Live data from Hacker News

Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

twitter.com

51–60 of 74 posts

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#51
post #8

The swipe from bottom gesture meant the least annoying iPhone X / 11 cases had the bottom mostly cut out, e.g. the Apple silicon case. Another reason for not covering the edges.

My case has a lip all around the phone, including the bottom, and the swipe gestures work just fine.

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#53
post #5

I don't think this argument is very convincing. There's still more than enough space between the edge of the phone and the edge of the screen to allow a case to have a slightly overlapping lip. Cases that work this way are better because they give you a new bezel made of rubber above the screen to cushion a fall. Now, maybe Apple wants to convince people that a case that doesn't actually protect the screen is a good…

Screens are much more durable now than when I started getting cases though.

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#54
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bulk isn’t just about looks, it’s about function. The bulkier the phone (including any case, if using one), the harder it is to hold and use in one hand. Apple’s announcement of the iPhone mini is a pretty clear indication that they believe there is still a market for smaller phones.

For me rather than use a phone with a case I'd prefer the manufacturer just make the phone larger so it can be handle day to day life without a protective sleeve.

The best materials for protection are soft ones like silicone, plastic or leather. Soft materials wear down, so you wouldn't want them to be built-in to your $1000 phone. Better to have a $2 case you can swap out when it wears down (and it let's people customize their phone to suit their style)

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah I don't get his logic at all. I would have purchased a case either way. At least with a thinner phone, the case isn't as unwieldy.

Thinking on this, I don’t remember cases for the original Blackberry or Palm devices. I never cased a flip phone. Or one of my candy bar phones. Apple gets really excited to say “thinnest iPhone ever” — but then we (or at least I) slap an Otterbox on it because I want the thing to last. At the end of the day, it’s just for marketing purposes. No one wants to buy a Jitterbug phone. People want to buy sleek and sexy. A…

I did managed to crack the screens on both my Palm IIIx and a Nokia N73, so despite their bulky plastic cases, they weren't impervious (since the smartphone era I've also cracked only two screens - iPhone 5S and 11 Pro Max, only the former was caseless)

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#56
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I can't even recall seeing someone use their phone without a case Exactly, they're too fragile to use without some sort of case. Which really makes the "look how thin and pretty the new device is!" something of a lie. And pointless, who cares if the phone is the thinnest ever, when it's going to live its life in a thick jacket? I don't want to use a case. I want a phone I can buy for the way it looks and feels and…

I tried to sneak in this final question to my comment, but what other option is there for a luxury consumer gadget? You could argue that phones should just be uglier and thicker and more rugged such that they don't need a case, but I don't think it's very palatable for a $1000 handheld to be taking damage directly for most people when the ruggedness can be outsourced to a $20 case. Nor do I think a luxury consumer ga…

I would imagine for a $1000 item, it wouldn't be unreasonable to have a designer try to find a way to be more rugged and still not ugly -- see for example, IBM thinkpads, though they are perhaps the other extreme

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#57
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd rather get over it and still have the device in my pocket without needing the extra hardware to keep it in one piece.

I tried to go caseless but realized I was constantly thinking about what surface I was putting it on. Is the surface wet at this restaurant? Is it dirty? Is it slippery? Can metal slide on it? If it does inevitably fall, what will happen? A case solved all this. And frankly I can't even recall seeing someone use their phone without a case, so it seems to be a prevailing issue. I'm not sure what the alternative is tha…

I use mine without a case. It has minor cosmetic damage in 3 years with heavy usage.

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#58
Off topic but I am amazed at the PR generated by apple fanboys in media. I am seeing so many tweets praising apple for removing chargers and other accessories from the box for environment.

Chinese companies have been doing that for years and they actually pass the savings to the consumer.

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#59
post #5

I don't think this argument is very convincing. There's still more than enough space between the edge of the phone and the edge of the screen to allow a case to have a slightly overlapping lip. Cases that work this way are better because they give you a new bezel made of rubber above the screen to cushion a fall. Now, maybe Apple wants to convince people that a case that doesn't actually protect the screen is a good…

AKA exactly how the iPhone 5 cases worked?

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#60

I hate cases and think they make the phone totally bulky. The strap for the 5th pen iPod touch is what should be on every iPhone. Apple often comes up with good ideas but fails to execute on them properly.

Do people actually drop their phones much while using it? I feel like most of the time you drop it by knocking if off of a table, or dropping it while pulling it out of your pocket, where a wrist strap wouldn't help. And I think Apple actually is much better at execution than coming up with new ideas. A lot of the things they do (iPad, face ID, notch, airpods, airdrop) are not new ideas, just executed better.

I haven’t had a case on my iPhone X in at least a year. The only damage is a very slight crack in the glass surrounding the camera lens (not the lens itself)
Post reply on HN