Live data from Hacker News

How Carrots Became the new Junk Food

fastcompany.com

61–70 of 85 posts

Re: How Carrots Became the new Junk Food

#62
post #35
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Out of curiosity: I have a friend who had the same allergy... she switched to purely organic carrots and it went away. Does it work the same way with your wife?

I get allergies to them too (plus apples, bananas, strawberries, and a bunch of other fruit). The weird thing is that I could eat all of these things probably up until my early 20s (late 1990s), and now all I can do is stare and salivate.

FYI Mars bars help control the salivation.

Re: How Carrots Became the new Junk Food

#63
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I stopped buying baby carrots when I found out that they are just big carrots cut down. They aren't picked early or anything. Thus, a lot of waste is created to make baby carrots.

Shaved carrots.

Single, dual, multi-blade or electric? Seriously, do you go for the clean contoured shave or multifaceted polygonal surfacing? Is a shave effectively different from peeling?

Re: How Carrots Became the new Junk Food

#65
post #59
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Out of curiosity: I have a friend who had the same allergy... she switched to purely organic carrots and it went away. Does it work the same way with your wife?

Well, not exactly sure, but for apples (also triggers her allergies) organic doesn't help. All of these she had no reactions when she lived in France. Guess we should try the organic carrots some time.

Rather than thinking organic/inorganic, why not try different varieties of carrots? If you can't find a retailer that sells named varieties, try growing your own because seeds are always sold with the name. There's all sorts of types and colours:

http://www.carrotmuseum.co.uk/today.html

Re: How Carrots Became the new Junk Food

#66
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I get allergies to them too (plus apples, bananas, strawberries, and a bunch of other fruit). The weird thing is that I could eat all of these things probably up until my early 20s (late 1990s), and now all I can do is stare and salivate.

FYI Mars bars help control the salivation.

Well, I'm allergic to those too, so it isn't much help ;)

Re: How Carrots Became the new Junk Food

#67
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's interesting. How can I learn more?

That's a good question. Debunking of the glycemic index as a dietary guideline isn't where most diet-focused scientists spend their time, since it's not where gains are to be found (everyone, except people pushing GI-oriented diets, knows that carrots are healthier than candy bars). I came to the conclusion that looking at GI was a loony way to determine diet while researching Gary Taubes and the Good Calories, Bad C…

I'm not sure how relevant Gary Taubes is to the subject of carrots. In his latest book, "Why We Get Fat", carrots aren't mentioned in the text at all, only in an appendix which spells out a Duke University Medical Center diet.

For those who don't read all the way to the end of the sixth page at _Reason_, Taubes has a response[1] to his critic, Fumento.

Contrary to your assertion about Taubes "first making a name for himself" back in 2003, he's been a science writer for something like 30 years. He won an MIT journalism fellowship back in 1996 and he's won three awards from the National Association of Science Writers.[2]

I also don't know about the "religious fervor" of Taubes' anti-carbohydrate stance. He's made it clear, for example, that not all carbohydrates are the same, just as not all fats are bad for you. I think his main point is that the post WW2 infatuation with low-fat diets has been a disaster.

Both Taubes and Fumento are bright fellows who write about controversial areas of science, so it's not a big surprise that they might disagree on a topic. But it's pretty easy to tell the difference between them: Taubes is the one with masters degrees in engineering and journalism and writes articles for _Science_, while Fumento is the one whose degree is in law and writes articles for _Reason_.

[1] http://reason.com/archives/2003/03/01/an-exercise-in-vitriol...

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gary_Taubes

Re: How Carrots Became the new Junk Food

#68

I know why baby carrot sales flatlined. Every bag I buy is slimy. Something changed in the pipeline/process and now they are disgusting.

It's (slightly) more work, but a quick rinse under the tap fixes that.

You know its a bacterial film you're trying to wash off, right? Short of alcohol or some antiseptic, its still completely disgusting.

Re: How Carrots Became the new Junk Food

#69
post #14

I know why baby carrot sales flatlined. Every bag I buy is slimy. Something changed in the pipeline/process and now they are disgusting.

for me, it was more simple. baby carrots are crazy expensive compared to normal carrots. i decided i was perfectly fine eating normal carrots instead.

Try growing some carrots of your own. Way cheaper than buying them, gives you a sense of pride in your own work, really easy to grow, basically just requires sprinkling seeds in the spring and pulling them out of the ground and washing them off when they get big enough.

Re: How Carrots Became the new Junk Food

#70
post #48

Missed the best reason carrots are like junk food: they're sweet.

But they have a lot of fiber which is supposed to be the antidote for sweet.

Fiber slows digestion, which (according to my limited understanding) mitigates the blood insulin spike which is the main fault of fructose - but I wouldn't really call that mitigation an "antidote".
Post reply on HN