Live data from Hacker News

Elementary OS 5.1 Hera

blog.elementary.io

31–40 of 193 posts

Re: Elementary OS 5.1 Hera

#31
post #12

Every workstation in my office runs Elementary. Around half of our employees came to the company with little or no prior technical experience, and it's worked out pretty well.

Just last week I wrote a blog post about installing eOS on my SO's parents PC. They are not technical at all yet they have had (close to) no problem with switching from Windows to Linux thanks to eOS.

Re: Elementary OS 5.1 Hera

#32

Serious question time. What benefit will I get from running something like Elementary over Ubuntu? Forgive my ignorance, but honestly the whole OS looks like it's just a fork of Ubuntu with a couple of swapped in applications, and a GTK3 theme on top of GNOME trying to make it look like a ten year old version of macOS. I hate to be so negative, but the "new greeter" they are showing looks like something from Windows…

It’s nicer to use.

Which parts are nicer? What makes them nicer?

Re: Elementary OS 5.1 Hera

#33

Serious question time. What benefit will I get from running something like Elementary over Ubuntu? Forgive my ignorance, but honestly the whole OS looks like it's just a fork of Ubuntu with a couple of swapped in applications, and a GTK3 theme on top of GNOME trying to make it look like a ten year old version of macOS. I hate to be so negative, but the "new greeter" they are showing looks like something from Windows…

The majority of Linux distros are just forks of other major distros with swapped apps/DEs, so no need to expect magic.

Elementary definitely has a nicer software center UI and I personally love their terminal application more than others (even though I currently use Kubuntu). Many people like it because it reminds them of macOS, even though you don't.

And you're kind of right about GTK, but elementaryOS uses the Pantheon desktop environment built on top of GTK.

Elementary has the most gorgeous look for my taste.

Re: Elementary OS 5.1 Hera

#35
post #28
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you hope so? Vala is a decent language which let's users build Gtk applications easily.

Because most people aren't going to learn yet another language for the privilege of being able to contribute to something.

If you are going to contribute to a Linux Desktop Environment, you are not the target audience for Elementary.

Elementary wants to be “the Apple of Linux”, to attract less-technical users and switchers from other OSes. Their development philosophy is similarly top-down: someone sets a “vision” and a small group of people gets to implement it. If you are a coder and you value bottom-up development, you should really look elsewhere.

Re: Elementary OS 5.1 Hera

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s nicer to use.

Which parts are nicer? What makes them nicer?

Every single bit of the desktop is nicer than stock GNOME. Preferences, the terminal, the dock, window decorations, you name it. It’s just visually polished and _consistent_ to a degree I haven’t found in any other distro yet.

Re: Elementary OS 5.1 Hera

#38

Serious question time. What benefit will I get from running something like Elementary over Ubuntu? Forgive my ignorance, but honestly the whole OS looks like it's just a fork of Ubuntu with a couple of swapped in applications, and a GTK3 theme on top of GNOME trying to make it look like a ten year old version of macOS. I hate to be so negative, but the "new greeter" they are showing looks like something from Windows…

Appreciate their work but that greeter UI looks awful. Onboarding screens look well designed though.

Re: Elementary OS 5.1 Hera

#39

I think Elementary should have focused on just shipping Pantheon as their end product. GNOME has had issues not only in the performance department, but it's also a very different type of minimalism for a DE that's supposed to be the mainstream pick for normal users. Elementary has adopted a far more conventional DE that feels as simple as GNOME, but far more usable. But I'm never going to use Elementary over Ubuntu o…

It’s essentially Ubuntu LTS (I run and install exactly the same packages and PPAs as bionic), so you might want to sign up now :)

Re: Elementary OS 5.1 Hera

#40

Serious question time. What benefit will I get from running something like Elementary over Ubuntu? Forgive my ignorance, but honestly the whole OS looks like it's just a fork of Ubuntu with a couple of swapped in applications, and a GTK3 theme on top of GNOME trying to make it look like a ten year old version of macOS. I hate to be so negative, but the "new greeter" they are showing looks like something from Windows…

You said it, the biggest difference is in the UI and UX, and while you do not like it, many do.

Like explaining to people who dislike veggie why veggie is delicious, it's difficult to explain why you like things to people who don't share the same view for something so subjective.

Post reply on HN