Live data from Hacker News

I Want to Fix Goodreads

prepend.com

61–70 of 205 posts

Re: I Want to Fix Goodreads

#61
I’ve been building a prototype over at https://longtweetsapp.com because I’ve had the same problems. It’s hard to find books so I took a more personalized, data-driven approach, starting with Twitter networks, because I was tired of bestseller and most popular lists.

It’s still early goings, but I’d love feedback - I’m dogfooding it with interesting results. Send me a note: hareesh.ganesan+longtweets@gmail.com

Re: I Want to Fix Goodreads

#62

Howdy, Mek here -- I run https://openlibrary.org over at the non-profit Internet Archive (the folks that bring you the Wayback Machine). Open Library is an free, online California Library with millions of digital books to read and borrow. It's additionally an open catalog of millions of books which you may track like goodreads. Best part? If it's not to your liking, the whole project is open source! https://github.co…

Fellow Goodreads refugees, you can import your lists into OpenLibrary.org.

1. Export: https://www.goodreads.com/review/import

2. Import: https://openlibrary.org/account/import

Re: I Want to Fix Goodreads

#63
Book rating and recommendations are an impossible problem to begin with. If you browse through Goodreads, you will see that everything is rated 4 stars. People only finish and rate books they like, and it's impossible to compare books of different genres, lengths, time periods, complexity etc. on the same objective scale like it is for movies or TV shows.

Re: I Want to Fix Goodreads

#64
post #55

I am a Goodreads employee. this is a burner account. i could be fired for posting. we love Goodreads and we know it is bad today. we are working to fix it. there are very few of us. we are trying. we are making big changes soon.

> i could be fired for posting. Yikes, that's rather dramatic! Especially since all you've said is "we're working to fix it. changes soon." That's a pretty harmless statement, I would think. What gives you the idea that such statements put your employment at risk?

> there are very few of us. we are trying

This implies support for Goodreads at Amazon is very thin. It could be read as a critical statement (even though it's pretty clear to everyone that the site very clearly stagnated since the acquisition, focusing almost exclusively on Kindle integration).

Amazon management is famously militaristic in attitude and would likely take action against a low-level employee criticizing the company in public

Re: I Want to Fix Goodreads

#65
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> i could be fired for posting. Yikes, that's rather dramatic! Especially since all you've said is "we're working to fix it. changes soon." That's a pretty harmless statement, I would think. What gives you the idea that such statements put your employment at risk?

It might be the general fear present in some Amazon corp offices? (PIP stories, etc.)

> general fear present

I don't know about this. Is it documented, or have you "heard it through the grapevine," so-to-speak?

Re: I Want to Fix Goodreads

#66

I am a Goodreads employee. this is a burner account. i could be fired for posting. we love Goodreads and we know it is bad today. we are working to fix it. there are very few of us. we are trying. we are making big changes soon.

Can we have half stars or quarter stars? I read a lot of books, and choosing full-star 1 to 5 makes the ratings pretty useless for people who read a lot. My internal rankings are: 1 hated it/was offended/didn't finish 2 disliked it/likely didn't finish 3 finished but it was a struggle 4 finished/enjoyed/had some issues 5 finished fast/really enjoyed/may or may not have still had issues. If I look back at the 30 to 50…

I have been rating a year or so after reading based on how much of the book I remember or how much it influenced me. It's made rating much easier.

Re: I Want to Fix Goodreads

#67
post #64
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> i could be fired for posting. Yikes, that's rather dramatic! Especially since all you've said is "we're working to fix it. changes soon." That's a pretty harmless statement, I would think. What gives you the idea that such statements put your employment at risk?

> there are very few of us. we are trying This implies support for Goodreads at Amazon is very thin. It could be read as a critical statement (even though it's pretty clear to everyone that the site very clearly stagnated since the acquisition, focusing almost exclusively on Kindle integration). Amazon management is famously militaristic in attitude and would likely take action against a low-level employee criticizin…

> management is famously militaristic

Although I know that Amazon is hiring intelligence operatives[0] to bust unions, this aspect (militaristic middle management) is news to me. Where can I learn more?

0. https://www.theverge.com/2020/9/1/21417401/amazon-job-listin...

Re: I Want to Fix Goodreads

#68
I don’t care about reviews or recommendations. I have a to-read list that will last me the rest of my life easily.

The thing I hate about goodreads is there are two search fields one to search books you’ve read and one to search every book.

I’ve wanted to search books I’ve read like 5 times in my life but for some reason I always end up using the only search books I’ve read search bar and I get no results. Just make it a checkbox or return two lists or something.

Re: I Want to Fix Goodreads

#69

My problem with Goodreads isn't the recommendations engine. The recommendations are fine. I'm actually skeptical that any ML recommendation engine is going to recommend better books than my friends will. The only thing I expect from a recommendation engine is discovery , by which I mean finding new things that neither I nor my friends have read that look interesting. Whether they're good is another story altogether..…

Discovery engines are pretty easy if you just use clustering unless you allow transitivity (book in two clusters can be used to suggest a book in either cluster)

If it is so easy, why most of them sucks?

Re: I Want to Fix Goodreads

#70

I am a Goodreads employee. this is a burner account. i could be fired for posting. we love Goodreads and we know it is bad today. we are working to fix it. there are very few of us. we are trying. we are making big changes soon.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN