Live data from Hacker News

OBS Studio 26.0

github.com

121–130 of 163 posts

Re: OBS Studio 26.0

#121
> Windows: Added Virtual Camera

There's already a plugin for that and I've been using it for a while. I use it to combine my webcam with my desktop so that I can watch YouTube together with my family while still looking at each other's face.

Re: OBS Studio 26.0

#123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> OBS was a driving factor Why? OBS runs on macOS too

It runs horribly on macOS. Like a night and day difference. If I understand correctly the difference is primarily regarding the encoder. I also switched my streaming machine over to windows recently. Edit: ok, “horrible” is dramatic, but it was honestly shocking the first time I booted into windows and gave OBS a try there. Exact same computer that struggled with OBS in macOS produced a much better output without bre…

Using Boot Camp or a Hackintosh to be able to do that on the same computer? Might help to make the distinction between it overperforming via Boot Camp or underperforming on a Hackintosh.

Re: OBS Studio 26.0

#124

Love me some OBS, I use it for piano practice with my tutor. Simultaneous video feeds (face, hands) and window capture of VMPK mirroring the MIDI out of my digital piano piped into a virtual camera, then VBcable pipes the OBS monitor audio to an input source. Put those two together as the audio and recording devices in zoom and were off! If there is interest I’d love to write more about it and share, let me know!

Could you ask someone to make a video of you while you are using this setup? Like a friend/family member in your room holding a phone? I would like to show an older piano teacher this setup.

Re: OBS Studio 26.0

#125
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

OBS 0.659 is "Classic" OBS which has been discontinued for years. If you're having issues capturing games with OBS Studio, stop by our forums or Discord with a log and we may be able to help. If the game uses any kind of anti-cheat engine, it's possible the developer only whitelisted older capture DLLs but this is rare.

There is no log. OBS "captures" but the image is black while the game sound is there. One common attribute I found for all these games are that they are "true full screen". One example is "Tomb Raider", the series reboot from 2013. OBS 0.659 has no problem capturing my gameplay, while newer versions gives, like I said, black screen on recording. Quick question if you indulge me: Why was classic discontinued?

If you can stream your games on a Zoom/Skype call as a test, then OBS should be able to handle it too with the right configuration.

Re: OBS Studio 26.0

#126

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a counter anecdote - my 2015 MacBook Pro stutters within 30-40 seconds of OBS streaming a 1080p feed to YouTube. Is there anything to tweak? Or is my machine too old?

Not sure, you may want to drop to 720p and maybe lower your bitrate. For my latest project I was using a Macbook pro 2015 to test it, running my app and streaming at the same time fine. I was running Windows 10 though on the mac. If you're running Mac OS try using a utility like SMC Fan Control to set the fan RPM high. Mac OS by default wants to be as silent as possible which could be leading to some performance issu…

A lower bitrate (=better quality assuming constant file size) requires your encoder to work harder. If anything you want to use faster settings with higher bitrates (=lower quality). Some encoders let you cap the bitrate but what this does is basically ruin video quality in scenes where the bitrate cap has been exceeded, it doesn't actually make it less CPU intensive.

Re: OBS Studio 26.0

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

OBS supports hardware encoding ironically on Intel integrated graphics, but doesn't on discrete graphics. So a much better graphics chipset in a macbook is likely to be a hinderance for this.

Nvenc is supported, even says in the change log that they improved the messages they show if you are using old nvidia drivers.

NVENC is not supported on macOS because Apple does not expose it in their VT toolkit that OBS is required to use to access hardware encoders.

Re: OBS Studio 26.0

#128
post #70
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One of the reasons why OBS got so popular compared to Xsplit is that it is free.

Interesting – Xsplit is reported as a $20K sponsor on the website: https://opencollective.com/obsproject#section-budget (Scroll down to see the list of contributors.)

The OBS team has a very friendly relationship with XSplit folks, they're nice people and strive for a better product for all users.

Re: OBS Studio 26.0

#129

OBS is such a great tool. It does its job in a clear and specific manner, and exposes as many levers as you need in the controls. The plugin system seems a bit unrefined though, I think it could be a major win if it was somewhat more accessible. Platform-specific stuff kinda sucks but it's the nature of the beast. Unfortunately, at some point they seemed to have removed support for the AMD encoder used with my old GP…

Some kind of plugin manager/installer is certainly something that will get added to OBS, probably sooner than later.

The AMD AMF encoder is still preset in OBS, it just requires somewhat recent GPU drivers to work (19.7.1 minimum, 19.9.2 or newer recommended)

Re: OBS Studio 26.0

#130

Still no support for my audio interface over USB… You can add it, but no signal comes true. I know about virtual audio routing, but I'm so sad this bug hasn't been fixed after years…

Your device must support one of the common audio protocols to work in OBS (for Windows WASAPI for example). There's also an ASIO plugin available.

OBS will probably not add any specific code to support non-conforming device(s) without an external maintainer willing to keep the needed code updated over the years.

Post reply on HN