Live data from Hacker News

Patrick McKenzie (patio11) on Japan Aid: Help for the Well-Prepared

nytimes.com

71–73 of 73 posts

Re: Patrick McKenzie (patio11) on Japan Aid: Help for the Well-Prepared

#71
post #64
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Randomly jumping on a flight into Japan to wander around asking people in English if they need help is obviously stupid. But that's not just stupid for Japan, that's stupid for pretty much everywhere. Pointing out its stupidity isn't useful - people who would do that aren't listening to you anyways - so why conflate that sort of behavior with simple, non-disruptive, non-panic-inducing actions like donating money to t…

they'll spend it somewhere else "Spend it somewhere else" was exactly what I wrote in my blog post, but when the New York Times says "We can give you three hundred words" then Priority #1 is "Don't Panic" and Priority #Left_On_Cutting_Room_Floor is explaining to people how relief organizations actually operate.

"Everything you actually could do is worthless to us, but please send all possible help for this scary thing that you don't understand and can't possibly actually assist with" is the opposite of "Don't Panic". It conveys helplessness and disempowers your readers.

Re: Patrick McKenzie (patio11) on Japan Aid: Help for the Well-Prepared

#72
post #71
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

they'll spend it somewhere else "Spend it somewhere else" was exactly what I wrote in my blog post, but when the New York Times says "We can give you three hundred words" then Priority #1 is "Don't Panic" and Priority #Left_On_Cutting_Room_Floor is explaining to people how relief organizations actually operate.

"Everything you actually could do is worthless to us, but please send all possible help for this scary thing that you don't understand and can't possibly actually assist with" is the opposite of "Don't Panic". It conveys helplessness and disempowers your readers.

That's the opposite of how I read that. I take it as a comfort that they're doing their best, and they're the best at what they're doing. If they needed food or money, I would gladly send it, but he's saying they don't. Great!

Re: Patrick McKenzie (patio11) on Japan Aid: Help for the Well-Prepared

#73
post #15
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Japan has a population of ~ 300 million and is one of the most advanced and wealthiest nations on Earth. I am sure those affected need help but what makes you think others can provide help better/faster then Japan itself can? Perhaps the US navy has lifting capacity that Japan could use, but what else?

Actually, the population of Japan is about 127 million. http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=population+of+japan

Huh, where did I even get the 300 number? I was sure of it! Kids, don't trust your brain, check the facts you think you know!
Post reply on HN