Live data from Hacker News

I bought netflix.soy

tinyprojects.dev

251–260 of 272 posts

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#251

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Arbitration through UDRP is expensive, both in terms of process costs and employee time. A reasonable company would probably pay more than registration costs to avoid it.

Not if you take into account that they also want to deter future cybersquatting.

Covering actual costs without significant profit is a deterrent. If it costs $20 to register and you ask for $30 I think you're likely to get it.

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#253

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For anyone unfamiliar, this is a clever riff on a classic economics joke about the Efficient Market Hypothesis [1]. "Two economists are walking down the street and one of them notices what appears to be a $20 bill (or a $100 bill—the monetary amounts vary) on the sidewalk. “It’s not a real $20 bill,” the other economist declares. “If it were a real $20 bill, someone would have picked it up off the sidewalk already.”…

Except the $20 bill in this case is a $-10 bill (or whatever the domain name costs), as there is no profit to be made by registering a top company's trademark as a domain name.

I wouldn't necessarily think like that.

A domain can be either resold to another third party or could be sold to the trademark owner itself. You might reach a price agreement that brings you some money and costs the trademark owner less than getting a lawyer involved.

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#254

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Arbitration through UDRP is expensive, both in terms of process costs and employee time. A reasonable company would probably pay more than registration costs to avoid it.

You're underestimating how much value there is to companies in setting precedent on defending their trademark with an easy and practically guaranteed win. Companies need to proactively defend their trademark when it's being infringed upon or they risk losing it, and this is a really easy way to defend it.

The precedent is already established, you're missing the point: in order to enforce such precedent you have to go to court anyway.

And that costs money.

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#255
post #225
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's worth noting that MarkMonitor ownership has changed in recent years. Regardless, they certainly can register all the names for you, if that's what you ask them to do, but at some point, there's an awful lot of names, and it feels extortiony to pay for them all. I was working for a MarkMonitor client when the 'landrush' for all these new tlds was happening, and we'd get frequent emails about which tlds were going…

When you mention the change of ownership, I assume that there's an implication there, but would you be willing to be explicit about it?

They're owned by a VC firm now, which I suspect means they'll need to change how they operate in order to show growth. That's not what I would want in a registrar I'm counting on for absolute stability of domain names for my hypothetical big/important company.

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#256

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Now this a valid reason to give your kid the surname of a brand. To get rich quick. Too bad that this also limits employment options in the long run (can you imagine Google to work for Amazon?)

Except having the name is not enough, you also need to have used it in business already. Happens all the time, as many brand names come from family names and the founder isn't the only person bearing that name.

>you also need to have used it in business already.

What is this based on? Because surely I have the right to own mylastname.suffix without being a business even if someone decides to make a business that bears my family name.

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#257

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Free speech is a right issued by governments to the people. It is not a valid concept between two private parties. https://money.cnn.com/2017/08/08/technology/google-workplace...

Yes, but the argument GP responded to was that "ICANN enforces trademark rights on domains" and that "If the trademark already existed when you bought the domain, and especially if it's widely used and ambiguous, you're gonna lose that domain if the company comes after you." He argues that the practice has its basis in trademark laws. If it is so, nominative use of a trademark to e.g. criticize a product is considere…

I agree in that perhaps entities with a public platform (in this case, literally the internet domain) should be compelled to provide reasonably equal access/equal speech rights to everybody.

However, the law is not in that rationale's favor. US courts have repeatedly rejected the argument that private companies are state actors subject to the 1st Amendment [0].

The reality is that the internet is governed almost entirely by private companies.

https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R45650

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#258
post #206

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure, if your name is Mike Google, then you might have better chances at keeping your domain. Probably still not good chances to profit off of it.

Now this a valid reason to give your kid the surname of a brand. To get rich quick. Too bad that this also limits employment options in the long run (can you imagine Google to work for Amazon?)

Might be less limiting than you think.

There was famously an apple store employee called "Sam Sung" - https://www.cultofmac.com/290116/sam-sung-auctioning-apple-s...

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#259
post #61
post #7

I'm from Israel, and this is the first time I've heard about the .קום tld. I've never seen any website that uses it. The author mentioned that creating a new tld costs a minimum of 185k USD. This makes me wonder who would pay this kind of money for this completely useless tld.

.קום is just .com transliterated into Hebrew letters, right? That actually seems quite useful, if people are typing not realizing the keyboard is set to Hebrew.

If the keyboard was set to Hebrew then the subdomain would also be spelled out in the wrong characters, so the URL would be nonsense or go to a different site. Additionally, as people mentioned, the standard Hebrew layout is incompatible with QUERTY (I am a Hebrew speaker and have never heard of the phonetic Hebrew layout you linked to). Also when you type the URL the characters would be spelled out in the oppose right-to-left direction as .com.

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#260

> Did you know it costs a minimum of $185,000 to create your own domain name ending? If I were a blackhat with money, I'd register the ".con" TLD. ... Sure hoping a whitehat gets it first.

At least it would be self-descriptive! :D

Another self-descriptive one would be .orc
Post reply on HN