Live data from Hacker News

Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

twitter.com

21–30 of 74 posts

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#21
post #9

The more pertinent question, if you step back for a moment, is why the hell are we sacrificing everything for thinner phones and edge-to-edge displays only to then ship them with a more or less mandatory case to stick in.

Because cases can add functionality or customization that only a subset of users might want. See the "naked robotic core" idea http://5by5.tv/hypercritical/86.

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#22
post #18
post #9

The more pertinent question, if you step back for a moment, is why the hell are we sacrificing everything for thinner phones and edge-to-edge displays only to then ship them with a more or less mandatory case to stick in.

What are you saying? If they make thicker phone then case is not needed?

That perhaps if we weren't focused on thinness above all, perhaps they could be made robust enough to survive without needing a case.

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#23
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah it always struck me as bizarre - here is a technological marvel, beautifully crafted, polished and shiny, slim and elegant. But you have to put it in an ugly protective case or it'll be borked inside a year.

You really don't. I haven't used a case on for more than a total of a month in the last ten years. Even with dropping my phone fairly frequently, and sometimes onto concrete from head height, I've only had one phone receive more than minor cosmetic scratches.

I've gone 3 years with no case on my current phone. The screen is still unscratched and not chipped or cracked or anything. The most obvious wear and tear is actually in the paint on the back of the phone that has faded where my fingers normally comfortably position themselves.

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#26

I hate cases and think they make the phone totally bulky. The strap for the 5th pen iPod touch is what should be on every iPhone. Apple often comes up with good ideas but fails to execute on them properly.

I hate breaking my phone. Cases may not be pretty, but they’re pragmatic.

Also FYI: literally no one cares how your phone looks.

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#28
post #11
post #9

The more pertinent question, if you step back for a moment, is why the hell are we sacrificing everything for thinner phones and edge-to-edge displays only to then ship them with a more or less mandatory case to stick in.

Yeah it always struck me as bizarre - here is a technological marvel, beautifully crafted, polished and shiny, slim and elegant. But you have to put it in an ugly protective case or it'll be borked inside a year.

Are you really marveled by your phone after you've had it for a week or so?

I think once the honeymoon gadget phase wears off, most people get over it and then prefer to protect it so that their expensive device lasts longer.

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#29
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You really don't. I haven't used a case on for more than a total of a month in the last ten years. Even with dropping my phone fairly frequently, and sometimes onto concrete from head height, I've only had one phone receive more than minor cosmetic scratches.

Whereas I lose count of the various phones I've cracked. Never had an iphone, but I've destroyed screens on Samsungs, Motorolas, at least one nexus device... Every phone I insisted on using caseless. Perhaps I'm just clumsy :)

Low quality glass cracks more.

Re: Did Apple build MagSafe so that cases can “stick” to the new iPhones?

#30
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah it always struck me as bizarre - here is a technological marvel, beautifully crafted, polished and shiny, slim and elegant. But you have to put it in an ugly protective case or it'll be borked inside a year.

Are you really marveled by your phone after you've had it for a week or so? I think once the honeymoon gadget phase wears off, most people get over it and then prefer to protect it so that their expensive device lasts longer.

I'd rather get over it and still have the device in my pocket without needing the extra hardware to keep it in one piece.
Post reply on HN