Live data from Hacker News

Apple apologizes to WordPress, won’t force the free app to add purchases

theverge.com

91–100 of 387 posts

Re: Apple apologizes to WordPress, won’t force the free app to add purchases

#91

As an app developer myself, with apps on both the Google Play Store and the App Store with over 250K monthly active users, I have become so frustrated with Apple's arbitrary and capricious enforcement of its App Store regulations, its bullying and coercion of developers, its extortionate fees, and its monopolistic anti-competitive practices, that I have stopped updating my apps on the App Store. I wonder how many oth…

> its extortionate fees Their fees are not so high as to be extortionate. They're not close to being deserving of that hyperbolic label. The Apple and Google fees are a dramatic improvement over the model that they gradually replaced over the past decade. Want to get on a retail shelf? Nope, you can't. One in a zillion odds you find someone to publish your box to retail - congratulations, now you get to keep less tha…

I don’t know where to start with this. Antitrust is specifically about big corporations, that’s the whole point. We treat them differently. You’re saying if the market was opened up, prices would drop due to competition, so that means it shouldn’t be opened up? You think Apple’s in a situation where it has an unfair burden despite being one of the largest companies in the world?

Re: Apple apologizes to WordPress, won’t force the free app to add purchases

#92
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I'm pretty sure that will have massive opposition, because they are deathly scared of opening their devices back to the general-purpose computers they actually are. Who's the opposition coming from? Apple? They can fart around and waste time and money on appeals, but if they get hit with an antitrust ruling there isn't much they'll be able to do about it.

So tell me again when an “antitrust” ruling has ever been applied to a company with less than 50%?

> So tell me again when an “antitrust” ruling has ever been applied to a company with less than 50%?

50% of what is the issue, though. Some arbitrary descriptive market the target company preferred to be used for the antitrust analysis, or the actual market in which substitution, and thus actual competition, occurs as found by the court hearing the case?

Because defining the relevant market is not infrequently a contentious point in antitrust.

Re: Apple apologizes to WordPress, won’t force the free app to add purchases

#93
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> [..] and its monopolistic anti-competitive practices, iOS owns 25% of the market. How is that a monopoly? You might not like their policies, but as you mention, you have a choice to move to a competitor with a vastly larger market share. > I'm better off turning to the Play Store or one of the many other app stores that can be used on Android devices. Doesn't this demonstrate that the Apple AppStore isn't a monopol…

a) Global market share is irrelevant, show US share, which is about 51/49 b) Apple makes up the plurality of all store revenues, despite having a smaller install base both globally and in the US. c) You can display monopolistic/duopoly behavior without having 100% of the market.

Ok so when was 49% considered a “monopoly”. Can you name one incident in case law where that was the case?

Re: Apple apologizes to WordPress, won’t force the free app to add purchases

#94

As an app developer myself, with apps on both the Google Play Store and the App Store with over 250K monthly active users, I have become so frustrated with Apple's arbitrary and capricious enforcement of its App Store regulations, its bullying and coercion of developers, its extortionate fees, and its monopolistic anti-competitive practices, that I have stopped updating my apps on the App Store. I wonder how many oth…

Another shout out for WSL2. Feels good to have real Linux not Apple's kind of close but not quite, plus wide range of hardware to choose from and compatibility with commercial GUI apps.

Re: Apple apologizes to WordPress, won’t force the free app to add purchases

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> its extortionate fees Their fees are not so high as to be extortionate. They're not close to being deserving of that hyperbolic label. The Apple and Google fees are a dramatic improvement over the model that they gradually replaced over the past decade. Want to get on a retail shelf? Nope, you can't. One in a zillion odds you find someone to publish your box to retail - congratulations, now you get to keep less tha…

I don’t know where to start with this. Antitrust is specifically about big corporations, that’s the whole point. We treat them differently. You’re saying if the market was opened up, prices would drop due to competition, so that means it shouldn’t be opened up? You think Apple’s in a situation where it has an unfair burden despite being one of the largest companies in the world?

So I am sure you have case law showing where anti trust charges were filed against a company with 50% market share.

Re: Apple apologizes to WordPress, won’t force the free app to add purchases

#96

Really at this point Apple control over app store is anti-competitive (and Google over play store), having to rely on community outrage to get stuff like this turned is ridiculous. They should create legislation to control access to all app stores to prevent this rent seeking - force app stores to treat all apps equally according to store defined guidelines (including store owners apps) - any submissions have to be r…

No business treats all users equally. Businesses make deals with other businesses all the time. Look up “no duty to deal”.

Re: Apple apologizes to WordPress, won’t force the free app to add purchases

#97
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> [..] and its monopolistic anti-competitive practices, iOS owns 25% of the market. How is that a monopoly? You might not like their policies, but as you mention, you have a choice to move to a competitor with a vastly larger market share. > I'm better off turning to the Play Store or one of the many other app stores that can be used on Android devices. Doesn't this demonstrate that the Apple AppStore isn't a monopol…

a) Global market share is irrelevant, show US share, which is about 51/49 b) Apple makes up the plurality of all store revenues, despite having a smaller install base both globally and in the US. c) You can display monopolistic/duopoly behavior without having 100% of the market.

b) isn't it fair then that Apple charges a premium for access to a better market segment?

Re: Apple apologizes to WordPress, won’t force the free app to add purchases

#98
post #81

Really at this point Apple control over app store is anti-competitive (and Google over play store), having to rely on community outrage to get stuff like this turned is ridiculous. They should create legislation to control access to all app stores to prevent this rent seeking - force app stores to treat all apps equally according to store defined guidelines (including store owners apps) - any submissions have to be r…

> They should create legislation to control access to all app stores to prevent this rent seeking You have a lot of faith in 60+ year old (mostly tech-illiterate men) to fix technology they don't understand. Government isn't the solution to this problem. Developers leaving the app store is probably only what will get Apple to change.

Sure they understand. Did you hear all of the insightful questions that the representatives asked Zuckerberg? Especially when they asked Zuckerburg about Twitter’s policies.

Re: Apple apologizes to WordPress, won’t force the free app to add purchases

#99

Really at this point Apple control over app store is anti-competitive (and Google over play store), having to rely on community outrage to get stuff like this turned is ridiculous. They should create legislation to control access to all app stores to prevent this rent seeking - force app stores to treat all apps equally according to store defined guidelines (including store owners apps) - any submissions have to be r…

Im not really into congress defining how apps get reviewed. I’d rather see it just get broken up in some way. Either you can’t have a phone and an app store (like the studio/movie model) or they at least have to support other app stores. Side note: my iPhone autocorrected app store to App Store, which I think is another example of overreach.

The studio/movie regulation was overturned....

Re: Apple apologizes to WordPress, won’t force the free app to add purchases

#100

As an app developer myself, with apps on both the Google Play Store and the App Store with over 250K monthly active users, I have become so frustrated with Apple's arbitrary and capricious enforcement of its App Store regulations, its bullying and coercion of developers, its extortionate fees, and its monopolistic anti-competitive practices, that I have stopped updating my apps on the App Store. I wonder how many oth…

Just wanted to say, as someone who's been a fervent Apple fan since 2007, getting a Pixel was the best tech decision I've made in years :)
Post reply on HN