Live data from Hacker News

IMF Says Great Lockdown Recession Likely Worst Since Depression

bloomberg.com

41–50 of 134 posts

Re: IMF Says Great Lockdown Recession Likely Worst Since Depression

#41

This certainly feels real to me. Yesterday, I was laid off from my job at Easypost. We had a very big and very painful layoff because my company took on way too much leverage. The circumstances of COVID19 were tough to foresee but I really wish we hadn't taken on so much debt while times were good. I have experience in Go, Ruby, Python and I'm excited to hack again.

Best of luck finding your next job. It can be hard while you're searching, but some how it always works out for the best.

Re: IMF Says Great Lockdown Recession Likely Worst Since Depression

#42

The unemployment rate isn't even close to the 10% we saw after the '08 recession. Only about half. Does that mean that twice as many people are going to become unemployed, than are right now?

We won't have the numbers for sure until the end of the month, but based on the insane spike in initial claims [0], the US probably hit 10% last week [1].

That said, the past two weeks the claims seem to have hit their processing limit, with people still not getting through - it's guaranteed to continue rising for the rest of the month, past the numbers I have here.

[0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ICSA

[1] 3.3 million + 6.8 + 6.6 = 16.7 million, 16.7 / 160 million (number I've seen for estimated working-age people) = 10.4%, 10.4% + 4% (previous unemployment rate) = 14.4%

Quick edit, unemployment rate is updated monthly here: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNRATE - based on when it updated, that 3.3 million is already included in the 4.4%, so actually more like 4.4% + ((6.8 + 6.6) / 160) = 12.8%-ish (and more than likely still rising)

Re: IMF Says Great Lockdown Recession Likely Worst Since Depression

#43

The unemployment rate isn't even close to the 10% we saw after the '08 recession. Only about half. Does that mean that twice as many people are going to become unemployed, than are right now?

I think that's the case. Even when lockdowns start being lifted, people won't have money to spend, meaning more companies closing doors...

Re: IMF Says Great Lockdown Recession Likely Worst Since Depression

#44
I find myself less interested in whether or not something is a recession or not. I mean, sure, the numbers of the economy are going down, but the big numbers don't necessarily mean much for anyone's personal life. Of course it can; losing your job is no fun. But the big reason why the Great Depression was so bad, is that we didn't have any social security back then. Unemployed meant having no income at all. No health insurance, no pensions, none of the things that people started fighting for exactly because of the Great Depression.

And because of that, these recessions and depressions are far less devastating than they used to.

Of course I'm saying this living in a rich country that does have all of these amenities; in poorer countries that don't yet take care of their poor (and possibly the US that chooses not to take care of its poor), things may still feel like the 1930s. But in a rich, well-organised country, there's really no need for that anymore. We can easily get through this is we want to. Skip a vacation, buy a luxury item less, make sure the poorest don't fall through the cracks (and there will be more cracks of course), and we'll be fine. The misery is mostly a political decision.

Re: IMF Says Great Lockdown Recession Likely Worst Since Depression

#45

The unemployment rate isn't even close to the 10% we saw after the '08 recession. Only about half. Does that mean that twice as many people are going to become unemployed, than are right now?

16 million people filled for unemployment. We are way over 10% now. They haven't announced the new rate.

Re: IMF Says Great Lockdown Recession Likely Worst Since Depression

#46

The unemployment rate isn't even close to the 10% we saw after the '08 recession. Only about half. Does that mean that twice as many people are going to become unemployed, than are right now?

Whoa... https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/unemployment-rate

Re: IMF Says Great Lockdown Recession Likely Worst Since Depression

#47
post #30

The important question is whether the recession due to the lockdown (which is at least useful for stopping the virus) will continue after the virus has passed and the lockdown is lifted.

There will be huge shift in structure of business. Many small mom and pop shops are not coming back. Big chains, and franchises survive. Permanent changes in customer behavior. Many people with resistance and habits against 'new ways' are forced to learn internet shopping and delivery. Their habits can change permanently.

I'm sure the stir crazy masses will be able to detach from their dependence on the inflated costs of delivery services.

Re: IMF Says Great Lockdown Recession Likely Worst Since Depression

#48

I don't get what the point of still using the term "recession" is. Even if it's temporary, this is a full-blown depression right?

I think of the word "depression" as a lagging descriptor. It means there have _already_ been two to three years of low or negative GDP growth.

Technically, I think it even takes 2 quarters to call a recession.

But I get your point... even if we don't have the stats for six months or two years, we all know where this is going. It's just the standard terminology doesn't help right now.

Re: IMF Says Great Lockdown Recession Likely Worst Since Depression

#49
post #44

I find myself less interested in whether or not something is a recession or not. I mean, sure, the numbers of the economy are going down, but the big numbers don't necessarily mean much for anyone's personal life. Of course it can; losing your job is no fun. But the big reason why the Great Depression was so bad, is that we didn't have any social security back then. Unemployed meant having no income at all. No health…

If people aren't working and creating a functioning economy, all of those things you described go away. They're tax-dependant. They aren't just whistled up from the wild blue yonder.

Re: IMF Says Great Lockdown Recession Likely Worst Since Depression

#50

I don't get what the point of still using the term "recession" is. Even if it's temporary, this is a full-blown depression right?

How is it a depression if it's only been a few months? Also the IMF article predicts a 3% contraction for 2020 and a 5.8% growth in 2021, so by what definition is this a depression?

A recession is where your neighbor loses their job. A depression is where you lose your job too.
Post reply on HN