad, it's probably doing a good job at that. But I guess, I simply expected more interactivity from an AWS console replacement, haha

Re: Show HN: Vantage – An alternative AWS console focused on developer experience

#50

Congratulations on the launch. The cost estimation feature is awesome - very useful for people like me who are not very good at cleaning up resources. Also like the cross-region view without having to switch console regions. This looks promising - good luck!

Thanks!
Post reply on HN