Live data from Hacker News

Online Cash Bitcoin could Challenge Governments, Banks

techland.time.com

31–40 of 221 posts

Re: Online Cash Bitcoin could Challenge Governments, Banks

#31

Why is Bitcoin a good currency again? If I understand how it is distributed correctly, those with higher/more computational power receive more of the finite bitcoins. How does that not favor the already rich?

The point of Bitcoin isn't to not favor the rich (all types of money favor those who have it), but to prevent central control. That control leads to things like hyper inflation, preventing payments to certain parties, seizing of assets, etc.

Re: Online Cash Bitcoin could Challenge Governments, Banks

#32

Why is Bitcoin a good currency again? If I understand how it is distributed correctly, those with higher/more computational power receive more of the finite bitcoins. How does that not favor the already rich?

Because mining for bitcoins is a lot of work, and ultimately doesn't make huge amounts of money? Because it isn't the job of a currency to evenly distribute the wealth?

Re: Online Cash Bitcoin could Challenge Governments, Banks

#33
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From a practical standpoint, Bitcoin has other problems for using it in a real business -- mainly the fact that taxes are only payable in the coin of the realm. If you are a real, legal business, do you want your entire personal and business future contingent on the ability to exchange bitcoin with dollars?

You don't have to put all your eggs in one basket. You could accept payment in dollars and bitcoins, and exchange the bitcoins for dollars the day you receive it. If the bitcoin market suddenly crashes, you'd only lose the amount you hadn't managed to exchange for dollars.

If you do that, what's the advantage of bitcoin?

Re: Online Cash Bitcoin could Challenge Governments, Banks

#34

I have a hard time getting excited about a currency when the main reasons given for it's existence are for online gambling and Wikileak donations. I would be excited about a dollar alternative that allowed the common person to protect themselves from the inflationary rot that the US Congress is hell-bent on subjecting us to.

Those are the first uses because online gamblers and muckraking NGOs are the ones most desperate for an alternative to a government-issued currency. If the average person was unable to function with inflationary currencies, they'd find an alternative.

Inflationary currencies? I'm pretty sure every form of currency is subject to inflation.

Re: Online Cash Bitcoin could Challenge Governments, Banks

#35
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From a practical standpoint, Bitcoin has other problems for using it in a real business -- mainly the fact that taxes are only payable in the coin of the realm. If you are a real, legal business, do you want your entire personal and business future contingent on the ability to exchange bitcoin with dollars?

You don't have to put all your eggs in one basket. You could accept payment in dollars and bitcoins, and exchange the bitcoins for dollars the day you receive it. If the bitcoin market suddenly crashes, you'd only lose the amount you hadn't managed to exchange for dollars.

And how exactly would you exchange bitcoin for dollars? Presumably, you'd have to go through a bank, or PayPal, or a regulated brokerage house of some kind. To keep bitcoin from taking off, all the US government would have to do is pass a law or put pressure on the financial industry to not allow that exchange.

Re: Online Cash Bitcoin could Challenge Governments, Banks

#36
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't have to put all your eggs in one basket. You could accept payment in dollars and bitcoins, and exchange the bitcoins for dollars the day you receive it. If the bitcoin market suddenly crashes, you'd only lose the amount you hadn't managed to exchange for dollars.

If you do that, what's the advantage of bitcoin?

Currency Diversification. The point being that at the end of each day/week/month you can cash it out for dollars/euro/yen.

That's the idea anyway. I'm not sure how practical it is!

Re: Online Cash Bitcoin could Challenge Governments, Banks

#37

I have a hard time getting excited about a currency when the main reasons given for it's existence are for online gambling and Wikileak donations. I would be excited about a dollar alternative that allowed the common person to protect themselves from the inflationary rot that the US Congress is hell-bent on subjecting us to.

I feel the same way, but there is a much more lucrative reason to use bitcoins: The lack of transaction fees. I don't know about you, but it really bothers me that you have to give up ≈3% of your revenue to the credit card companies if you want to do business online.

Re: Online Cash Bitcoin could Challenge Governments, Banks

#39

Why is Bitcoin a good currency again? If I understand how it is distributed correctly, those with higher/more computational power receive more of the finite bitcoins. How does that not favor the already rich?

It's my understanding that it's probably easier to trade bitcoins for dollars than calculate them directly, unless you happen to have a lot of spare computing resources lying around. For instance, if I set my desktop machine calculating, I might make 50 BTC in a year. But I could buy that on an exchange for $50 right now if I wanted to.

That said, bitcoins do favour the already rich. If I have $1000 I can buy more bitcoins than someone with only $100. This is not exactly unusual.

The advantage of using bitcoins as a currency is that you can transfer them electronically without the need for a centralised banking system and all the bureaucracy that entails. As a programmer, this is what really excites me about the system.

Re: Online Cash Bitcoin could Challenge Governments, Banks

#40

Bitcoin is pretty sweet, but its extremely confusing. I barely understand it, and i'm an extremely technical user. I think people need to work harder on bringing down the complexity.

What complexity? The client pretty much only has one button, "send BitCoins".
Post reply on HN