Live data from Hacker News

Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars

governor.wa.gov

391–400 of 568 posts

Re: Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars

#391
post #336

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Money purely reflects consumer confidence, and as long as the economy is based on money, so does the entire economy.

Not really. There's tons of steady demand to drive money forward. You can double or half average consumer confidence and it won't change the price of a burger or a t-shirt.

One consumer? No. All consumers, it definitely will.

Re: Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars

#392
post #174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

HN's culture against partisan political statements looks particularly like sticking one's head in the sand these days. Coronavirus is not a political thing, but our (partisan) elected leaders had an enormous amount of power over how prepared we were, and their agendas shape the on-going response. It's impossible to talk accurately about the problem or solution without mentioning parties and politicians by name.

This is crazy. There is nothing any party could do to have prevented the virus from reaching the United States, aside from a complete shutdown of the borders, including for American citizens. It is too transmissible, too undetectable, etc, to prevent it. Containment is the only feasible option, and America is actually ahead of the curve. Unlike Italy and France and Europe, American states are shutting down before hos…

Of course we could have contained it. See Taiwan for a golden example. About one case per day since this started.

China, Japan, and South Korea or other examples.

Re: Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars

#393
post #275

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree that "millions will die" is just pure panic. But I'd like to point out that China is most definitely _not_ out of the woods yet. And won't be until there's a cure. This merry-go-round could start again there at a moment's notice.

I don't get this sentiment, I mean numbers are pretty clear at this point. We have +-2% mortality rate, and that when system is not utterly overloaded and those critical patients (15-20%) are getting artificial ventilation and very personalized treatment. Without it, most if not all would die. So real mortality, once health systems will crumble from the load (we will see in 1 week here in Europe), might be more aroun…

You're confusing things. Not everyone who has the disease is diagnosed or treated in a hospital. In fact the majority of people are probably not. As the healthcare system is stressed, you will see higher "mortality" in the hospital cases because only the extremely severe patients will seek treatment and the rest will try to get by on their own. None of this is _population_ mortality. Meaning, these numbers cannot be extrapolated to the population as a whole, due to the selection bias inherent in them, and the lack of accurate infection rate estimates.

Re: Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars

#394
post #88

My Daughter was working as a temp between jobs and the work has now been stopped, she had two second interviews planned in Sydney this week now both positions have been retracted and nobody hiring or interviewing, she has about 7 weeks of cash savings and 4 months lease on a rental. Oh and no unemployment benefit or subsidies as she is New Zealander working in Australia. Young People at the lowest risk from this viru…

From a purely economic perspective, you might be right. However the cost is blood. The mortality rate goes from about 1% to above 3%, since the UK’s hospitals will quickly be overrun.

The cost will be at least the delta 1.3 million preventable deaths. This doesn’t include the hundreds of thousands of folks left with pulmonary fibrosis, which has a 3-5 year life expectancy.

Re: Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars

#395
post #393

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't get this sentiment, I mean numbers are pretty clear at this point. We have +-2% mortality rate, and that when system is not utterly overloaded and those critical patients (15-20%) are getting artificial ventilation and very personalized treatment. Without it, most if not all would die. So real mortality, once health systems will crumble from the load (we will see in 1 week here in Europe), might be more aroun…

You're confusing things. Not everyone who has the disease is diagnosed or treated in a hospital. In fact the majority of people are probably not. As the healthcare system is stressed, you will see higher "mortality" in the hospital cases because only the extremely severe patients will seek treatment and the rest will try to get by on their own. None of this is _population_ mortality. Meaning, these numbers cannot be…

That would cover the sceptical 10%. But OK, lets be really sceptical and have only 1% - still 800k - 4 millions. Sounds a bit like millions to me

Re: Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars

#396

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not really. There's tons of steady demand to drive money forward. You can double or half average consumer confidence and it won't change the price of a burger or a t-shirt.

One consumer? No. All consumers, it definitely will.

How big of an area do you need to see this effect? I've never heard of this kind of pricing difference on a city, county, or state basis.

And the stock market varies wildly on a daily and monthly basis without affecting the prices of almost anything.

It seems clear to me that money is not even close to affected by consumer confidence the way the stock market is.

Re: Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars

#397
post #393

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're confusing things. Not everyone who has the disease is diagnosed or treated in a hospital. In fact the majority of people are probably not. As the healthcare system is stressed, you will see higher "mortality" in the hospital cases because only the extremely severe patients will seek treatment and the rest will try to get by on their own. None of this is _population_ mortality. Meaning, these numbers cannot be…

That would cover the sceptical 10%. But OK, lets be really sceptical and have only 1% - still 800k - 4 millions. Sounds a bit like millions to me

This ignores several things. For one thing we might get a reprieve due to seasonality. For another, better treatments will almost certainly be found in the near future. Some are undergoing trials as we speak. Then there's the issue of people who will acquire immunity and therefore cease to be transmission vectors. And then there's the most glaring issue: less than 6K people are likely to die in the _very epicenter_ of the epidemic: in China. Out of 55M people in that region. People are returning to work there now. So this can be contained, with drastic measures. And you can bet drastic measures will be taken if we even begin to approach seven figure casualty counts. Extrapolated from 55M Hubei population to 331M of US population, this would be less than 40K dead: on the order of a severe flu season, but compressed into 3 months. That's in the absence of any advanced treatments, and with a healthcare system arguably inferior to what you'd find in the West.

Re: Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars

#398

When talking about economic damage it is also worth thinking about what we are trying to avoid in the US- if SARS-Cov2 gets to 60% of the population, then at a 2% case fatality rate we are looking at 4 million excess deaths. Most importantly, that is a humanitarian tragedy that we must avoid. However, having numbers also let’s us put an economic value out there for what we are trying to save. A 1% reduction in the ca…

I hate myself for saying this but if one wants a cold calculous thought experiment, what about thinking about the mortality age? mostly older people, not only don't work but are also often a net burden to society.

Yes we've already extracted all the value we could extract from them. Better get rid of the useless husks asap.

Do you realize how that sounds?

Re: Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars

#399

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Current total deaths are 6,000 with China already saying the worst is behind them. Why the US would have 4M deaths?

The number coming out of China do not seem... completely above board and have been questioned by many people. Also as other have said, China, being an authoritarian country, had the power to lock down in ways that the US simply is not ready for or willing to put up with. Already in KY we've had a man who refused to self isolate after testing positive so now we have to station someone outside his house. We have 21 cas…

We need a couple more cases like that for people to be out baying for blood and for pandemic-level laws that allow people to be jailed/isolated forcibly.

Re: Washington governor announces shutdown of restaurants, bars

#400

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://i.redd.it/apxxmlc4kfm41.jpg

Interesting, but to truly track similar to Italy wouldn't we need higher numbers being we're a much larger populous? Just curious.

The US isn't doing anywhere near as much testing as Italy.
Post reply on HN