Live data from Hacker News

Venezuelan ship sinks itself after ramming cruise liner with a reinforced hull

thedrive.com

51–60 of 164 posts

Re: Venezuelan ship sinks itself after ramming cruise liner with a reinforced hull

#51
post #23

This is insane. I can't imagine what was going through the Venezuelan captain's head trying to do this. It's one thing if the shooting is already started to defend yourself. But even if this stunt had worked, you're looking at many months of downtime while your ship is being repaired in drydock. Millions of dollars, and bigtime loss of capability for a small navy. Unless you are an icebreaker, you just don't intentio…

Venezuela has a habit (recently) of putting loyalty ahead of meritocracy in government positions. I would not be at all surprised if the captain had minimal actual nautical experience, but a lot of party loyalty.

Re: Venezuelan ship sinks itself after ramming cruise liner with a reinforced hull

#52
post #45
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not what I meant. Could be there as an excuse loaded with drugs so the navy then can move in. Iraq was invaded under the false pretence of the weapons of mass destruction which didn't exist and UN observers proved so 1 week before Invasion. Panama was invaded under the excuse of drug war. Planting drugs to justify the invasion wouldn't be much of a stretch. Pretty bad luck that 1 of 3 reinforced cruise just drifts to…

Except in your examples nobody needed to stage something like a cruise ship stuffed with drugs, they just made their case and did whatever. There is no need for staging anything, nobody would need a cruise ship full of drugs to think that drugs are coming out of Venezuela... Staging an event with a cruise ship as an excuse when they could just do the thing anyway seems like an overly complicated conspiracy theory.

There were staged news, like newspaper articles showing in astonishing detail Saddam's biological and chemical weapons, which oops didn't exist. Also check where the La Tortuga island is located, It's right next to the coast, surrounded by other island, pretty dangerous location to just be drifting without paying attention to where you are.

I'm not saying, that's definitely the reason they are there, I'm saying it's pretty weird and odd timing to suspect ulterior motives.

Re: Venezuelan ship sinks itself after ramming cruise liner with a reinforced hull

#55

Trump recently announced we are doubling the size of southern command and dramatically increasing our activity off the coast of Venezuela, where this occurred. Could the cruise ship have been doing something sneaky?

Trump announced it to distract from covid-19. Saber rattling in both South America and Iran.

Re: Venezuelan ship sinks itself after ramming cruise liner with a reinforced hull

#56
post #52
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except in your examples nobody needed to stage something like a cruise ship stuffed with drugs, they just made their case and did whatever. There is no need for staging anything, nobody would need a cruise ship full of drugs to think that drugs are coming out of Venezuela... Staging an event with a cruise ship as an excuse when they could just do the thing anyway seems like an overly complicated conspiracy theory.

There were staged news, like newspaper articles showing in astonishing detail Saddam's biological and chemical weapons, which oops didn't exist. Also check where the La Tortuga island is located, It's right next to the coast, surrounded by other island, pretty dangerous location to just be drifting without paying attention to where you are. I'm not saying, that's definitely the reason they are there, I'm saying it's…

That's my point, someone could just lie on TV...no need to stage something with a cruise ship.

Re: Venezuelan ship sinks itself after ramming cruise liner with a reinforced hull

#57
post #33
post #23

This is insane. I can't imagine what was going through the Venezuelan captain's head trying to do this. It's one thing if the shooting is already started to defend yourself. But even if this stunt had worked, you're looking at many months of downtime while your ship is being repaired in drydock. Millions of dollars, and bigtime loss of capability for a small navy. Unless you are an icebreaker, you just don't intentio…

I mean, less crazy than trying to ram a ship with a locomotive I suppose: https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/0... https://in.reuters.com/video/watch/idOVC7T0OCH Strange days.

TIL there is actually a specific US federal law against "wrecking trains".

https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-2000-t...

Re: Venezuelan ship sinks itself after ramming cruise liner with a reinforced hull

#58
post #23

This is insane. I can't imagine what was going through the Venezuelan captain's head trying to do this. It's one thing if the shooting is already started to defend yourself. But even if this stunt had worked, you're looking at many months of downtime while your ship is being repaired in drydock. Millions of dollars, and bigtime loss of capability for a small navy. Unless you are an icebreaker, you just don't intentio…

Ramming (or "shouldering") is not that uncommon. The Chinese Coast Guard has built large, lightly-armed ships[1] partly because the size helps them ram/shoulder other ships out of the way in the course of attempting to build artificial islands and claim sovereignty in the South China Sea.

Of course, ramming an 8500-ton icebreaker with a 1500-ton corvette is a different story, and in the Venezuelan case, the stupid have been punished.

[1] https://thediplomat.com/2016/01/beijing-builds-monster-ship-...

(edited for grammar)

Re: Venezuelan ship sinks itself after ramming cruise liner with a reinforced hull

#59
post #32
post #23

This is insane. I can't imagine what was going through the Venezuelan captain's head trying to do this. It's one thing if the shooting is already started to defend yourself. But even if this stunt had worked, you're looking at many months of downtime while your ship is being repaired in drydock. Millions of dollars, and bigtime loss of capability for a small navy. Unless you are an icebreaker, you just don't intentio…

Well, ramming used to be BIG: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Lissa_(1866) One can't possibly blame the captain wanting to be as cool as admiral Tegetthoff back then: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Anton_Romako_001.jpg

No need to go that far back. One famous one is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patrol_torpedo_boat_PT-109

Re: Venezuelan ship sinks itself after ramming cruise liner with a reinforced hull

#60
post #23

This is insane. I can't imagine what was going through the Venezuelan captain's head trying to do this. It's one thing if the shooting is already started to defend yourself. But even if this stunt had worked, you're looking at many months of downtime while your ship is being repaired in drydock. Millions of dollars, and bigtime loss of capability for a small navy. Unless you are an icebreaker, you just don't intentio…

Ramming (or "shouldering") is not that uncommon. The Chinese Coast Guard has built large, lightly-armed ships[1] partly because the size helps them ram/shoulder other ships out of the way in the course of attempting to build artificial islands and claim sovereignty in the South China Sea. Of course, ramming an 8500-ton icebreaker with a 1500-ton corvette is a different story, and in the Venezuelan case, the stupid ha…

The Russians also used ramming to capture several Ukrainian ships near Crimea.
Post reply on HN