Live data from Hacker News

Mark Rober (former NASA) launches a 30 day Creative Engineering Class

monthly.com

71–80 of 100 posts

Re: Mark Rober (former NASA) launches a 30 day Creative Engineering Class

#71
The comments hating on Rober are way off base.

He has been on youtube for nearly 10 years making videos, and as he gained success, he started to work with more and more people to do even more amazing work.

Watch one of his initial videos (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O1P6K_PaS0A) and compare to his work now.

Re: Mark Rober (former NASA) launches a 30 day Creative Engineering Class

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He also pollutes the environment with all of his projects. Filling his swimming pool with plastic balls for views.

I don't think any body cares about that. Specially when you can collect the plastic balls (because it's in your pool) and recycle it (which I'm sure he did, I don't think he dumped it in his kitchen trash can). He also uses biodegradable glitter.

Biodegradable glitter is a marketing scam, fyi. https://www.getlemonhead.com/blog/the-truth-about-bio-degrad...

Re: Mark Rober (former NASA) launches a 30 day Creative Engineering Class

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for pointing this out. I've enjoyed quite a few of Mark's videos over the years. He's clearly smart and talented, but it was unsettling how insanely productive he seemed to be. That sort of thing naturally creeps into my subconscious and not in a healthy way. He mentions the people he works with but the videos are still presented in a way that makes them feel like a single person production. I should've figure…

He also pollutes the environment with all of his projects. Filling his swimming pool with plastic balls for views.

You've posted this 3 times in response to comments on this thread. Do you have an axe to grind against Mark?

Re: Mark Rober (former NASA) launches a 30 day Creative Engineering Class

#74

This is clearly marketing, and clearly good one. From what I can tell, it's a course that was mostly produced by someone else and will be delivered by someone else, but they recorded Mark Rober - the guy famous on YouTube for glitterbombing people - as the instructor. But their FAQ already states that he will "be able to" look at what students are doing and "may occasionally [..] give feedback", so most likely he won…

Thanks for pointing this out. I've enjoyed quite a few of Mark's videos over the years. He's clearly smart and talented, but it was unsettling how insanely productive he seemed to be. That sort of thing naturally creeps into my subconscious and not in a healthy way. He mentions the people he works with but the videos are still presented in a way that makes them feel like a single person production. I should've figure…

After working on a few of my own ambitious side projects, I've come to realize there is no way in hell he does all that alone. There's a team of people helping him and designing the things he shows in his videos.

Re: Mark Rober (former NASA) launches a 30 day Creative Engineering Class

#75

This guy is doing a lot to pollute the environment just to get views on YouTube. Filling a swimming pool with plastic balls is one example. Has he heard of plastic pollution?

Also the guy that helped and donated $50,000 to team trees. Clearly you're trying to find a point to hate on him without acknowledging the good he's done.

Re: Mark Rober (former NASA) launches a 30 day Creative Engineering Class

#76
post #38
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

After his latest video I was wondering if his recording of the thieves in their homes runs afoul of wiretapping laws. I can appreciate that someone who just stole a package probably isn't likely to try to press charges, but made me wonder if he is just assuming that risk. Maybe the box has a 'shrinkwrap' license agreeing to be recorded?

Surely there are provisions in the law for this? Otherwise I could just go to your home, steal one of your wireless security cameras, place it in my house and have you charged with wiretapping?

Right, but intent matters. You're not allowed to boobytrap your property, but beyond that you won't be held liable for burglars injuring themselves.

I mean, if instead of glitter and fart spray the thing was wired specifically to explode and kill the thief, the argument "they stole my explosives and blew themselves up" won't hold water.

I'm curious what a court would rule on this matter - anywhere from fart spray over property damage to death.

Re: Mark Rober (former NASA) launches a 30 day Creative Engineering Class

#77

This is clearly marketing, and clearly good one. From what I can tell, it's a course that was mostly produced by someone else and will be delivered by someone else, but they recorded Mark Rober - the guy famous on YouTube for glitterbombing people - as the instructor. But their FAQ already states that he will "be able to" look at what students are doing and "may occasionally [..] give feedback", so most likely he won…

I am indeed blown away by marketting efforts around this. They successfully and continuously targetted me on FB and the ad was effective enough to make me click. Now I see they got on HN which is hard for even legitimately deserving posts. They know their target demographic extremely well and knows how to get noticed. The ultimate give away for me was the fact that this cannot be good in-person class given such a huge marketting effort and potential enrollment that might be in order of 10s of thousands. Ultimately it's no more than buying a lesson video.

Re: Mark Rober (former NASA) launches a 30 day Creative Engineering Class

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think any body cares about that. Specially when you can collect the plastic balls (because it's in your pool) and recycle it (which I'm sure he did, I don't think he dumped it in his kitchen trash can). He also uses biodegradable glitter.

Biodegradable glitter is a marketing scam, fyi. https://www.getlemonhead.com/blog/the-truth-about-bio-degrad...

It depends on what sort of biodegradable glitter you're using. Some glitter is even edible.

Re: Mark Rober (former NASA) launches a 30 day Creative Engineering Class

#79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for pointing this out. I've enjoyed quite a few of Mark's videos over the years. He's clearly smart and talented, but it was unsettling how insanely productive he seemed to be. That sort of thing naturally creeps into my subconscious and not in a healthy way. He mentions the people he works with but the videos are still presented in a way that makes them feel like a single person production. I should've figure…

He also pollutes the environment with all of his projects. Filling his swimming pool with plastic balls for views.

You can say this about every sort of entertainment that require props or special effects.

Re: Mark Rober (former NASA) launches a 30 day Creative Engineering Class

#80
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd recommend watching those videos before knocking him for the glitter bombs. They are impressively engineered, with entertaining videos which contain a good deal of detail about how, why, and in the most recent version, how they are working with law enforcement to crack down on package thieves.

If you’re into this type of engineering check out “stuff made here” or “BPS Space”.

I hope Joe is doing alright. He just announced he's burned out and taking a break. I'm sure he could use it. He's done some impressive stuff.
Post reply on HN