Live data from Hacker News

Ethical AI researcher Timnit Gebru fired from Google

twitter.com

71–80 of 310 posts

Re: Ethical AI researcher Timnit Gebru fired from Google

#71
post #49
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Were you a vendor or did you work in sales/management. I have honestly never seen such a scenario in swes. Would love to know more.

Both full time SWEs. The gap exists, you can ask around. It's widely known at Google.

Have you looked at the self reported salary data? It doesn't really seem to bear that out (although of course any self reported data is going to have issues)

Re: Ethical AI researcher Timnit Gebru fired from Google

#72
post #39

The comments here are weird right now. They seem overly focused on the spat she and Yann LeCun had a while back when it doesn't seem like this incident is about that? Hopefully some clarification comes out about what her demands were and the internet drops their pitchfork about something that happened long ago

The LeCun affair is pretty good evidence that she's a hot head who's more than willing to provoke public drama.

Re: Ethical AI researcher Timnit Gebru fired from Google

#73

[flagged]

I hope with this episode and Coinbase, SV will lead the fight against toxic SJWs.

I’ve always thought only SV has the freedom and power to start this fight. Then academia and other institutions can follow and ride the momentum.

Re: Ethical AI researcher Timnit Gebru fired from Google

#75
post #39

The comments here are weird right now. They seem overly focused on the spat she and Yann LeCun had a while back when it doesn't seem like this incident is about that? Hopefully some clarification comes out about what her demands were and the internet drops their pitchfork about something that happened long ago

It's a pattern of behavior. She had a thread just last week calling her employers "a bunch of privileged White men" and complaining that they were disrespecting her by not letting her work on some unspecified research project.

https://twitter.com/timnitGebru/status/1331757629996109824

Re: Ethical AI researcher Timnit Gebru fired from Google

#76

The email she posted [1] makes it pretty clear that she sent an email with some demands/conditions (separate from the one "to Brain women and allies") and said that she would resign if they weren't met. Google said they wouldn't agree to them, accepted her threatened resignation, and told her it was effective immediately. Without knowing more context, it sounds like she tried to do some hardball negotiating by threat…

This is some next level drama alright. Threaten workplace with your own demands.

Re: Ethical AI researcher Timnit Gebru fired from Google

#77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd never heard of this fight before, so I just looked it up. My interpretation is that he made that claim, Gebru responded by claiming that that was an overly reductionist view of things (given, presumably, the fact that biased assumptions could affect the coded assumptions as well as the training data), he maintained his opinion, and she felt frustrated that she didn't feel she was being listened to. I did not see…

Here’s a good summary: https://www.google.com/amp/s/syncedreview.com/2020/06/30/yan... I think it’s clear Gebru was acting in bad faith and LeCunn was baffled and trying to deescalate. Gebru responds to each attempt to deescalate by a reply designed to further rile up Twitter, without actually talking to any of the points LeCunn makes. Virtually all of her replies are some variant of “you are wrong, but I won’t say w…

I wouldn't be shocked if Google saw this drama, saw that she was offering to resign, and was like "that's a freebie."

Re: Ethical AI researcher Timnit Gebru fired from Google

#79
post #17

Racism exists. Pay discrimination exists. Yet, you can't go about breaking every norm and rule if you are famous and from an under-represented group. I also saw the tweets at Yann LeCun. I'm not his biggest fan, but that wasn't right. She's hurting minorities for her own agenda. Edit: removed info about myself.

I've never heard of a 300% pay gap between people doing the same job, how does that even happen? Were you paid significantly under par or did that other person somehow hit jackpot? And at what level are we talking about?

Sorry, I'm gonna not answer just because I don't want to make it about myself and also don't want to reveal my identity.

Re: Ethical AI researcher Timnit Gebru fired from Google

#80

I think this is a great argument for why unionization in tech is going to be important. Right now the only way to disagree with unethical actions by your employer is leaving; easily replaced.

But is this truly the situation where a union makes a difference? She hasn't been fired unfairly for someone who is a senior manager. She has ready employment possibilities and won't experience any hardship.

I'd rather they kept their powder dry to protect employees fired for things like union organisation, and protecting the workforce during large layoffs/reorgs, individuals discriminated against for their race/religion/sexuality, being compelled to take actions that are immoral/illegal etc. None of which seem to apply here.

Post reply on HN