Live data from Hacker News

Why I'm not buying Facebook

finance.fortune.cnn.com

41–50 of 106 posts

Re: Why I'm not buying Facebook

#41

I remember how excited average investors were at the prospect of a new way of going public when Google announced its innovative auction IPO. "Finally, Wall Street banks wouldn't be able to crowd to the front of the line!" Their public auction, their "don't be evil", and their continued use of their power for good -- like their trick to get openness principles adopted during the wireless spectrum auction -- all exempl…

The behavior and culture of a company is often a direct reflection of the character of the people who founded it. Unfortunately, very few 24 year olds are mature enough to handle the responsibility and decisions that come with a large corporation - even though the corporation may be successful, other problems become evident. Take Etsy, for instance, another company founded by a 24 year old. While they have been succe…

Don't forget Microsoft. If you weren't convinced already, Breaking Windows makes it fairly clear that the company was a projection of Bill Gates.

Re: Why I'm not buying Facebook

#42
post #11

One reason why I'm not buying Facebook: I don't have $2mil lying around. Another one; Why is Mark so reticent to IPO? Because he loses control? Or because that means making the numbers public, and people will see just where the money is going. Either way, if the CEO doesn't want to go public and may be forced to, that is not good.

He's said (maybe at Davos?) that the main reason is because Facebook has a lot of stuff they want to launch that is high risk and might not be acceptable to see come from a public company. (For example, could you imagine what would have happened the stock when Beacon came out?)

Re: Why I'm not buying Facebook

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The behavior and culture of a company is often a direct reflection of the character of the people who founded it. Unfortunately, very few 24 year olds are mature enough to handle the responsibility and decisions that come with a large corporation - even though the corporation may be successful, other problems become evident. Take Etsy, for instance, another company founded by a 24 year old. While they have been succe…

Do elaborate. I know a handful of people at Etsy and they all seem pleased to be there.

They treat their employees quite well, for the most part. It's the customers who suffer from this.

Re: Why I'm not buying Facebook

#44
post #37

"And any advertiser who is trying to target me on the social network is wasting their money." He ruined a perfectly objective point with this subjective generalization. That being said, I'm with him for on most points, and I agree on the bigger picture.

The future of Facebook is not targeting you on 'a social network', its opening up an ad-sense competitor and targeting you on any website - with your personal information. The like and connect buttons are just the first step.

With that in mind it sounds like a good deal to me.

Re: Why I'm not buying Facebook

#45
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The behavior and culture of a company is often a direct reflection of the character of the people who founded it. Unfortunately, very few 24 year olds are mature enough to handle the responsibility and decisions that come with a large corporation - even though the corporation may be successful, other problems become evident. Take Etsy, for instance, another company founded by a 24 year old. While they have been succe…

Can you explain further about Etsy? Is this documented somewhere?

There is plenty of discontent documented on the web, in blogs, on Etsy's forums (which are difficult to penetrate, since the search and navigation features are poor), on the forums of other marketplace sites, on Twitter, and so on.

They have a knack for turning away people who should be their biggest supporters. I can think of many successful shop owners have left after 2-3 years, disappointed by the way the site is administrated.

Re: Why I'm not buying Facebook

#46
The only people what can make money on Facebook stock, is Chinese government officials. All they need to do, is to accumulate $FCBK stock and then allow Facebook.com to be used in China. Number of Facebook users will jump from 0.5B to 1.5B, same with the valuation from $50B to $150B ;)

Re: Why I'm not buying Facebook

#47
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The behavior and culture of a company is often a direct reflection of the character of the people who founded it. Unfortunately, very few 24 year olds are mature enough to handle the responsibility and decisions that come with a large corporation - even though the corporation may be successful, other problems become evident. Take Etsy, for instance, another company founded by a 24 year old. While they have been succe…

Don't forget Microsoft. If you weren't convinced already, Breaking Windows makes it fairly clear that the company was a projection of Bill Gates.

I've always figured it was, and consequently I've never really hated Microsoft. I've always been impressed with what they managed, and by extension impressed by the man. It probably helps that I didn't personally suffer the worst of their marauding.

Re: Why I'm not buying Facebook

#48
post #11

One reason why I'm not buying Facebook: I don't have $2mil lying around. Another one; Why is Mark so reticent to IPO? Because he loses control? Or because that means making the numbers public, and people will see just where the money is going. Either way, if the CEO doesn't want to go public and may be forced to, that is not good.

He's only ever really had to answer to himself, right? From what I know of him, he probably likes that a lot more than having to answer to a bunch of shareholders.

Re: Why I'm not buying Facebook

#49

The only people what can make money on Facebook stock, is Chinese government officials. All they need to do, is to accumulate $FCBK stock and then allow Facebook.com to be used in China. Number of Facebook users will jump from 0.5B to 1.5B, same with the valuation from $50B to $150B ;)

They could do it twice. Buy before unblocking it and then short before blocking it again.

Re: Why I'm not buying Facebook

#50

Facebook has... twice myspace's revenue. Just let that sink in for a while.

Wait... is that good or bad?

It's troublesome if you want to invest in facebook. Facebook has 10x as many users as myspace, and they've translated that into a great deal of hype. But they've yet to translate it into sizable revenue, let alone into profit.
Post reply on HN