Live data from Hacker News

Ever missed an SMS on your Android? Here's why. (long-standing bug)

code.google.com

21–30 of 69 posts

Re: Ever missed an SMS on your Android? Here's why. (long-standing bug)

#21

tl;dr version: having the 'low space' warning on your Android phone results in the rejection of SMS messages. Even when there's actually e.g. >10mb of storage available. The bug has been present since 2009 and appears not to have been fixed yet by Google.

appears not to have been fixed yet by Google Or by anyone whining on the bug tracker who say this issue is ruining their life.

[deleted]

Re: Ever missed an SMS on your Android? Here's why. (long-standing bug)

#22

tl;dr version: having the 'low space' warning on your Android phone results in the rejection of SMS messages. Even when there's actually e.g. >10mb of storage available. The bug has been present since 2009 and appears not to have been fixed yet by Google.

appears not to have been fixed yet by Google Or by anyone whining on the bug tracker who say this issue is ruining their life.

So, you have to be able to fix bugs in Android if you want to use it? I somehow doubt that Google wants to sell Android phones only to the 20 million developers in the world who could (theoretically) fix bugs.

Re: Ever missed an SMS on your Android? Here's why. (long-standing bug)

#23

This is one of the examples where I'm concerned about my own professionality because i can't grasp why Google would overlook such an error for such a long time. Maybe there is a reason but my feeble mind can't bend around it?

Easily reproducible doesn't equal easily fixed.

Re: Ever missed an SMS on your Android? Here's why. (long-standing bug)

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

appears not to have been fixed yet by Google Or by anyone whining on the bug tracker who say this issue is ruining their life.

I really don't think that the "if you're not happy about a bug, fix it or shut up" mentality in open source projects is very helpful. Obviously solving issues like this is considerably more difficult and time consuming than complaining about them and many people complaining about them don't have the time and/or skills to solve them. However, they are real, existing issues that bother users and not complaining about t…

I think that part of jrockway's point is that at least some of the people complaining on a bug tracker, have the skills to help.

Re: Ever missed an SMS on your Android? Here's why. (long-standing bug)

#25
Because of the high quality of iOS and it's large market reach, Android development had to be rushed a great deal. This caused most of the programming power to go towards developing base features (android 1.x - 2.x) or implementing tablet features when the iPad arrived, and almost no resources were left for developers support (the emulators are awfully slow, severe lack of animations framework, etc...) and for bug fixing. Once things start to settle down, bugs will start to get fixed.

Re: Ever missed an SMS on your Android? Here's why. (long-standing bug)

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

appears not to have been fixed yet by Google Or by anyone whining on the bug tracker who say this issue is ruining their life.

I really don't think that the "if you're not happy about a bug, fix it or shut up" mentality in open source projects is very helpful. Obviously solving issues like this is considerably more difficult and time consuming than complaining about them and many people complaining about them don't have the time and/or skills to solve them. However, they are real, existing issues that bother users and not complaining about t…

In my opinion this mentality is more helpful than spamming bug tracker with "YOU SUCK FOR NOT FIXING THIS!!111eleven!" which seems especially common with Android's bugs. I even assume that such comments actually hamper fixing of respective bugs.

Re: Ever missed an SMS on your Android? Here's why. (long-standing bug)

#27
post #15

I encountered this recently. Really exceptionally poor engineering for a communication device. My solution: flash Cyanogen ROM, force all apps to install to the SD card. No more concerns about running out of internal memory.

> Really exceptionally poor engineering for a communication device.

I disagree. You can not judge their entire engineering based on this particular bug. From my little experience developing an Android application, I have to say that they have done a pretty good job in the engineering/API design part.

Re: Ever missed an SMS on your Android? Here's why. (long-standing bug)

#28

tl;dr version: having the 'low space' warning on your Android phone results in the rejection of SMS messages. Even when there's actually e.g. >10mb of storage available. The bug has been present since 2009 and appears not to have been fixed yet by Google.

I get the low space message with what seems like a fairly limited number of apps installed, caches cleared and as much as possible pushed to SD ... what is the actual capacity there? HTC Incredible in my case ...

AFAIK, HTC Incredible has a bug that makes this warning appear even if you have 800MB+ of free space. The joy of forks… http://www.zdnet.com/blog/google/is-your-droid-incredible-lo...

Re: Ever missed an SMS on your Android? Here's why. (long-standing bug)

#29

Related: I've had all of my SMS messages deleted 3 times on my HTC Incredible from this bug: http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=5669

That's a bad bug.

But I have to say that comment [1] might be going a bit far comparing the loss of some SMSes to the burning of the library of Alexandrina

[1] http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=5669#c415

Re: Ever missed an SMS on your Android? Here's why. (long-standing bug)

#30
Thanks for posting this! Now I finally know why some important texts from business associates never arrived.

I really can't believe this bug made it through to production. Why would carriers accept software with this kind of bug? I know I was blaming my carrier the whole time, and I bet others have been too.

Post reply on HN