Live data from Hacker News

Can You Locate Iran? Few Voters Can

morningconsult.com

31–40 of 104 posts

Re: Can You Locate Iran? Few Voters Can

#31
post #3
post #2

This sort of poll is perennial but never says anything interesting, imo.

I get the impression from the map of responses that many respondents were taking the piss. Who really thinks Iran is Greenland?

Yeah. They probably paid for completion of the poll, and completing the poll required some selection of a location, so a ton of people did exactly that without even reading what the question was.

Re: Can You Locate Iran? Few Voters Can

#32
post #26
post #9

47% supported the strike? How could they possibly have had enough information to support it? Iran = Bad Man from Iran = Bad Kill Man from Iran = Good???

I love and sympathize with your comment heavily. As far as 47% support I think it because: Trump = Good Something Trump ordered = Good

Also, their only news source told them it was a good thing.

Re: Can You Locate Iran? Few Voters Can

#34
post #9

47% supported the strike? How could they possibly have had enough information to support it? Iran = Bad Man from Iran = Bad Kill Man from Iran = Good???

“Every miserable fool who has nothing at all of which he can be proud, adopts as a last resource pride in the nation to which he belongs; he is ready and happy to defend all its faults and follies tooth and nail, thus reimbursing himself for his own inferiority.” ― Arthur Schopenhauer edit: it's easy to read this pridefully yourself ("i have other things to be proud of and therefore i'm immune from such petty things"…

[deleted]

Re: Can You Locate Iran? Few Voters Can

#35
post #27

"Men were about twice as likely as women to be able to identify Iran on both maps" Wow, that's unexpected. Is there some credible source on why this is the case? Also curious if this is generally true...would you get the same result if they were asked to identify Belgium on a map?

Scientific studies suggest men generally have a better sense of direction than women, and use that sense of direction more effectively. Kind of makes you wonder where the "fails to ask for directions" trope comes from! :) https://blog.education.nationalgeographic.org/2015/12/10/do-...

Re: Can You Locate Iran? Few Voters Can

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is it not interesting because of the lack of novelty, or not interesting because you think it's acceptable to want to kill someone but not to actually know much about them?

I don't think being able to accurately tell where Iran is is a requirement for wanting to kill someone from there, no. Knowing approximately where it is is useful, but what does it really matter if you confuse it with the next country over?

If one lacks the knowledge to even identify another nation on the global map, you have to wonder if this person actually has strong, sound judgement (when they speak in favor of dropping bombs) or if they’re easily malleable partisans.

Re: Can You Locate Iran? Few Voters Can

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is it not interesting because of the lack of novelty, or not interesting because you think it's acceptable to want to kill someone but not to actually know much about them?

I don't think being able to accurately tell where Iran is is a requirement for wanting to kill someone from there, no. Knowing approximately where it is is useful, but what does it really matter if you confuse it with the next country over?

It means that you have been wholesale influenced rather than informed about the conflict that politicians are peddling to you, as you don't have a grasp on the most basic facts of the matter. We're talking of civilian support for acts of war here.

Specially since an actual war with the people of that polity is an obvious outcome.

Re: Can You Locate Iran? Few Voters Can

#38
post #35
post #27

"Men were about twice as likely as women to be able to identify Iran on both maps" Wow, that's unexpected. Is there some credible source on why this is the case? Also curious if this is generally true...would you get the same result if they were asked to identify Belgium on a map?

Scientific studies suggest men generally have a better sense of direction than women, and use that sense of direction more effectively. Kind of makes you wonder where the "fails to ask for directions" trope comes from! :) https://blog.education.nationalgeographic.org/2015/12/10/do-...

And yes - I know it didn't PROVE men have a better sense, it suggests that based on the effects of hormones administered to women.

Re: Can You Locate Iran? Few Voters Can

#39

Not at all surprising. Sad, but not surprising. How many voters know who the Secretary of State is? How many voters know who their local congress critter is? I guarantee the numbers are similarly dismal.

It's pretty typical for the kind of answers you get from polling people walking around the mall in the middle of a weekday.

Re: Can You Locate Iran? Few Voters Can

#40
post #9

47% supported the strike? How could they possibly have had enough information to support it? Iran = Bad Man from Iran = Bad Kill Man from Iran = Good???

> How could they possibly have had enough information to support it?

That is true for just about any political question. The consequences are usually so complex that the average citizen can't possibly be informed well enough on the matter. Just look at what happened with brexit...

Mandatory political disclaimer: I'm not saying democracy is wrong, and I wouldn't know how to solve this problem either.

Post reply on HN