Live data from Hacker News

Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

reuters.com

461–470 of 637 posts

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#461

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"The NYT didn’t have to be right, they only had to sell newspapers and clicks." This is totally wrong. The New York Times depends on its reputation for accuracy.

If they are wrong, their reputation won't suffer that much. They can just say, "We based our story on the best information available to us as outsiders." Which, to me at least, is a perfectly legitimate thing for a newspaper to do. Yes, they should check facts and vet sources, but their primary responsibility is to do the best they can and get the information out there for the public.

It's pretty clear that Boeing's leadership could have had better info than the NYT, yet they either didn't, or they ignored/hid what they knew.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#463
post #260

Most business in the United States is done despite of management, not because of it. The executives lie and BS through all of it, and the soldiers on the ground kill themselves to get things done.

I've lately been reading about the notion of "managerialism". The book Confronting Managerialism defines it as "What occurs when a special group, called management, ensconces itself systemically in an organization and deprives owners and employees of their decision-making power (including distribution of emoluments) and justifies that takeover on the grounds of the managing group's education and exclusive possession…

> At least once, I want work at a place that really has its shit together.

I'm old enough now that I just skip directly to wishing for powerball numbers.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#464

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've lately been reading about the notion of "managerialism". The book Confronting Managerialism defines it as "What occurs when a special group, called management, ensconces itself systemically in an organization and deprives owners and employees of their decision-making power (including distribution of emoluments) and justifies that takeover on the grounds of the managing group's education and exclusive possession…

I think the problem is both broader and simpler. There's an economic term for it, but i don't recall what it is. Basically, the whole of capitalism depends on the idea that individual incentives (for employees) can be aligned with organizational goals. Often, however, employees realize they can make more money by putting their efforts into getting a bigger slice of the pie instead of working to make the pie bigger. T…

> the whole of capitalism depends on the idea that individual incentives (for employees) can be aligned with organizational goals

And here I was thinking it relied on the capital-owners having the state use its centralized coercive power (like the police and the military) to enforce the capital-owners' property rights. Silly me.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#465

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be honest, I don't know. It's hard to compare for the US domestic flights, since you have to decide on comparable routes. That said, flights throughout Asia at distances similar to US domestic flights tend to be reasonably cheap. I decided to make a comparison: Fly Singapore Airlines from Singapore to Hong Kong. This will cost you 225 USD in economy. A domestic US flight of the same distance would be San Francisco…

Albuquerque isn't a major destination though. Flying to provincial cities is always expensive. A better comparison with about the same distance in the US is New York to Miami, which can be done nonstop for under $200 on Delta, or $135 on whatever "Frontier" is. EDIT: In fact you can go from New York to Las Vegas for under $200, round-trip, which is considerably farther.

yeah, but then you'd be Las Vegas.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#466
post #459

The only credible way from here is to: - remove the hack that is MCAS for the purpose of being able to piggyback on the old 737 type certificate; - start the process of type-certifying 737-MAX as the individual design that it is without MCAS instead of trying to make it behave like the old 737 just to keep things on the cheap side; - and offer free type certification for existing 737 pilots to obtain their certificat…

Wait, Boeing were actually trying to do something _different_ than this?

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#467
post #459

The only credible way from here is to: - remove the hack that is MCAS for the purpose of being able to piggyback on the old 737 type certificate; - start the process of type-certifying 737-MAX as the individual design that it is without MCAS instead of trying to make it behave like the old 737 just to keep things on the cheap side; - and offer free type certification for existing 737 pilots to obtain their certificat…

> start the process of type-certifying 737-MAX as the individual design that it is without MCAS

Do you know that it would be impossible to fly without MCAS (or something very similar)?

They (B engineers) made MCAS not only for max to look like NG, but for compensate for very serious additional momentum due to engines moving forward

There would be big piece of software to watch for pitch and stall and react accordingly, no matter how you call it

"Pilots who flew Boeing 737 MAX planes registered complaints about the aircraft suddenly pitching downwards last year. ... eerily echoing reports from American pilots who complained of problems with the plane late last year."

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#468

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The NYT didn’t have to be right, they only had to sell newspapers and clicks. The burden of evidence for publishing a hit piece is much lower than that for making an actual business decision. I’m no fan of Boeing but the truth is, betting your entire business requires a much higher burden of proof than journalism does.

"The NYT didn’t have to be right, they only had to sell newspapers and clicks." This is totally wrong. The New York Times depends on its reputation for accuracy.

That seems backwards, I would think they would depend on accuracy for its reputation.

Their record of accuracy has suffered quite a bit in the past few years.

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#469

The big question for Boeing is how they will transition to a post-737 world. Until now, Boeing's business plan is that they will be building a starship for NASA in 2060, but you will still be stuck with a 737 on Southwest Airlines, a A320 on Jetblue, and never know that aviation could be better. The 737 throws off a lot of cash, but the single-aisle monoculture makes flying miserable. A 737 replacement will be expens…

I can relate to your point about a new aircraft design to replace 737, but can you explain why single-aisle is so bad? I mean, are you saying the seating to be 2-1-2 instead of 3-3? Or wider short-range aircraft with 2-2-2 or 2-3-2 ? Elaboration please...

Re: Boeing CEO ousted as 737 Max crisis deepens

#470
post #117

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're probably trolling but just in case - their planes not killing passengers is somewhat more important to society than the diversity of their hiring practices.

The point was moving their production out of an area controlled by corrupt whites allowed them to create a more inclusive workforce. The unfortunate tragedies due to poor pilot training in the developing world are orthogonal.

Please don't troll, and please stop posting flamebait and/or unsubstantive comments. None of that is cool here.

You've done it so much that we would normally ban an account like this, but https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21852176 is a good comment. Please use HN for intellectual curiosity like that.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Post reply on HN