Live data from Hacker News

Facebook says a bug caused its iPhone app’s inadvertent camera access

techcrunch.com

71–80 of 143 posts

Re: Facebook says a bug caused its iPhone app’s inadvertent camera access

#71
post #11

> Facebook vice president of integrity Guy Rosen The same Guy Rosen who was the CEO of Onvao - the infamous data grab app that Facebook purchased.... yeah, that integrity guy...

Well you can have integrity in form of being consistently evil doer. Hitler showed some integrity with his treatment of jews/slavs/dissent. Facebook has consistently shown integrity when it comes to spying on users, lying to everybody, and generally being a douchebag of a company

Re: Facebook says a bug caused its iPhone app’s inadvertent camera access

#72
post #61
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nothing is preventing you from putting a sticker over your webcam, just like Zuck does.

Or I can close my eyes and imagine that nothing happened Result will be the same Stickers do not work - because people around you do not put it too magically And what even sillier - that someone have phone with installed fb app in 2k19

> stickers do not work.

lulwut?

Re: Facebook says a bug caused its iPhone app’s inadvertent camera access

#73
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or I can close my eyes and imagine that nothing happened Result will be the same Stickers do not work - because people around you do not put it too magically And what even sillier - that someone have phone with installed fb app in 2k19

>Stickers do not work They do though.

They do if everyone put it

Do everyone put it?

Re: Facebook says a bug caused its iPhone app’s inadvertent camera access

#74
post #69
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So we, filthy plebs, have low value and because of that we have to share our data for free Nice

This is an intentional misreading of the parent comment and does not belong on this forum. Zuck being a high value target for extortion/exploitation/attack is an objective fact. Saying so doesn't imply that anyone else is "low value" - attackers will attack whoever and whatever they can to achieve their goal, which is almost always money.

If it is misleading then first priority of fb is defending privacy and user data at all costs.

Everyone, not just one person

Nice

Re: Facebook says a bug caused its iPhone app’s inadvertent camera access

#77
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They do if everyone put it Do everyone put it?

No one else has a computer in my bedroom

So your neighbors with hires full spectrum light camera pointed at your windows does not count

Mhhh, okay

Re: Facebook says a bug caused its iPhone app’s inadvertent camera access

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> They appear to be doing this in collaboration with Apple as the battery usage for the camera does not increase despite the camera constantly being initiated while using the Facebook app. I’m sure any battery usage from this would just be listed under Facebook.

Right, battery usage is reported by app not by hardware function. It seems unlikely Apple would be willfully letting Facebook have special capabilities.

Not too long ago, the idea of the NSA & GCHQ working together to silently strong-arm tech giants to spy on their own citizens/customers was a laughable conspiracy theory.

Then we learned about PRISM. Hard proof that Apple, Facebook, Google, and the NSA secretly collaborate to mass-collect data on US citizens. It's 100% reasonable (and perhaps in our best interest) to assume any large tech company will and does cater to the NSA/CIA/GCHQ/Mossad's interests before their customers' - or even their shareholders'. Revenue and market share are important, but a powerful agency threatening your company takes priority over anything.

Until proven innocent, we should assume that any and every large tech-centric corporation either has been or can be forced to cooperate with PRISM. IMHO now that the public has access to the Snowden leaks and Vault 7, it is irresponsible (and perhaps dangerous) to think otherwise.

Re: Facebook says a bug caused its iPhone app’s inadvertent camera access

#79
post #34
post #3

Good time to remind that Facebook has previously intentionally bypassed permission dialogs to gather data without user permission: https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/5433555/Note-by-C...

Also nice reminder about that lovely photo of Zuck with a sticker covering up his webcam. Now why would he do something like that ... ?

Those persons stupid enough to leave a webcam uncovered when not in use deserve the consequences of their actions.

Those who leave a microphone operational when not in use also deserve the consequences of their actions.

Stupid people reap stupid rewards.

Re: Facebook says a bug caused its iPhone app’s inadvertent camera access

#80
post #3

Good time to remind that Facebook has previously intentionally bypassed permission dialogs to gather data without user permission: https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/5433555/Note-by-C...

> Good time to remind that Facebook has previously intentionally bypassed permission dialogs to gather data without user permission:

I wonder if the camera app leaves some by-product that the Facebook app can exploit to derive some data that the user would not usually give to FB.

Perhaps it initializes the GPS without being prompted (as camera uses it for geotagging). Or maybe it checks for the time required to enable the camera, comparing with previous attempts in a kind of A/B test, so it can know if the camera was being used for another app?

Post reply on HN