Live data from Hacker News

USS Pueblo

en.wikipedia.org

31–40 of 118 posts

Re: USS Pueblo

#31
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've seen this come up a lot recently. Antisemitic, alt-right grifters have been using this incident as some sort of dogwhistle

Dogwhistle for what? I'm genuinely curious, I don't know what that could be used as a dogwhistle for.

It was attacked by the Israelis, so it's used as a cause celebre by people who want to get people to question our support of Israel. This includes, but is not limited to, antisemites.

Re: USS Pueblo

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The boat? Not much. It’s the act that offers value. The value of invading another sovereign nation's territory in order to repatriate some hunk object that has purely symbolic value? Hardly seems worth the cost and massive fallout that would ensure.

you mean the boat that was illegally seized during the cold war, and still is illegally held?

We're talking about two countries that are still technically at war with each other, at the peak of cold war when such niceties as "legality" didn't stop anyone. "Illegal" is meaningless here.

Re: USS Pueblo

#33
post #7

A foolhardy idea would be to surreptitiously go there while some other action is happening elsewhere and tug it out. Now, it’d be difficult to pull off and offers no upside and lots of downside, but it’d be very intrepid to pull off.

I was thinking similarly, but a bit more destructive - it would be an interesting exercise to plan a fire mission that would scuttle the ship to retire it from active service while not damaging the museum around it.

Always interesting to be reminded of all of these incidents from past operations.

Re: USS Pueblo

#34
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The boat? Not much. It’s the act that offers value. The value of invading another sovereign nation's territory in order to repatriate some hunk object that has purely symbolic value? Hardly seems worth the cost and massive fallout that would ensure.

First it’s not an invasion, it’s an incursion. Like I said upthread, it’s got lots of downside but little upside. But the upside would be quite triumphant.

> First it’s not an invasion, it’s an incursion.

This is a really weird hair to try to split, given that the two words are essentially synonymous.

> When an army crosses a border into another country for battle, they are making an incursion into enemy territory. An incursion is an invasion as well as an attack.[0]

> [An incursion is] An aggressive movement into somewhere; an invasion[1]

> Invasion is a synonym for incursion in attack topic.[2]

...and so forth.

[0] https://www.vocabulary.com/dictionary/incursion

[1] https://wikidiff.com/invasion/incursion

[2] https://thesaurus.plus/related/incursion/invasion

Re: USS Pueblo

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's a school called the Pyongyang University of Science and Technology ( https://pust.co ) that invites foreigners to come teach North Korean citizens. I spent 2 semesters teaching computer science at PUST and it was a wonderful experience. You really get to know the locals (both students and staff) much better than on a short tourist trip. Some highlights include teaching Dijkstra's algorithm by showing them goo…

> All the students I met with were surprisingly well informed about both events in the US and American history. This is surprising to me. I imagine they read some news/propaganda about the events, rather than reading the NYTimes, WAPO, or BBC news directly. Can you comment on that? > As a former naval nuclear officer Did you have to get special approval?

> This is surprising to me. I imagine they read some news/propaganda about the events, rather than reading the NYTimes, WAPO, or BBC news directly. Can you comment on that?

Their history lessons certainly have a different emphasis than American history lessons. They emphasize things like slavery in the US and the CIA's interventions in Latin America in service of US businesses, but from all my conversations with students none of them had learned anything that was actually incorrect. They get their news mainly from government run newspapers, but also word of mouth spreads news pretty quickly.

> Did you have to get special approval?

It had been long enough since my time in service that non of my clearances were still valid, and so there was no special risk of me disclosing anything. I just contacted the American embassy in China and informed them of my plans.

Re: USS Pueblo

#36
post #7

A foolhardy idea would be to surreptitiously go there while some other action is happening elsewhere and tug it out. Now, it’d be difficult to pull off and offers no upside and lots of downside, but it’d be very intrepid to pull off.

This is a thing that happens, actually! Just not with naval vessels...

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/nov/14/max-hardberger...

Re: USS Pueblo

#37
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How were you able to visit it, honest question? As an American myself, I wouldn't dare set foot in that country. Was a visit there an easy experience? Would you go back?

I went when Americans were still allowed to go, with Koryo Tours, who I'd recommend strongly. As the only way to get in is with a tour agency, it's actually a very easy trip to arrange. All you have to do is get to Beijing, the agency takes care of the rest. That said, I wouldn't call it an easy destination while you're there, depending on your personality type. You have no freedom of movement, are pretty transparent…

Great feedback ! From your first sentence, i assume you are american ? Would you recommend it to non americans that wish to enter us soil within the decade ?

Re: USS Pueblo

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You visited North Korea?

Based on their spelling of “armoury” they don’t seem to be American. As far as I’m aware, the only country that forbids travel to NK is America.

I imagine the DPRK classifies all Americans and Europeans as simply "Western imperialist dogs", or something like that. The last thing I'd be worried about when planning a trip to Pyongyang is whether the US is cool with it. I would go to nearly any other country than go to North Korea. Just doesn't seem worth it. Wouldn't feel right putting my tourist $$$ directly in the pocket of the fascist Kim regime, for that.

Re: USS Pueblo

#39
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How were you able to visit it, honest question? As an American myself, I wouldn't dare set foot in that country. Was a visit there an easy experience? Would you go back?

I went when Americans were still allowed to go, with Koryo Tours, who I'd recommend strongly. As the only way to get in is with a tour agency, it's actually a very easy trip to arrange. All you have to do is get to Beijing, the agency takes care of the rest. That said, I wouldn't call it an easy destination while you're there, depending on your personality type. You have no freedom of movement, are pretty transparent…

>if you can imagine yourself acting similarly dumb, don't go.

Funny, all the people I know that do dumb things can't imagine themselves acting dumb.

Post reply on HN