Live data from Hacker News

Kenosha Militia FB Event Asking Attendees to Bring Weapons Reported 455 Times

buzzfeednews.com

21–30 of 40 posts

Re: Kenosha Militia FB Event Asking Attendees to Bring Weapons Reported 455 Times

#21
post #6

The kid was chased by multiple felony offenders, one with a gun, and was attacked and knocked to the ground by another with a skateboard. The video evidence clearly shows he acted in self defense

He transported an illegally owned firearm across state lines and used it to kill two people.

Apparently his attorney is saying he did not carry a weapon across state lines but rather a friend there let him borrow theirs. If that was a registered weapon, that will come out in the trial.

Re: Kenosha Militia FB Event Asking Attendees to Bring Weapons Reported 455 Times

#22
post #18
post #6

The kid was chased by multiple felony offenders, one with a gun, and was attacked and knocked to the ground by another with a skateboard. The video evidence clearly shows he acted in self defense

... after he already had killed a protestor. After realizing what he did, instead of calling for help or staying to justify his actions, he ran away and shot two more people in the process. Then the police let him walk away. Please contrast this with the same police shooting an unarmed black man seven times in the back at close range while getting into his car. Imagine if he had 2’ long rifle on him too. I don’t reli…

First, calling them protestors is dishonest. At that point it had devolved into a violent riot. He ran away because an armed man was chasing him, and another with a skateboard. Also, he was taken into custody, not allowed to walk away. The three men who attacked Kyle were all convicted criminals as well. https://mobile.twitter.com/MichaelCoudrey/status/12988734361...

The black man was not unarmed, he had a knife in his hand and a gun in his car. The police fired when he reached into the car. He already had the knife in his hand and told the police he was going to grab the other

Re: Kenosha Militia FB Event Asking Attendees to Bring Weapons Reported 455 Times

#23
post #16
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Whataboutism. And a terrible effort. There has been no confirmed violence traced back to left-wing groups. Criminality has mostly been opportunistic by local criminal gangs, spontaneous personal conflict or organized by law enforcement against civilians and journalists. Only right-wing groups are organizing terrorism. And the comparison is pointless. We should decry this behavior whenever we see it.

I don’t see the poster claiming this was left, right, whatever? Just trace the source.

OP was asking if riots were organized on social media as if that was some counter argument to why we should not permit the kind of organized violence from the BuzzFeed story. This struck me as an attempt to weaken the argument that we should be upset about right-wing terrorism on social media. It has also been widely asserted by the president (among others) that left-wing groups are the bigger terror threat. OP didn't say it but I'm reading between the lines.

Short answer is that it is all still irrelevant. Any attempt to organize violent confrontations on social media should be subject to removal. Incitement is explicitly excluded from first amendment protection. Planned rioting should absolutely be shut down as well but there's been no reports of that. Banning any organizing that could possibly lead to violence is definitely not the same thing.

Re: Kenosha Militia FB Event Asking Attendees to Bring Weapons Reported 455 Times

#24
I think the reason why it wasn't removed is probably because it wasn't clear it violated facebook policy. I guess after the fact because of media pressure facebook has decided that it did.

There is a cached url available at: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3AaKHZ...

It looks like in the event itself there was no direct call for violence unless the event description has been lost with the caching.

The title just said: "Armed Citizens to Protect our Lives and Property" and it was hosted by "Konosha Guard".

Re: Kenosha Militia FB Event Asking Attendees to Bring Weapons Reported 455 Times

#25
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He was 17, so regardless of his actions, he's still a kid. And he wasn't just walking around, he was defending business and property. Earlier in the day he was cleaning graffiti off of buildings in Kenosha

My favorite response to this circulating right now is a photograph of Ted Bundy doing dishes. That was not his business or property. He was a vigilante.

How things change. I think that just 10 or 15 years ago a person risking their own safety to protect someone's else building from being set on fire and burned to the ground would be considered a hero.

I'm not saying that he's innocent. It's just crazy how "That was not his business or property" makes a valid point today.

Re: Kenosha Militia FB Event Asking Attendees to Bring Weapons Reported 455 Times

#26
post #10
post #5

The media spin going on regarding Kenosha is crazy. If I hadn't seen the videos of what happened, I would have assumed it was a white supremacist shooting peaceful protesters, not someone who was being attacked and only shot when he couldn't get away.

The first person was killed because he threw a plastic bag. "The complaint claims that cell phone video showed Rosenbaum, who appeared to be unarmed, trailing behind Rittenhouse before throwing a plastic bag at him. As the pair approached a car, a loud bang is heard, followed by an unidentified male yelling an obscenity. When Rosenbaum gets close to Rittenhouse, another four bangs are heard." The widely circulated vi…

This is the prosecutors claim. This is the same prosecutor that decided to push for murder 1 which is a ridiculous over charge. Unless the prosecutor has written evidence from Kyle claiming he went to the protest either directly to kill people or aggro people into attacking him so he could kill them the charge won't stand.

For balance here is Kyle's lawyers statement on the incident where he claims one of his pursuers lunged at him to try and take his rifle and that was the reason for the first shooting:

https://wkow.com/2020/08/28/attorneys-say-accused-kenosha-sh...

> As Kyle proceeded towards the second mechanic’s shop, he was accosted by multiple rioters who recognized that he had been attempting to protect a business the mob wanted to destroy. This outraged the rioters and created a mob now determined to hurt Kyle. They began chasing him down. Kyle attempted to get away, but he could not do so quickly enough. Upon the sound of a gunshot behind him, Kyle turned and was immediately faced with an attacker lunging towards him and reaching for his rifle. He reacted instantaneously and justifiably with his weapon to protect himself, firing and striking the attacker.

Re: Kenosha Militia FB Event Asking Attendees to Bring Weapons Reported 455 Times

#27
post #10
post #5

The media spin going on regarding Kenosha is crazy. If I hadn't seen the videos of what happened, I would have assumed it was a white supremacist shooting peaceful protesters, not someone who was being attacked and only shot when he couldn't get away.

The first person was killed because he threw a plastic bag. "The complaint claims that cell phone video showed Rosenbaum, who appeared to be unarmed, trailing behind Rittenhouse before throwing a plastic bag at him. As the pair approached a car, a loud bang is heard, followed by an unidentified male yelling an obscenity. When Rosenbaum gets close to Rittenhouse, another four bangs are heard." The widely circulated vi…

Stabilized video (gif) of the first shooting: https://i.maga.host/rc9wxWa.gif

Note that this is after the bag was thrown - the person who threw it continued to chase the shooter and was within contact distance.

Apologies for the domain. This is a heavily politicized event, and YouTube seems to be taking down the videos.

Re: Kenosha Militia FB Event Asking Attendees to Bring Weapons Reported 455 Times

#28
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

... after he already had killed a protestor. After realizing what he did, instead of calling for help or staying to justify his actions, he ran away and shot two more people in the process. Then the police let him walk away. Please contrast this with the same police shooting an unarmed black man seven times in the back at close range while getting into his car. Imagine if he had 2’ long rifle on him too. I don’t reli…

First, calling them protestors is dishonest. At that point it had devolved into a violent riot. He ran away because an armed man was chasing him, and another with a skateboard. Also, he was taken into custody, not allowed to walk away. The three men who attacked Kyle were all convicted criminals as well. https://mobile.twitter.com/MichaelCoudrey/status/12988734361... The black man was not unarmed, he had a knife in h…

I believe you have multiple factual errors here; in particular, Rittenhouse shot and killed a person first, then tried to run away and killed 1 more person.

Also, Jacob Blake did not have a gun. It's stil unclear whether he was holding a knife or sunglasses.

Re: Kenosha Militia FB Event Asking Attendees to Bring Weapons Reported 455 Times

#30
I'm sorry but some guy going with his gun to a protest for no reason is as bad or probably worst than rioters and looters. I don't understand how some people can blame looters but defend this guy. Don't mix things together. He literally killed some humans. Are you out of your mind or your biases blinded you so badly that you can't judge anymore and you don't see anything?

They should investigate and see how a "17" years old is so brain washed to take a gun and go there. I hate rioters and looters, but I can't imagine how can I convince myself to go there with a gun. That isn't normal.

Post reply on HN