Live data from Hacker News

Apple Fitness+

apple.com

181–190 of 363 posts

Re: Apple Fitness+

#181
post #172

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It should work with AirPlay I'd imagine

I have no way to AirPlay to my TV as far as I know, because I don't have Apple TV. Are there other ways to?

Some "smart" tvs have AirPlay built in. (Samsung has some models). Ours did but we didn't know it initially.

Re: Apple Fitness+

#182

So you have to pay for a watch that collects your data? Furthermore the watch is likely full of proprietary chips - which is fine if you could buy those. If "your" watch goes bad, only Apple will be able to repair it and for sure their charge you adequately. And you give your data for free.

Why is paying for a watch that collects your data weird to you? Your phone also collects your data and I bet you paid for it too.

Also, the watch collecting your data is kind of the whole point.

Re: Apple Fitness+

#183

> For usage with iPad, Fitness+ requires iPad Pro, iPad (5th generation or later), iPad mini 4 or later, iPad Air 2, or iPad Air (3rd generation). Fitness+ is supported on Apple TV 4K and Apple TV HD. So if you don't have an Apple TV, you can't watch on a TV? That's a non starter for me (Peloton customer), seems a bit rubbish to be exercising in my living room and not using the TV to display the class.

wait... a $2,000 bike that only shows does bike workouts is fine, but a $150 device to stream entertainment and now fitness is too much? You can always just attach a HDMI cable to your phone or tablet (via converter) if you really want to.

Re: Apple Fitness+

#184

I like the idea of Apple Fitness+. That it provides an integrated experience with the watch and another device (iPhone/iPad/Apple TV) is exactly what I’ve been waiting for all these years! No need to create yet another online account on a service that may share (or sell or probably lose) my workout and health information. The workout recommendations are computed on-device, and the data stays on the devices (health da…

I disagree. YET ANOTHER feature that is linked to ONE SINGLE account. If apple decides to block your account, everything is gone. This happened some time ago to my microsoft account - everything gone. And why? Because I have uploaded (automatically) a nude picture of my gf to their cloud, it was detected by their algorithm and my account was locked. I had to communicate with microsoft by a PAPER LETTER(!) to understa…

Ah yes, those pesky Microsoft-Apple™ cloud guidelines.

Re: Apple Fitness+

#185

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Before jumping at Google/Fitbit train, take a look at Withings watches. Their Healthmate app is solid. In my experience much better than Fitbit, and it isnt trying to sell me on any premium services. I have a Steel HR & the battery life is measured in weeks.

If I end up not buying a new Apple Watch, I will look into it! My Fitbit broke recently and I'm on the market. The EKG is ... really tempting, though - that's about the only thing that's pulling me toward the Apple Watch.

I’m curious, why is the EKG feature that tempting? I don’t really see what I’d do with it besides doing a reading once in a while

Re: Apple Fitness+

#187
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But, there's an argument to be made that they would be cross-shopping $500 Amazon-Prime-deliver-tomorrow bikes, to pair with the Apple ecosystem they already have. I would be scared if I ran Peloton. Their entire MO is the ecosystem; you buy the bike, with the integrated tablet, and use their fitness program. Outside of the top 1% who could drop three grand on the Peloton system without blinking, Apple's whole "$500…

$500 stationary bikes are crap. Apple Fitness is only slightly cheaper than Peloton standalone - $10 vs $13 - so I don't think that would be a factor for many people. The main drive of Peloton if you aren't buying their bike is the instructors and high quality classes - I struggle to imagine many people would care more about watch integration than class quality, and I don't think Apple will be able to win out on the…

Apple has two hundred billion dollars in cash sitting in a bank account, a fitness ecosystem, and deep experience in fitness and video production. They've announced that the initial set of programs will include cycling, treadmill walk & run, yoga, core, strength, rowing, HIIT, and cooldown. They're planning to add new workouts every week, and have popular, properly licensed music (Peloton spent years illegally playing music, before switching to no-copyright music for a year. Today its in a better place).

I would not bet money on Apple losing on class quality, let alone variety.

Re: Apple Fitness+

#188

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder what that means for companies like Peloton. I can imagine an Apple Watch and a small "smart" bike trainer[1] would be infinitely more practical and affordable for most people and still allow Apple users to track all of the same metrics as Peloton. [1] Something like this, but with an odometer and WiFi: https://www.amazon.com/Goplus-Exercise-Trainers-Flywheel-Sta...

They could just buy Peloton. "Apple Peloton".

They could, but if they have superior hardware I doubt they'd want to have to support the long tail of Peloton users with existing bikes.

Re: Apple Fitness+

#189
post #3

I think Apple Fitness+ will be fine as a standalone product, but I believe this is a stepping off point for more fully fledged fitness products from Apple. Using their AR technology (iPad/iPhone/etc), they can replicate a lot of the same functionality a multi-thousand dollar product like the Tempo provides. They can automatically correct form, recognize weights, etc.

Should check out Gymaholic iPhone app. Really good use of AR and overall nice experience.

https://apps.apple.com/gb/app/gymaholic-workout-tracker/id64...

Re: Apple Fitness+

#190

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If Apple did this for home workouts I would subscribe to Fitness+ in a heartbeat. I currently practice yoga at home, and the worst part is I don't have an instructor to correct my form.

You can try https://yoganotch.com - uses motion sensors to give feedback on yoga form

cool design! + I don't need to film myself while doing yoga. what is the accuracy?
Post reply on HN