Live data from Hacker News

Apple Judge ‘Inclined’ to Unblock Epic’s Unreal Engine but Not Fortnite

bloomberg.com

11–14 of 14 posts

Re: Apple Judge ‘Inclined’ to Unblock Epic’s Unreal Engine but Not Fortnite

#11
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can already authorize an arbitrary third party Android app to act as an app store, the only thing stopping you is your own decision making. Can't do that with iOS. You can even build your own AOSP device from scratch if you feel like, and it would be completely compatible with everything in the Android ecosystem (assuming you did a good job). If one party is making an effort to support open software lifecycles, w…

Well, that only happens if Apple is deemed a monopoly. A non-monopoly can do whatever it wants with its store. It will take years for anything to happen, look how long it took Microsoft back in the 90s.

It can happen if Congress passes a law and the President signs it.

I love how the intellectually dishonest Apple workers downvote. As I said, this should apply to all systems that electronically attempt to “corner the market” on an unsuspecting public, for example non-critical apps running on your car’s infotainment screen, your refrigerator, digital picture frames, thermostats, ... Let the manufacturers do what they want, so long as they allow users to do what they want after they’ve forked over their cash.

Re: Apple Judge ‘Inclined’ to Unblock Epic’s Unreal Engine but Not Fortnite

#12
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The judge is already leaning in the direction of monopoly, she sees no competition (and deliberate acts to block competition) to the App Store on the iPhone itself. Quoting her comments to Apple's counsel: "There is no competition. The question is, without competition, where does the 30 percent (App Store commission) come from? Why isn't it 10? 20? How is the consumer benefiting from, you (Apple) get to say what you…

The actual trial is not gonna happen any time soon, this is only for an emergency injunction to stop Apple from cutting Epic access to Apple Development tools. Watching the whole thing it's likely Fortnite will be off the App Store for the time being, and Epic will be able to continue to support Unreal Engine.

The major companies in Silicon Valley are already facing legislative scrutiny right now (Tim Apple testified in front of Congress a couple weeks ago and looked shocked at the revelations being thrown at him —I am guessing he will be firing a whole lot of people who must have known about that stuff, but forgot to mention it during their briefings). In addition, there are publicly announced anti-trust investigations underway by the Exexutive branch in US, EU, Russia and beyond. Sure there will be fines for past deeds, but they can shut it all down by allowing users to shop at any app store they want.

Re: Apple Judge ‘Inclined’ to Unblock Epic’s Unreal Engine but Not Fortnite

#13
post #3
post #2

Sorry the Bloomberg link showed me a purported recent picture of Celine Dion and I found it hard to concentrate. Seriously, we the people need to force Apple and Google to authorize qualified third-party app stores and open source the minimum level of development tools to support the hardware, even if they decide to never sell another device again. “It’s just that simple.” (Yeah, I know Google already voluntarily doe…

The fact that you say “force Apple” is really all there is to know. Apple isn’t the boogeyman here. Ruf had it US coming and the judge clearly sees it too.

Apple is your trigger? What are you worried about your stock options (there is an analyst call for $530 this am!)? Are you sure every branch of the major governments of the world (even those representing you) are wrong?

Re: Apple Judge ‘Inclined’ to Unblock Epic’s Unreal Engine but Not Fortnite

#14
post #2

Sorry the Bloomberg link showed me a purported recent picture of Celine Dion and I found it hard to concentrate. Seriously, we the people need to force Apple and Google to authorize qualified third-party app stores and open source the minimum level of development tools to support the hardware, even if they decide to never sell another device again. “It’s just that simple.” (Yeah, I know Google already voluntarily doe…

Here is another Bloomberg link for you (no Celine pics)..

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-08-26/house-ant...

love dem downvotes!

Post reply on HN