Live data from Hacker News

The Virus Can Be Stopped, but Only with Harsh Steps, Experts Say

nytimes.com

131–140 of 176 posts

Re: The Virus Can Be Stopped, but Only with Harsh Steps, Experts Say

#131

South Korea has virtually no new active cases daily, only 100 deaths after 4 months of exposure and hasn't brought in any laws even close the authoritarian stuff that is going on elsewhere across the planet in the name of covid-19/sars-cov-2 Buyer beware. Undoing laws and measures is a lot harder than enacting them in a "crisis". "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deser…

Benjamin Franklin also never fought a planet-wide virus.

Re: The Virus Can Be Stopped, but Only with Harsh Steps, Experts Say

#132
post #8

There is no way to stop the virus in the US - 10 million undocumented immigrants in the US can not afford to sit at home and watch TV for 3 months, they can't help you to do your fancy contact tracing to expose their families and friends who are also undocumented. They can't afford to be tested or treated as none of them will be on the government hands out list. How could you stop the coronavirus when 10 million REAL…

Yes, during a global pandemic crisis like this, undocumented immigrants are the problem. I bet every single one of those people in Disney World last week, partygoers in New Orleans, and spring break beach students were overwhelmingly not undocumented immigrants. Fear mongering a disenfranchised population will get you nowhere.

As a resident of New Orleans I can categorically tell you 99% of those assholes in the pictures on Bourbon St were tourists taking advantage of cheap tickets

Re: The Virus Can Be Stopped, but Only with Harsh Steps, Experts Say

#133
post #126
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is no evidence that dogs can spread coronavirus to humans. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prepare/animals.ht...

Yes there is evidence. From Pro-Med Mail: A second PCR-positive dog, Hong Kong https://promedmail.org/promed-post/?id=7112693 Apparently it was a very old dog though. Published Date: 2020-03-19 15:56:45 Subject: PRO/AH/EDR> COVID-19 update (45): China (Hong Kong) animal, dog, 2nd case PCR positive Archive Number: 20200319.7112693

Not sure if you missed the "dogs can spread coronavirus to humans" part but the source you linked finishes with this:

> The spokesman emphasised [SIC] that there is currently no evidence that pet animals can be a source of COVID-19 for humans or that this virus can cause the disease in dogs

Re: The Virus Can Be Stopped, but Only with Harsh Steps, Experts Say

#134
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is no evidence that dogs can spread coronavirus to humans. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prepare/animals.ht...

So what happens if I have covid19, I pet or hug a dog, and five minutes later someone else touches it? The virus suddenly disappears across the entire dog's surface?

Now I agree with your general sentiment but can't help but feel the unhelpful tone in your finishing question. We might as well do without that. You can frame your messages to be less hostile without loosing the meaning of what you want to write.

Re: The Virus Can Be Stopped, but Only with Harsh Steps, Experts Say

#135
post #5

If there’s anything the current debacles in Europe and the U.S. has taught us, it’s that selfish and/or irrational jerks abound, and asking nicely doesn’t work at all.

I believe that the trend to call vast numbers of people selfish and irrational is itself inaccurate and part of in group psychology. People who are not like our group are immoral. Perhaps someone is struggling with drugs or mental issues or poverty and needs to go out, perhaps there are other factors which should not be waved way as selfishness or being jerks? How can you tell? It's easier not to bother and have less…

I know this is a little politically incorrect an opinion for HN: While there are definitely people with underlying issues (drugs, poverty, mental health), many people are simply narcissistic jerks by nature, for no real reason. Asking nicely and pleading for them to behave will not work, nor will shaming misbehavior. Jerks respond only to incentives and disincentives.

Without enforcement, all these "orders" about distancing and sheltering in place and not hoarding are just going to be ignored by the jerks, like any rule without enforcement.

Re: The Virus Can Be Stopped, but Only with Harsh Steps, Experts Say

#136
post #8

There is no way to stop the virus in the US - 10 million undocumented immigrants in the US can not afford to sit at home and watch TV for 3 months, they can't help you to do your fancy contact tracing to expose their families and friends who are also undocumented. They can't afford to be tested or treated as none of them will be on the government hands out list. How could you stop the coronavirus when 10 million REAL…

This is a well thought out insightful comment. The current downvotes and comments against it say a lot about HN and why we really can't tackle this virus. We can't even take on another species attacking human kind logically.

The author’s rhetoric is likely the cause of the downvotes, in particular focusing explicitly on “undocumented immigrants” when there seems to be no evidence that this group of people presents any greater (or lesser) risk than other groups that share their socioeconomic or demographic status.

To contrast with your interpretation, I found the author’s comment to be unnecessarily divisive.

Consider, for example, that Asian people are being harassed and assaulted in response to how aspects of this pandemic have been framed.

Now consider the response that the author’s comment might incite towards demographics associated with undocumented immigrants, in light of this, given that there is no reason to believe the premise.

Re: The Virus Can Be Stopped, but Only with Harsh Steps, Experts Say

#137

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This. I'm terrified by the number of utter idiots violating the restrictions and putting so many vulnerable people at risk. Or those people recorded while spreading their spit all over a train cart. Where is this coming from? What is those people's end game? It can't be due to stupidity; there must be some malice in this behaviour as well, right?

I don't think there is any malice, it's just ignorance. We're in uncharted territory here and people have no idea how to behave. Not to mention humans are social creatures and it's very much against our instincts to be shut-ins that don't interact.

> We’re in uncharted territory here [...]

Small point of disagreement on this one. There may not be a 1:1 correspondence between what’s happening now and any exact historical event, but I would have hoped that traditionally Western nations would have studied countries affected by SARS (et al.) and learned from their successes/failures.

Re: The Virus Can Be Stopped, but Only with Harsh Steps, Experts Say

#138
post #26
post #8

There is no way to stop the virus in the US - 10 million undocumented immigrants in the US can not afford to sit at home and watch TV for 3 months, they can't help you to do your fancy contact tracing to expose their families and friends who are also undocumented. They can't afford to be tested or treated as none of them will be on the government hands out list. How could you stop the coronavirus when 10 million REAL…

I see you're being downvoted, but I don't sense any malice in your post. You're also not incorrect in your assessment, but your scope is a bit limited. There are far more than just undocumented immigrants who can't afford to stay home and will have to do whatever they can do to keep life going for themselves. This is true everywhere, not just the US. The last to comply won't be holding out due to malice or ignorance,…

Immigration status has absolutely nothing to do with it. There are undocumented immigrants who can afford it, and undocumented immigrants who cannot. The relevant factor is someone's financial position, not their immigration status. Regardless of intent, the parent comment singles out a demonized population of people. This is not constructive or helpful.

Re: The Virus Can Be Stopped, but Only with Harsh Steps, Experts Say

#139

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Economic, pollution data is similarly manipulated. Local officials have incentives to misreport this data. Why should infection data be any different? The current CCP narrative is that all new cases are imported. Do you find this credible?

> pollution data is similarly manipulated Even the satellite measurements NASA shoots? I'd sincerely like to see the tech behind that coverup!

I'm not sure why you would bring NASA into this conversation.

https://www.nber.org/papers/w18729

Re: The Virus Can Be Stopped, but Only with Harsh Steps, Experts Say

#140
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ve watched every one of Cuomo’s press conferences. He message is always clear - that we are trying to not overwhelm the health system. He doesn’t say “flatten the curve” because he believes words matter and tries to communicate to avoid panic (Hence his refusal to call “Stay Indoors” as “Shelter in Place”) But the medical side of the state government - along with their action - has been consistently flatten the cur…

> call “Stay Indoors” as “Shelter in Place” This piece of this story is utterly fascinating to me right now. It's like half the population has a completely different interpretation of the phrase shelter-in-place. I feel like it's entirely too vague and has led to a situation where, in my neck of the woods in Orange county, CA, people are using the ambiguous language to justify going about their daily lives. Where, to…

I had to venture out Friday in NYC and parks and streets were filled with people. Lines to get cocktails going down the street. Basketball games. No one wearing masks. For the first time since it started I started to be worried about my family and myself.

I think "Stay In Your Home" or "Stay the Fk Home" are needed as daily SMS messages and voicemails.

Post reply on HN