Live data from Hacker News

Cement Produces More Pollution Than All the Trucks in the World

bloomberg.com

211–220 of 249 posts

Re: Cement Produces More Pollution Than All the Trucks in the World

#211
post #199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

CO2 is pollution.

Could you please not post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News?

The article specifically refers to carbon dioxide as pollution, which was disagreed with by the parent poster. Carbon dioxide is semantically referred to both as pollution and non-pollution, and I was pointing out the contrast.

Your comment, on the other hand, is purely non-substantive.

Re: Cement Produces More Pollution Than All the Trucks in the World

#212

One good thing the US and Canada does is to not use cement for houses ! It is somewhat negated by the terrible insulation in most homes in the US (and the fact that homes tend to last less long I guess). Does anyone have any data on how much gets emitted for house construction depending on the material ?

It is not applicable to many places in the world where there is no such an abandon of land space and wood supply. The American suburbia has its own environmental impact which might offset any benefit comparing to more congested tall buildings areas.

Re: Cement Produces More Pollution Than All the Trucks in the World

#213
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fundamentally, there is very little you can change on an individual basis that will make a real difference. By all means, lead by example, but we have to support systemic changes at all levels of government to actually make any head way here.

If everyone thinks like this nothing will change. You can do both. Campaign for political change and change your personal behaviour. I've done radical changes to my life at least last few years to reduce my pollution/co2 footprint and if more people think like this it _will_ help. So saying that there is nothing that can be done on the individual level is quite dangerous as I personally think over time this will have…

On the other hand, if a small percentage of concerned citizens do everything they personally can without changing the political climate, nothing will change.

In Ontario (Canada) we elected a conservative government who is running advertisements against the Federal Carbon Tax saying:

> “Ontario has a better way: holding the biggest polluters accountable; reducing trash; and keeping our lakes clean. A carbon tax isn’t the only way to fight climate change.”

My government thinks reducing trash and lake runoff is fighting climate change. Everything I've personally done; switching to public transit, flying less and buying my electricity from a green supplier has been swamped by this huge step backward at the political level.

Re: Cement Produces More Pollution Than All the Trucks in the World

#214
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If everyone thinks like this nothing will change. You can do both. Campaign for political change and change your personal behaviour. I've done radical changes to my life at least last few years to reduce my pollution/co2 footprint and if more people think like this it _will_ help. So saying that there is nothing that can be done on the individual level is quite dangerous as I personally think over time this will have…

On the other hand, if a small percentage of concerned citizens do everything they personally can without changing the political climate, nothing will change. In Ontario (Canada) we elected a conservative government who is running advertisements against the Federal Carbon Tax saying: > “Ontario has a better way: holding the biggest polluters accountable; reducing trash; and keeping our lakes clean. A carbon tax isn’t…

The politicians definitely have to be on board in the end but when you say your efforts are swamped, remember that it is not just you, there are millions of us changing our behaviour and trying to reduce the carbon footprint.

Together we actually make a difference. Personally I also try to encourage friends and family in a non pushy way to attempt some of the things I do. Many respond positively, especially considering other benefits like eating more healthy and walking more.

Re: Cement Produces More Pollution Than All the Trucks in the World

#215
post #208
post #205

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> https://bigthink.com/strange-maps/what-the-world-will-look-l... . I could not see any graphics/media (the website is a mess. It tries to load a dozen 3rd party resources). But the article is pretty optimistic: > Now is the time to buy property in Greenland – before it too turns green... > Yeah sure, we can't individually give up on our beef sandwich I'm sure there will be cities in these new deserts. And people in…

I used this one: https://www3.epa.gov/carbon-footprint-calculator/

I found one with metric measurements. I consume about 12 tons Co2 per year. Is a little more than average (12 hours flight this year).

Re: Cement Produces More Pollution Than All the Trucks in the World

#216
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fundamentally, there is very little you can change on an individual basis that will make a real difference. By all means, lead by example, but we have to support systemic changes at all levels of government to actually make any head way here.

If everyone thinks like this nothing will change. You can do both. Campaign for political change and change your personal behaviour. I've done radical changes to my life at least last few years to reduce my pollution/co2 footprint and if more people think like this it _will_ help. So saying that there is nothing that can be done on the individual level is quite dangerous as I personally think over time this will have…

It would be good to have a system in place to reward measurable action on the individual level.

One example might be to institute a "carbon savings account" which individuals add to when they add solar panels, buy more efficient vehicles and appliances, reduce their heating bills... whatever's measureable. Mandatory restrictions on carbon-intensive activity (there's no way around that anyway) would enable spending these rewards.

Re: Cement Produces More Pollution Than All the Trucks in the World

#218
post #15
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The list you provide is missing some man made sources of CO2 and methane. It's just CO2 emissions from fuel combustion. Meat production is almost as much as transportation, roughly 17%.

Though all meat production is not made equal; beef production is overwhelmingly more emissive per serving (6.61 lbs of CO2 per 4 oz) than pork (1.72 lbs) or poultry (1.26). Even without giving up eating meat, substituting most of your beef meals for chicken would still be a step in the right direction (and is essentially zero-cost, considering that this requires no significant lifestyle changes and anywhere that sell…

This might have ethical implications considering how much worse chicken lives are than cows lives and how many more chickens you need to kill per calorie.

Re: Cement Produces More Pollution Than All the Trucks in the World

#219
Mass timber (also sometimes referred to as CLT) has the potential to replace cement for the construction of many types of buildings.

Mass timber has an extra benefit too: since trees scrub CO2 from the atmosphere, growing trees for construction ends up sequestering significant amounts of CO2.

There's a lot of work to be done around sustainable forestry practices, along with the process of actually harvesting the associated wood, but I think this is a pretty cool option.

Here's an article that provides some context on mass timber, along with some of the outstanding questions: https://e360.yale.edu/features/as-mass-timber-takes-off-how-...

Re: Cement Produces More Pollution Than All the Trucks in the World

#220

One alternative to traditional concrete is autoclaved aerated concrete[1], a 70 year old material that's more eco friendly. Some of the advantages are mentioned in this video[2]. I'm guessing higher upfront cost means it's not competitive with traditional concrete. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autoclaved_aerated_concrete [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FS3BTDBMt7I

>alternative to traditional concrete

Related:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18487704

About the earthship I mentioned in that comment, which was made using non-traditional materials and techniques: I don't remember what materials were used, except that, IIRC, the creator said it was not cob. Mud was used, of course, that was clear from looking at it. So was glass for the windows. I mean the other materials - not sure about those. But it looked sturdy, and was huge.

Post reply on HN