Live data from Hacker News

Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected

news.cornell.edu

61–70 of 86 posts

Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected

#61
post #3

From a Jupiter-like gas giant type exoplanet, which generate radio emissions through entirely natural processes just like the gas giants in our own solar system. The title is a tad more spectacular than the actual discovery.

Comments like these are why I mostly only read the comments and headline.

Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected

#62
post #50
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can't see a good reason to assume an alien civilization would be industrial to begin with, whatever discovery path might lead one there. And I don't even mean they could be underwater creatures etc., which is also a possibility. Imagine Earth as we know it, inhabited by humans as we know them, but no fossil fuels (due to a different geological history), very few metal ores (making every metal as scarce as, say, pla…

That seems like an interesting plot for a story. Stonepunk? It seems a sufficiently advanced society could have Antikythera type computing mechanisms ground from stone. And extravagant "wood"-working artifacts shaped by sharp stone tools (obsidian single point turning tools for your lathe?). So you could have advanced looms for textiles, etc.. And then without metals you don't have electrical conduction, but what cou…

Children of Time touches on this in some interesting ways: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children_of_Time_(novel)

Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected

#63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That still suggests a _machine race_ could have sent it.

We could define intelligent life as being any of a sapient species, regardless of physical composition. That's helps do away with only carbon-based lifeforms.

What would be the definition of sapience for a machine civilization?

Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We could define intelligent life as being any of a sapient species, regardless of physical composition. That's helps do away with only carbon-based lifeforms.

What would be the definition of sapience for a machine civilization?

Same as for humans. Or a hive mind, or some other type.

Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The title is in an odd spot where, on the face, it is completely anodyne, and not at all misleading or “clickbait.” Yet even sensible readers (like me!) see “radio” and “exoplanet” in the same sentence and think “ALIENS!” Very awkward spot for the science PR people writing this. It’s almost like it needs extra words to prevent people from adding “Possible (But Definitely Non-Alien) Radio Emission From Exoplanet (Whic…

> anodyne It's pretty rare for me to run into a (non-technical, niche) word I'm not at least somewhat familiar with, thanks! anodyne (adjective): not likely to provoke dissent or offense; inoffensive, often deliberately so.

I used that a couple of weeks ago responding to a bland email from my state’s DOT completely ignoring the concerns I raised.

Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected

#67
post #45

Radio JOVE is a STEM project that explores the radio emission of our own Jupiter, which is very similar to what has been detected in Tau Boötes. It's a very fun backyard amateur radioastronomy project that's great for kids. https://radiojove.gsfc.nasa.gov/

Wow, that sent me down a short rabbit-hole of listening to Jupiter [0] [1] and other space radio emissions [2].

Makes me wonder if these sounds were ever remixed into music? Would certainly be an interesting concept along the lines of the German Space Night TV program.

[0] https://youtu.be/slE2i0O0pDY

[1] https://vimeo.com/173638603

[2] https://www.nasa.gov/vision/universe/features/halloween_soun...

Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What would be the definition of sapience for a machine civilization?

Same as for humans. Or a hive mind, or some other type.

Which is?

Common dictionaries, such as Oxford, state:

Sapient 1. Wise, or attempting to appear wise. 2. Relating to the human species.

Where

1. wise is defined: Having or showing experience, knowledge, and good judgement. Hard to see how that would apply to a hypothetical hive or machine drone civilization with only a single ‘wise’ controller.

2. Clearly not applicable.

Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected

#69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same as for humans. Or a hive mind, or some other type.

Which is? Common dictionaries, such as Oxford, state: Sapient 1. Wise, or attempting to appear wise. 2. Relating to the human species. Where 1. wise is defined: Having or showing experience, knowledge, and good judgement. Hard to see how that would apply to a hypothetical hive or machine drone civilization with only a single ‘wise’ controller. 2. Clearly not applicable.

Sentience might be a better word.

Re: Possible Radio Emission from Exoplanet Detected

#70
post #45

Radio JOVE is a STEM project that explores the radio emission of our own Jupiter, which is very similar to what has been detected in Tau Boötes. It's a very fun backyard amateur radioastronomy project that's great for kids. https://radiojove.gsfc.nasa.gov/

Wow, that sent me down a short rabbit-hole of listening to Jupiter [0] [1] and other space radio emissions [2]. Makes me wonder if these sounds were ever remixed into music? Would certainly be an interesting concept along the lines of the German Space Night TV program. [0] https://youtu.be/slE2i0O0pDY [1] https://vimeo.com/173638603 [2] https://www.nasa.gov/vision/universe/features/halloween_soun...

There is "The Space Project", a 2014 album of songs by various artists using "electromagnetic radiation fluctuations in the magnetosphere of the celestial bodies studied by the Voyager probes" [1]. I like Spiritualized's track on it [2].

[1] https://www.discogs.com/Various-The-Space-Project/release/56... [2] https://youtu.be/GksfQN1_LsM

Post reply on HN