Live data from Hacker News

Mysterious Avid Issue Knocks Out Mac Pro Workstations Across Hollywood

variety.com

71–80 of 213 posts

Re: Mysterious Avid Issue Knocks Out Mac Pro Workstations Across Hollywood

#71

rule 1 of hollywood tech support: Always take what the editor says with a massive pinch of salt. I spent ten years in the movie industry, and the people that were the most forthright, and almost universally wrong about technical things were editors. "The monitor is out of grade" No, you've set the background lights to red. "The sound is out of sync" No, you've turned off the amp and somehow managed to get the crappy…

[deleted]

Re: Mysterious Avid Issue Knocks Out Mac Pro Workstations Across Hollywood

#72
post #2

yikes. having written aax plugins for a while, i have to say, i’m kind of surprised this came from AVID. from what it sounds like (having scraped the surface), it’s not their editing software (Pro Tools, et al.) but their copy protection management tool/device driver - iLok. i’m sure there are some very anxious engineers in the AVID offices today.

> their copy protection management tool/device driver - iLok. They're still using that? These things were successfully cracked in the nineties, I was convinced nobody uses hardware dongles anymore.

Actually the current generation of iLok hasn't been cracked yet (and from what I've heard it's unlikely that it ever will be).

There was a time a few years ago when the wrapper got cracked but as far as I know the security itself is still strong.

Re: Mysterious Avid Issue Knocks Out Mac Pro Workstations Across Hollywood

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> their copy protection management tool/device driver - iLok. They're still using that? These things were successfully cracked in the nineties, I was convinced nobody uses hardware dongles anymore.

Steinberg Cubase uses these aswell

Cubase uses eLicenser, not iLok, and it hasn't been cracked since a version about 10+ years ago so it does a pretty good job - even if that does mean cubase has fallen in popularity.

Re: Mysterious Avid Issue Knocks Out Mac Pro Workstations Across Hollywood

#74
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> their copy protection management tool/device driver - iLok. They're still using that? These things were successfully cracked in the nineties, I was convinced nobody uses hardware dongles anymore.

The new Mac Pro tower has an internal USB-A port, explicitly for this reason [1]. 1: https://appleinsider.com/articles/19/06/04/apples-new-mac-pr...

I look at what the industry has allowed itself become and cringe.

Re: Mysterious Avid Issue Knocks Out Mac Pro Workstations Across Hollywood

#75

rule 1 of hollywood tech support: Always take what the editor says with a massive pinch of salt. I spent ten years in the movie industry, and the people that were the most forthright, and almost universally wrong about technical things were editors. "The monitor is out of grade" No, you've set the background lights to red. "The sound is out of sync" No, you've turned off the amp and somehow managed to get the crappy…

[deleted]

Re: Mysterious Avid Issue Knocks Out Mac Pro Workstations Across Hollywood

#76

I switched to Adobe Premiere under Windows 10 with NVIDA 2080 for accelerated rendering and have been very satisfied.

It's really warming to me that Avid and Premiere, two applications I learned video editing on at school when I was 10, are still big things today.

Re: Mysterious Avid Issue Knocks Out Mac Pro Workstations Across Hollywood

#77
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That must really be annoying someone over at apple. Spend all that time design something beautiful. And... Everyone calls it garbage

We also call them "trashcans" in conversation. It's an identifiable and memorable term, rather than "mac pro (original/2006)", "mac pro (cylinder/2013)" or "mac pro (cheese grater/2019)"

Cheese grater will definitely stick just like trashcan. Both highly utilitarian tools, mind you.

Re: Mysterious Avid Issue Knocks Out Mac Pro Workstations Across Hollywood

#78
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd revise that to the far more irritating segment of users who think they're more technical than they really are. Actual non technical users are fine, because they generally know when they don't understand a thing. The thinks-their-technical users will bravely throw in whatever phrases they've heard mentioned in relation to a completely unrelated problem.

What, will you refuse to help me if I call you in deep distress and said that "xcode command line tools is failing to update because of the nginx 503 errors clearly visible in Safari"

Yes

Re: Mysterious Avid Issue Knocks Out Mac Pro Workstations Across Hollywood

#79
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

i, as an app developer, have to reboot my mac atleast two times the week to get xcode back into a working state. not to sound like a jerk, but if you dont have to powercycle you prob not pushing your machine far enough

Or running stable software that locks up less? Maybe Xcode is just badly written?

any sufficiently complicated software can reach a state where problems arise. you just need to push it far enough.

e.g. i have the swift compiler giving up every few weeks because i feed it code that crashes its internal constrain-solver. good thing is, submitting such code samples i can contribute to its improvement. i believe everyone has a tale of some software exhibiting strange behaviour, ive seen it all: adobe products crashing when you exit them, broken text rendering in firefox until a restart, hell, i even had the windows' LogonUI.exe hang on me.

the point is: consider a software to be a state machine. since we stopped formally verifying correctness of our programs, it is in the realm of possible for each program to reach a state where its behaviour is undesired and there is no easy path to move it to a more stable state.

Re: Mysterious Avid Issue Knocks Out Mac Pro Workstations Across Hollywood

#80
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Beautiful? There's a reason why it got the name, it looks like a trashcan. And the old mac pro is filled with garbage(how fitting, right?). If it was any good then apple would have stuck to it, but it was garbage, so they didn't. Now we have the new mac pro, and it's a big step up from the trashcan.

Yes, and lots of very smart designers have put lots of time over many decades into making trashcans look good. The apple trashcan certainly looks vastly better than other commercially available workstations.

> The apple trashcan certainly looks vastly better than other commercially available workstations.

Not really, when given the tendency of them to roll around when being transported in production environments, they tend to end up bolted within wooden boxes with little wheels on the bottom.

There's a reason Apple listened and put wheels on the new one.

Post reply on HN